Amazon-Whole Foods Deal Puts Spotlight on France’s CarrefourBy and
Digital-savvy CEO seeks to turn around French store chain
Carrefour could become European target for Amazon: analyst
Carrefour SA, which pioneered the big-box supermarket combining food and general merchandise in the 1960s, has been stepping up efforts to fuse e-commerce and in-store shopping. Amazon.com Inc.’s $13.7 billion deal for Whole Foods Market Inc. raises the ante for the French retailer.
Carrefour this month named a new chief executive officer, turning to 44-year-old Alexandre Bompard, who has been leading electronics retailer Fnac Darty SA since 2011. His mission, which is taking on additional urgency in the wake of the Amazon deal, is to expand his new employer’s online presence while revamping its tired “hypermarkets.”
Such stores have gone from being Carrefour’s backbone to its Achilles heel, struggling with competition from Amazon as well as nimbler big-box operators like Societe d’importation Leclerc SA, discounters and higher-end grocers like Grand Frais.
“The hypermarket concept needs to be fundamentally rethought in terms of what it’s bringing to the market and in terms of differentiation from online,” said Joelle de Montgolfier, retail consultant at Bain & Co.
French retailers, with Carrefour among the leaders, have been more successful in e-commerce. Click-and-collect services have flourished in France for more than a decade, making the industry more advanced in that respect than the U.S. Carrefour has more than 500 sites where online shoppers can pick up their groceries, while Wal-Mart Stores Inc. started introducing the option in 2014.
Bompard takes over as new French President Emmanuel Macron, bolstered by a strong legislative majority, aims to loosen up the country’s rigid labor market and stimulate the digital economy.
At Fnac, Bompard wowed investors by steering the retailer in a high-tech direction and by leading the acquisition of appliance chain Darty. Together, Fnac and Darty’s e-commerce receive nearly as many visitors as Amazon in France, according to a study by Mediametrie and French e-commerce federation Fevad. Shares in Fnac Darty roughly tripled since its 2013 IPO, and digital prowess has spared it from going the way of Borders bookstores, which succumbed to Amazon.
Carrefour shares are trading about 70 percent below their 1999 peak as rapid growth in Brazil and the roll-out of smaller city shops have failed to compensate for investor concern over the French hypermarkets. After the Whole Foods deal on Friday, Carrefour plunged along with other supermarkets, before rebounding slightly on Monday and Tuesday, when the shares were up as much as 1.6 percent in early Paris trading.
Even before the arrival of Bompard, who takes over July 18, Carrefour has been trying to boost its e-commerce presence. Its more than 50 acquisitions since 2000 include organic food provider Greenweez and technology and home goods marketplace Rue du Commerce. Online sales had a gross merchandise value of 1.2 billion euros ($1.34 billion) in 2016, and current CEO Georges Plassat has targeted 4 billion euros annually by 2020.
Still, Carrefour is lagging behind its peers in the French market for online groceries. Poor execution in the first years of its services has allowed rival Leclerc to take first place, accounting for 43.5 percent of French online grocery revenue, Sanford C. Bernstein said in a report, citing Kantar Worldpanel data. Carrefour’s 9 percent share also lags behind Auchan’s 25.3 percent.
With a digital-savvy new CEO ready to change that, Carrefour could find itself on Amazon’s shopping list, said Xavier Caroen, an analyst at Bryan Garnier.
“If worst comes to worst, provided that Alexandre Bompard does the job properly, Carrefour would be a target of choice for Amazon,” Caroen said in a note.
— With assistance by Richard Weiss