Skip to content
CityLab
Justice

What It Takes to Preserve a Building Tied to Black History

A former abolitionists’ home in Brooklyn with ties to the Underground Railroad may have a chance at landmark status after a 16-year battle.

An eviction notice at 227 Duffield Street after owner Samiel Hanasab moved to demolish it in 2019. The former abolitionist home is being considered for landmark status. 

An eviction notice at 227 Duffield Street after owner Samiel Hanasab moved to demolish it in 2019. The former abolitionist home is being considered for landmark status. 

Photographer: Rebecca Bellan

Corrected

As protesters demand a national reckoning on America’s whitewashed history, activists are rallying around a former abolitionists’ home in downtown Brooklyn with ties to the Underground Railroad as a chance to diversify historic preservation. High-profile endorsements to designate the building with landmark status, including by Mayor Bill de Blasio and New York Attorney General Letitia James, have bolstered a campaign by activists that goes back 16 years. 

The former home of prominent abolitionists Harriet and Thomas Truesdell, 227 Duffield Street is the last historical residence on a block with a record of abolitionist participation — a neglected slice of history among shiny new high rises, office buildings and chain hotels. Oral history has it that the home was a stop on the Underground Railroad, but the unrecorded connection has been hard to prove. The current owner, developer Samiel Hanasab, wants to tear it down and build a 13-story apartment building in its place.