Iron Ore Miners Take a Mighty Hit as Capitulation Mars Ugly Week

Updated on
  • ‘This process may have further to go,’ CMC’s Spooner predicts
  • BHP Billiton, Rio Tinto and Fortescue shares sink in Sydney

Iron ore is at risk of extending declines in the coming weeks after a drumbeat of warnings of a pullback helped to spur the biggest one-day slump in more than a year, intensifying investor concern about rising supplies and hammering miners’ shares.

“It just appears to be a real capitulation phase going on in iron ore at the moment,” Ric Spooner, chief market analyst at CMC Markets in Sydney, said after the benchmark spot price collapsed 8.5 percent on Wednesday to the lowest since Nov. 7. “This process may have further to go before we begin to reach a base, which is somewhere more like in the $50-to-$60 range.”

Iron ore entered a bear market last week as a procession of analysts, Australia’s government and even some miners said gains to the highest since 2014 were unsustainable. The potential for a significant drop was foreseen, given a possible downturn in Chinese construction, increased supplies and high inventory levels at ports, according to Spooner. Steel prices in China, the top customer for seaborne ore, have also been sinking.

‘More Sustainable’

“I don’t think anybody should be surprised to see the iron ore price come back to more sustainable levels,” Fortescue Metals Group Ltd. Chief Executive Officer Nev Power said on a media call after a production report. New supply is coming from Vale SA, Roy Hill Holdings Pty and Anglo American Plc, he said, adding: “What we’ll see is the iron ore price return to where you’d predict it to be off the supply curve, which is somewhere around that $60 to $65 a ton.”

Spot ore with 62 percent content in Qingdao dropped $6.34 to $68.04 a dry ton on Wednesday, declining for a fifth day, according to Metal Bulletin Ltd. On Thursday, the benchmark, which hit almost $95 in February, rose 0.9 percent to $68.68 in this week’s final pricing given the public holiday in Singapore on Friday.

Miners sank. In Sydney, Fortescue plunged 6.8 percent to A$5.50, the lowest since November, while Rio Tinto Group fell 4.4 percent. BHP Billiton Ltd., which is facing calls from Elliott Management Corp. for an overhaul, dropped 4 percent. The trio are Australia’s largest shippers.

Not everyone is bearish. The pullback is probably a short-term weakness, Tom Price, a London-based analyst at Morgan Stanley, wrote in a note received Thursday. The bank sees $70 to $90 as a stable range until the second half, when seaborne exports typically peak and steel activity slows before winter.

Futures in Asia showed some support on Thursday as traders weighed the outlook, trade data from China as well as Power’s comments. In Singapore, the SGX AsiaClear contract was 1.1 percent higher at $66.91 a ton after slumping 5.7 percent the day before. Futures in Dalian, China, ended little changed.

China’s Demand

Fortescue reported a 6 percent drop in shipments in the quarter to March 31, in line with analysts’ expectations. Iron ore and steel demand in China remained strong during the first three months of 2017, driven by construction and infrastructure activity, the company said in a statement.

Data from China on Thursday pointed to robust imports and higher supply. Inbound volumes were 95.6 million tons in March, just short of a monthly record, while first-quarter shipments jumped 12 percent to 271 million tons, according to the National Statistics Bureau. That’s a record quarterly figure.

The sell-off in iron ore followed a slew of bearish outlooks, many of which have flagged prospects for rising supply from Australia and Brazil, the top shippers. After Barclays Plc, Australia’s central bank and BHP flagged reasons for a drop, Goldman Sachs Group Inc. added to the chorus with a report on Wednesday affirming its view iron ore could fall to $60.

“The slump reflects a worsening outlook for steel demand and the fact that the previous run-up in prices has been too great,” Wu Zhili, an analyst at Shenhua Futures Co., said by phone from Shenzhen. “I don’t see the drop as being excessive; it’s well within expectations.”

— With assistance by Martin Ritchie

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.