U.S., Japan Test Xi With Taiwan Moves Ahead of Trump Summit

  • Allies take steps toward upgraded security ties with island
  • Moves could weigh on meeting between leaders at Mar-a-Lago

With Trump, Taiwan's Tightrope Gets Narrower

The U.S. and Japan are taking steps toward upgrading ties with Taiwan, risking a run-in with China as Donald Trump and Xi Jinping prepare for a first meeting in Florida next week.

The two allies have made a series of moves signaling more-direct relations with the diplomatically isolated island even after Trump reaffirmed the U.S.’s long-standing policy recognizing that both sides are part of “One China.” In the last week alone, Taiwan has seen its U.S. envoy share a Washington stage with Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and hosted a vice minister from Japan, its highest-level official visit in almost half a century.

Rex Tillerson and Fumio Kishida, Japan’s foreign minister, in Tokyo on March 16.

Photographer: Toru Yamanaka/Pool via Bloomberg

Such exchanges could weigh on talks if the Mar-a-Lago summit goes ahead between Xi and Trump, who jolted ties in December by taking an unprecedented phone call from Taiwan’s president, Tsai Ing-wen and openly questioned the One-China policy. China considers its sovereignty over Taiwan a “core interest” and is anxious for reassurances that Trump won’t alter U.S. policy, sell the island more arms or establish direct military ties.

A QuickTake explainer on Taiwan’s relationship with China

While Trump hasn’t said anything provocative about Taiwan since taking office, tensions between the island and China are running high because Tsai’s pro-independence Democratic Progressive Party swept the Beijing-friendly Kuomintang from power last year. Tsai, who has angered Beijing by refusing to endorse the One-China framework, has sought to bolster the island’s military and reduce its trade dependence on China.

The Taiwanese president told a banquet hosted by the American Chamber of Commerce in Taipei last week that she wanted an “upgraded strategic relationship between our two countries,” including deeper security cooperation and defense-industry ties.

“We firmly oppose any forms of military exchanges and official visits between Taiwan and countries that have established diplomatic ties with us,” Taiwan Affairs Office spokesman Ma Xiaoguang said Wednesday at a regular briefing in Beijing. “This goes without saying."

The U.S. and Japan -- security allies with their own concerns about China’s growing might -- have shown a willingness to oblige Taiwan. The island’s de facto U.S. ambassador Stanley Kao was among the representatives from a 68-member anti-Islamic State coalition invited to the State Department on March 22. Kao posed for a group photo with Tillerson. China was not represented.

Tsai Ing-wen on a submarine at the Tsoying navy base in Kaohsiung on March 21.

Photographer: Sam Yeh/AFP via Getty Images

On Monday, China’s foreign ministry said it lodged a “serious” protest with Japan after Vice Minister for Internal Affairs and Communications Jiro Akama attended a cultural exchange meeting in Taiwan on March 25. On Jan. 1, Japan also changed the name of its mission in Taipei to the Japan-Taiwan Exchange Association, which could be seen as implying state-to-state relations.

‘Grave Disturbances’

China’s foreign ministry spokeswoman Hua Chunying said Japan’s recent “provocative actions” regarding Taiwan have already caused “grave disturbances” to ties. Japanese Foreign Minister Fumio Kishida said Akama’s visit represented “non-governmental, practical ties” and wasn’t a break with practice since establishing relations with China in 1972.

Japan’s move was probably “coordinated with Washington,” said June Teufel Dreyer, a University of Miami political science professor, whose new book, “Middle Kingdom and Empire of the Rising Sun,” explores China-Japan ties. She said Kao’s attendance at the Islamic State summit represented a “real, if tiny, step up in U.S.-Taiwan relations.”

Robert Lighthizer

Photographer: Zach Gibson/Bloomberg

Asked last week about Taiwan’s participation in the Islamic State summit, State Department spokesman Mark Toner said the U.S. appreciated contributions from coalition members “big or small.” Robert Lighthizer, Trump’s pick for trade representative, told senators overseeing his confirmation last week that he intended to “develop a trade-and-investment policy that promotes a stronger bilateral relationship with Taiwan.” 

Leaders Meeting

Arthur Ding, director of National Chengchi University’s Institute of International Relations in Taipei, said Tsai’s approach to the U.S. was “cautious and gradual” and that ties would improve regardless of any deals between Trump and Xi. “Given the ongoing trend of warming relations between Taiwan and the U.S., I think the possibility is rather low for the Xi-Trump summit to negatively affect it,” Ding said.

Taiwanese foreign ministry spokeswoman Eleanor Wang said in a text message Tuesday that the island had a “solid friendship” with the U.S. and expected to be in close contact with Washington before and after any Xi summit. Wang called the visit Japanese vice minister’s visit a “meaningful” step toward enhancing communications.

The National Defense Authorization Act signed by President Barack Obama in December gave Trump another way to upgrade Taiwan ties, since it would allow exchanges between senior military officials including the “assistant secretary of defense or above.” Trump could also deploy uniformed Marines at the yet-to-be completed American Institute in Taiwan complex, where plain-clothes troops have been stationed since 2005.

An arms sale to Taiwan could also test relations with China, which delayed a visit by then-Defense Secretary Robert Gates for almost a year after the U.S. announced a $6.4 billion deal in 2010. The Washington Free Beacon reported this month that the Trump administration was preparing to provide more and better defensive arms to the island.

Getting Trump to reaffirm past policies on Taiwan would be a priority for Xi in any summit, Huang Jing, a professor of U.S.-China relations at the National University of Singapore, told Bloomberg Television on Monday.

“Xi Jinping is taking a high risk to meet Donald Trump,” Huang said. “If there is anything substantial to be achieved, the No. 1 is Xi Jinping would like Donald Trump to repeat from his own mouth to the public the One-China policy, and say what Tillerson said in China that the bilateral relationship should be based on cooperation, not confrontation.”

— With assistance by Isabel Reynolds, Adela Lin, and Russell Ward

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.
    LEARN MORE