G-7 Mutes Trade Spat as Greek Sideline Talks Take Limelight

Updated on
  • World commerce proved a sticking point a G20 meeting in March
  • Officials said to discuss Greece on Bari summit sidelines

OECD's Gurria Says Inequality Not Due to Globalization

Group of Seven finance chiefs don’t see eye-to-eye on trade, so they’re reverting to a default issue in economic diplomacy: Greece.

Officials arriving on Thursday for talks in the Southern Italian port of Bari -- a crossroads of commerce for more than two millenia -- downplayed any focus on their festering disagreement after two abortive Group of 20 discussions this year suggested the Trump administration won’t sign up to the long-existing global consensus on free trade.

That leaves sideline talks on Greece as the most fruitful arena for talks for now. On Wednesday, a senior U.S. Treasury official said they are looking for Europe to take the lead in solving the country’s debt problem. Informal talks on Greece were held on Thursday night, according to German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble. His nation, together with Italy, France, the International Monetary Fund and the European Central Bank make up the so-called Washington Group.

“Trade is explicitly off the table -- they’re not going to clinch anything at all,” said Isabelle Mateos y Lago, chief multi-asset strategist at BlackRock. But on Greece, “this is the right grouping within which to reach an agreement on some of the more political aspects.”

Talks on easing Greece’s debt load have been picking up steam amid hopes of striking a deal later this month, with officials targeting the May 22 meeting in euro-area finance ministers in Brussels. Among the preferred options is the use of leftovers from the country’s latest euro-area-backed bailout to repay about 12.4 billion euros ($11.4 billion) of IMF loans to Greece outstanding, according to EU officials.

“We’ll carry on working on this debt relief package,” IMF Managing Director Christine Lagarde said on Friday. “We certainly hope that the Europeans will be far more specific in terms of debt relief which is also an imperative.”

Budget Performance

Loans from the European Stability Mechanism carry much lower interest and much longer maturities than those extended by the fund, meaning that such a swap operation would ease Greece’s funding needs in the immediate future, even as the overall impact on debt sustainability will be limited.

A key issue in the talks is the assumptions about Greece’s budget performance after 2018, when the current bailout expires. The IMF has repeatedly raised doubts about Greece’s ability to maintain a stellar budget record for decades. Less ambitious fiscal targets, though, would increase the need for debt relief.

“I’m not talking about precise meetings but obviously we have the occasion to discuss here” on Greece, Pierre Moscovici, the EU’s Economic Affairs commissioner, told Bloomberg Television. “We need the IMF on board. There are discussions with the IMF, the IMF is involved and I think it is also positive.”

Moscovici discusses Greece, Brexit and the French and German elections on Bloomberg TV.

Source: Bloomberg

Greece isn’t represented at the G-7 or in the Washington Group, so it can’t disagree. By contrast, trade remains highly contentious and may loom large in Bari as finance ministers and central bank governors meet.

Bad Memories

At the G-20 in the German spa town of Baden-Baden, officials almost left trade out of their communique as U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin pressed for them to agree it should be “fair” rather than “free” -- while a month later in Washington, he crystallized that position, citing the President Donald Trump as favoring “reciprocal free trade.” 

Even that was somewhat of a departure for an administration that has pledged to rebalance global commerce in its favor, repatriate American manufacturing jobs and right the wrongs it sees as emanating from the current World Trade Organization-centered system.

Moscovici, who said in March after Baden-Baden that “I cannot overstate the importance of avoiding any rollback” on free trade, was reluctant to reopen those wounds.

Mnuchin attends the talks as the Trump administration faces a political firestorm back home, which has called into question its power to implement an ambitious economic agenda.

“We’ve discussed already in the G-20 twice -- once in Baden-Baden, the other time in Washington,” he said. “We are not here going to discuss about that.”

So any more formal progress remains unlikely for now even if that means trade becomes the elephant in the room in talks formally covering the global economy, financial institutions and fighting inequality. The officials’ meeting in Bari will be followed in just two weeks by G-7 summit in Sicily -- part of Donald Trump’s first international outing as President.

“I don’t think they’re holding their breath over this meeting,” said Torsten Slok, chief international economist at Deutsche Bank in New York. “Still, “that doesn’t mean we’re not watching it very carefully.”

— With assistance by Alessandro Speciale, Alessandra Migliaccio, Lorenzo Totaro, Birgit Jennen, Saleha Mohsin, Toru Fujioka, Matthew Miller, Flavia Rotondi, Elena Gergen-Constantine, Viktoria Dendrinou, Sotiris Nikas, and Nikos Chrysoloras

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.