Worst Value Stock Losses Since Brexit Portend Europe SlowdownBy
Shares in financials to healthcare are economic barometer
Quants see rotation in one of most popular strategies
As the risk-on rally resumes in European stocks, a pillar of the market is facing some of its worst losses since the Brexit vote.
They’re called value stocks, considered cheap and spanning industries from financials to materials and health-care stocks. They are beloved by quants -- and their comedown could be a bellwether for the state of the European economic cycle.
The thinking goes that value stocks do best during expansionary phases of the economy, when strong corporate profits will lift even the most chronically underpriced shares. Instead, since the end of April, investors in Europe have been chucking value shares to seek shelter in so-called quality names that could better weather an economic downturn.
“A cycle that is changing -- leading to this rotation -- will continue as long as macro data is weakening,” said Khuram Chaudhry, a quantitative strategist at JPMorgan Chase & Co. “We believe the macro data remains strong but may continue to weaken, which is why we have a stronger conviction for our style preferences.”
While inflation and jobs data have been strengthening, there are enough signs of weakness to support a bear’s case against value stocks. On Thursday, a reading of euro-area exports fell for the first time in five years, while German factory data declined to the worst level since September 2011.
Europe had been the perennial value play for overseas investors concerned about frothy prices in other developed markets. Seeking out cheap stocks has been a dismal strategy in the U.S. for much of the bull market, as growth-heavy tech stocks carry equities higher. But the appeal of Europe in general may be waning amid political drama in southern Europe. Funds focused on the single market have been bleeding assets while Wall Street strategists recommend pivoting to the S&P 500.
Over the past year, a long-short version of value has declined 7.9 percent -- the worst of the 17 most-common factors tracked by Bloomberg. Over the past 20 days, the factor has seen its biggest slump in two years.
Yet, slowing economic growth may not be the driving force. An aged bull market is more susceptible to shocks that send investors fleeing from value shares and increases volatility within investing styles, according to Jason Williams, a portfolio manager at Lazard Asset Management Ltd.
“This has less to do with a potential slowdown and more do to with the fact we’re in a rally that’s long in the tooth where there is a risk you see these whipsaws,” Williams said. “The biggest factor of all has been the political instability in Italy.”
Indeed, judging by earnings to price ratios, Italian banking stocks like Banco BPM SpA and BPER Banca top the value list. The former has fallen 21 percent in the past month, while BPER has declined 8.8 percent over the same period.
Still, Europe isn’t the only developed market struggling to keep value shares afloat. They’re lagging in the U.S. and Japan as well, demonstrating the extent to which fears of slowing synchronized global growth are preying on investors, said JPMorgan’s Khuram.
“When we are in a slowdown, the phase we’re currently in, we’re overweight growth, momentum and quality and underweight value,” he said. “That seems to be playing out.”