Russia-OPEC Deal Extension Hastens Decline of Oil Heartlands

  • Output at higher-taxed West Siberian fields is dropping
  • Rosneft, Lukoil pursuing projects with higher-margin barrels

Russian Economy Minister Says OPEC Deal Is Working

Russia’s deal with OPEC has bolstered state coffers by putting a floor under crude prices, but it’s also had one unintended consequence: depressing output in the nation’s West Siberian oil heartlands.

With the Kremlin offering lower tax rates for new projects in the Caspian and East Siberia, Rosneft PJSC, Lukoil PJSC and other producers have looked elsewhere for the cuts that will allow Russia to comply with 300,000 barrels-a-day of production curbs. That means the Soviet-era fields of West Siberia.

“West Siberian output is the first to go under knife,” said Alexander Kornilov, an oil analyst at Aton. “These are the least profitable barrels.” 

Since Russia joined forces with the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries, futures have rebounded from last year’s lows and the exporters have been able to earn more while pumping less. The nation, which relies on energy for more than 40 percent of its budget, saw revenue from oil and natural gas taxes recover to two-year highs in February and March thanks to the pact.

While Russia was one of the earliest oil producers, with output initially centered on Baku on what is now Azerbaijan, the industry only regained global prominence in the 1960s and 1970s with the exploitation of reserves in the Volga-Urals region and the the discovery of some of the world’s highest-producing fields along the Ob River in Western Siberia. Those discoveries include the Langepas, Uray and Kogalym units whose initials gave Lukoil its name, and Rosneft’s giant 25 billion-barrel Samotlor field.

After pledging in December to reduce production by 300,000 barrels a day from a post-Soviet record of 11.247 million in October, Russia agreed with OPEC last Thursday to extend the landmark deal. Output in the country’s oil heartland is falling fastest, with first-quarter production at Rosneft’s largest Yugansk unit dropping 4.2 percent from the preceding three months. 

Total Russian production will remain little changed at 547 million tons this year, according to Energy Minister Alexander Novak. The balance will come from Caspian, East and Northern Siberian deposits, offsetting the declines in West Siberia.

Barrels with tax discounts will jump 74 percent this year to 43.1 million tons, or 866,000 barrels a day, according to research by Bank of America Merrill Lynch analyst Karen Kostanian. That could increase to 80.9 million tons by the end of 2020 as overall Russian output increases, he said.

Russian Economy Minister speaks about the impact of OPEC production cuts and long-term oil market risks.

Source: Bloomberg

While that production puts some pressure on the Kremlin’s budget, it pales beside lost revenues of more than $10 billion should oil drop by $5 a barrel, according to Alexander Burgansky, an analyst at Renaissance Capital.

Without the Russia-OPEC deal, oil prices would be $1 to $3 lower, Oleg Vyugin, a member of Rosneft’s board, said in an interview in St. Petersburg on Thursday.

Pricing Trade-Off

“With tax savings of up to 90 percent for new projects, the displacement of West Siberian barrels can cost the Russian budget up to $25 a barrel, or $2.7 billion per annum,” said Burgansky. “This seems a low price to pay for price stability.”

Russia maintains its oil-price outlook at $50 to $60 on average for this year, Novak said. Brent crude traded at $50.87 a barrel as of 12:33 p.m. in London on Thursday.

The Russian Finance Ministry remains philosophical, seeing the shift away from West Siberia as a natural process.

“This is standard practice when falling output at tapped fields are compensated by the development of new fields,” Alexey Sazanov, director of tax and customs department at the Finance Ministry said by email. “All these new fields will sooner or later become old and their tax burden will shift to West Siberian levels.”

Higher Margins

In the meantime, Russian producers continue to shift investment to higher-margin barrels. Lukoil is pushing ahead with investments in the Caspian, where its Filanovsky field is subject to a combined extraction and export tax rate of 15 percent, assuming a crude price of $50. That compares with a rate of 58.1 percent for standard Russian fields.

The government will use the beneficial environment created by the OPEC deal extension to replenish its reserves, Finance Minister Anton Siluanov said in an email.

Over the longer term, budget revenues from oil are projected to drop 2 percent every six years, said Former Finance Minister Alexey Kudrin, who still advises Russian President Vladimir Putin. That would have been the case even before the deal with OPEC, which Kudrin stresses is a short-term arrangement.

Ironically, the speed of the decline in West Siberia will be determined in part by another decades-old oil heartland thousands of miles away -- the Permian basin in Texas, where shale producers continue to ramp up output.

“Higher oil production elsewhere, such as the U.S., can lead to excess oil supplies and price declines despite Russia-OPEC efforts,” said Burgansky. “In this case, the Russian budget will lose twice.”

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.