China's CLSA Shuts U.S. Equity Research, Cutting 90 WorkersBy , , and
Analysts Mayo, Silver, Maguire among those laid off by firm
Parent had introduced cost-reduction moves in September
Hong Kong-based CLSA dismissed 90 U.S.-based employees on Monday, most of whom worked in research, including research sales support staff, as well as a few traders, according to spokeswoman Simone Wheeler. The terminations include analysts Mike Mayo, a managing director who covered banks, and Avi Silver and Ed Maguire, both of whom wrote about technology firms, she said. Mayo and Maguire declined to comment while Silver didn’t immediately return messages left after business hours.
Financial research houses are facing revenue pressures, including from a proposal in Europe to make investors pay for investment analysis separately from trading commissions. While CLSA Chief Executive Officer Jonathan Slone said the move wasn’t directly linked to the so-called MiFID initiative, he said last week that investors should be allowed to decide what they want to pay for analyst research without too many regulatory restrictions.
The U.S. closure “was not made with any particular rule in mind,” Slone said in an e-mail. “You could say that the overall shift on payment for research was part of this, but this has been a long evolving process linked not only to MiFID but a whole host of changes.”
“We simply plan to invest in other parts of our business in the U.S. and believe we can best serve the clients in cash equities within an execution-only framework in the U.S. domestic marketplace,” Slone said.
While the rules -- under the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive -- are a European initiative, banks in Asia are also feeling the effects. Global investors have been allocating a smaller proportion of their commission payments to brokers that provide equity research and advisory services in Asia over the past two years, according to a survey released last month by Greenwich Associates.
Citic Securities, which bought CLSA from French bank Credit Agricole SA in 2013 for about $1.2 billion, considered selling the Hong Kong-based brokerage last year, people with knowledge of the matter said at the time. It cut about 25 staff in Asia two years ago, mainly in equities, a person familiar with the move said then.
CLSA began telegraphing some operations were strained in September, when it asked its 1,500 workers globally to take as many as 10 days of unpaid leave through March as it sought ways to cut costs. The firm introduced similar measures three times -- in 2003, 2008 and 2009 -- when it underwent trying market conditions.
The firm’s Americas unit will now employ 85 workers to execute U.S. and Asia stock trades, plus Asia equities sales, Wheeler said. Those employees, led by CLSA Americas LLC’s CEO Rick Gould, will continue to offer services including sector and portfolio trading, electronic execution and commission management, the company said in a statement Monday.
CLSA, established in 1986, has about 1,500 staff in 25 offices across Asia, Australia, the Americas and Europe, according to its website. The brokerage became well known for its high-profile annual forums, where guests included former U.S. President Bill Clinton and filmmaker Francis Ford Coppola.
Bank analyst Mayo is the author of “Exile on Wall Street: One Analyst’s Fight to Save the Big Banks From Themselves.”
— With assistance by Alfred Liu