Prison Awaits Brazil’s Iconic Ex-President Lula After Court Loss

Updated on
  • Supreme Court rejects freedom plea as Lula appeals conviction
  • Judge Sergio Moro can now order detention at any moment
Can Lula influence Brazil’s election from inside a prison cell? Bloomberg’s Raymond Colitt reports.

Brazil’s former President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva faces time in prison after the Supreme Court rejected his request to appeal at liberty a 12-year prison sentence for corruption. Equity and currency markets rallied.

The nation’s top court early on Thursday rejected by 6-5 Lula’s request for a preventative habeas corpus, removing the final legal hurdle to a prison order. All eyes are now on Sergio Moro, the judge who prosecuted Lula and can authorize the ex-president’s detention. While Moro could order Lula behind bars immediately, standard procedure for judges and courts suggests a one- or two-week delay.

"It’s a sad day for democracy and for Brazil," tweeted Gleisi Hoffmann, the national president of Lula’s Workers’ Party, after the decision. The party said on Twitter that it would continue to defend Lula’s candidacy for October’s presidential elections.

For more insight on Lula’s case, click here

By law, no one convicted of a criminal offense upheld on appeal can run for elected office for at least eight years. Yet there have been numerous exceptions to the "clean slate" law since its introduction in 2010. The final decision on Lula’s eligibility rests with the country’s top electoral court, known as the TSE.

Since leaving office in 2010 with sky-high approval ratings, the 72-year old former trade unionist has become a deeply polarizing figure, still beloved by many on the left for the legacy of his social policies, but increasingly reviled by the right for the corruption that flourished under 13 years of Workers’ Party rule.

Investors, who had been wary of his pledge to undo recent pro-market policies and his significant lead in presidential polls, breathed a sigh of relief. The Sao Paulo stock exhange jumped more than 2 percent and the country’s currency, the real, gained 0.6 percent in early trading.

Thousands of both pro- and anti-Lula protesters rallied in cities around the country on Tuesday and Wednesday, with opponents of the ex-president setting off fireworks as the result turned against him.

On Monday, the president of the Supreme Court even issued a televised address appealing for calm. Last week, two of Lula’s campaign buses were hit by gunfire while traveling in the southern state of Parana. Brazil’s Army chief shocked many by issuing a veiled warning repudiating impunity on the eve of the court hearing.

With Lula’s imprisonment almost certain -- and his chances of running in October minimal -- the key question is whether he can still influence the election, potentially casting himself as a martyr and victim of political persecution.

It also begs the question of who, if anybody, will emerge as the favorite ahead of the
October election. None of the centrist, reform-minded candidates are polling beyond single digits. President Michel Temer, who is contemplating a bid for the country’s top job, has a disapproval rating of 87 percent, according to an Ibope poll published hours after the Supreme Court ruling.

— With assistance by Rachel Gamarski

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.
    LEARN MORE