Ivanka Trump's Aid Sought for Jailed Chinese Investigators

Updated on
  • N.Y. labor group sent appeal to Trump after activists detained
  • Investigators admitted to theft of secrets, Chinese media says

Ivanka Trump.

Photographer: Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg

A labor-rights group whose investigators have been detained by Chinese authorities is appealing to Ivanka Trump to help secure their release after the men probed factories that supplied shoes for her brand.

In a four-page letter sent Tuesday to the first daughter at the White House, where she is an adviser to President Donald Trump, China Labor Watch said the three undercover activists were targeted because they were investigating a supplier connected to the Ivanka Trump brand.

“In the past 17 years, China Labor Watch has conducted hundreds of factory investigations and yet this is the first time our investigators face criminal detention,” Li Qiang, executive director of China Labor Watch, wrote in the letter, the first page of which was seen by Bloomberg. “We believe the reason to that is pertaining to the supplier factories of your brands particularly.”

The three activists were detained last month while investigating labor conditions at supplier Huajian Group in the southeastern province of Jiangxi. China Labor Watch said that it has been investigating conditions at 15 factories making products for the Ivanka Trump brand in the past year.

In the letter, Li implores Trump to use “your influence to help us advocate for the release of our investigators.”

Labor Conditions

Li also sent a flash drive containing video and photos of labor conditions at the factory that were collected during the investigation, according to the letter. As of Thursday, Li said he couldn’t confirm whether the White House had received the letter.

The White House staff wasn’t available for comment, while a representative for Ivanka Trump didn’t respond to a request for comment.

The U.S. State Department called for the release of the three men this week, but China’s foreign ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying rebuffed the appeal and said the case was an “internal matter.” White House spokesman Sean Spicer said Tuesday the U.S. will “continue to exert the proper diplomatic pressure on that.”

“After discussions with our licensee, we have determined that Ivanka Trump brand products have not been produced at the factory in question since March,” Abigail Klem, president of the Ivanka Trump brand, said on Wednesday. “Our licensee works with many footwear production factories and all factories are required to operate within strict social compliance regulations.”

Illegal Eavesdropping

The men -- Su Heng, Hua Haifeng and Li Zhao -- have confessed to illegally obtaining industrial secrets for a foreign organization, a state-run media outlet, The Paper, reported this week. They are accused of using recording devices, including a watch to take photos, in a factory in Ganzhou city and taking internal documents in exchange for payment. The trio were detained for illegal eavesdropping, said Wen Yu, a lawyer representing Hua.

Hua’s wife, Deng Guilian, hasn’t been able to see her husband since he was detained May 28.

“I just hope to receive any help there is,” she said. “My husband did not do anything wrong. Why must be he locked up and even be already given a guilty verdict by the Chinese media?”

Deng said she and her relatives are being monitored by authorities. She’s been cautioned by police not to speak to Western media, she said.

This is the second letter the labor organization has sent to Trump. In April, the group reported alleged labor violations at two unnamed factories that supply the Ivanka Trump brand. It said employees were forced to work at least 12 1/2 hours a day for wages below China’s legal minimum. Li said no response has been received to that letter.

Marc Fisher Footwear, which makes Ivanka Trump shoes under license, has said it was looking into the allegations outlined in April. Huajian, the supplier at the center of the controversy, denied it underpaid workers or that laborers were forced to work excessive hours.

“Western media have been misled by China Labor Watch and made erroneous reports,” it said in a statement. The company charges that the rights group has “undertaken illegal actions in China to gain twisted information, in order to profit.”

China Labor Watch previously identified labor violations at a Chinese toymaker used by Walt Disney Co., leading the entertainment giant to sever ties with the factory. It has also investigated plants used by Apple Inc.

— With assistance by Rachel Chang

(Updates to say videos and photos sent to Ivanka in sixth paragraph.)
    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE