At $60,000 an Acre, the Permian Basin May Be Too RitzyBy
Top shale play’s growing entry fee spurs risk-reward backlash
Oklahoma Scoop, Stack seen drawing overflow as deals migrate
Record prices for drilling rights in the Permian Basin, the most fertile U.S. shale field, are prompting oil companies and private equity investors to look elsewhere for the next big gushers.
Explorers eager to tap the basin’s mile-thick stack of oil-soaked rock layers have paid as much as $60,000 an acre. That marks a 50-fold explosion in deal prices over four years, according to Wood Mackenzie Ltd. It also pushes the cost 10 times higher than in the Bakken of North Dakota.
The backlash is just beginning. BP Plc, the U.K.-based supermajor, has focused its shale-drilling efforts on the other end of the hemisphere, in Argentina’s Vaca Muerta region, while Sanchez Energy Corp. has targeted the Eagle Ford of South Texas and Newfield Exploration Co. has acquired rights in the Stack field in northern Oklahoma.
As far as the Permian is concerned, “companies that don’t already have a foothold are seeing valuations that are out of control,” said Gabriele Sorbara, an analyst at Williams Capital Group LP in New York. “They can’t get involved.”
The Permian runs 250 miles wide and 300 miles long across West Texas and southeastern New Mexico. It’s a gold mine for oil drillers, not only because it has many more layers of oil-rich stone, but also because each seam is 10 or 15 times thicker than those in other shale formations such as the Bakken or Eagle Ford.
That means more opportunities to strike oil, and more pay zones. Permian wells can generate profit with crude selling for less than $40 a barrel, a threshold unheard of in other shale fields.
That’s why drillers already there have been boosting their efforts. Occidental Petroleum Corp., the biggest operator in the Permian, said on Thursday it may double output in the region during the next four years. The Permian is Occidental’s “foundation” and “growth engine,” Chief Executive Officer Vicki Hollub said in a conference call.
Now, though, prices have risen above $50 a barrel on the strength of a pledge by the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries and 11 other nations to enact output cuts. OPEC implemented 90 percent of the promised reductions last month, the highest compliance rate in the cartel’s history. Higher prices mean broader opportunity, opening new promise at fields where it costs more to produce oil. West Texas Intermediate crude rose 2 percent to $54.05 a barrel at 12:40 p.m. on Friday in New York.
Prime candidates to capture the Permian’s overflow are the Scoop and Stack regions of Oklahoma, the Bakken, the Haynesville Shale in Louisiana and the Eagle Ford. As for the Permian, uncertainties about whether it holds enough crude to justify skyrocketing prices is reminiscent of “the Internet circa 1998,” said Peter Pulikkan, a Bloomberg Intelligence analyst.
“We’re in the second inning of a Permian bubble,” Pulikkan said. “Some players are starting to look at other areas that may offer better risk-reward” ratios, given the buy-in.
Emboldened by a rejuvenated oil market where prices jumped 90 percent in New York in the past year, the rush to snap up Permian assets accelerated as 2016 wound down, with companies such as Exxon Mobil Corp. and private equity firms like Talara Capital Management LLC leading the push. By year’s end, the region had absorbed one of every four dollars spent globally on oilfield acquisitions, according to Wood Mackenzie, the Edinburgh-based research house.
However, the attractiveness of the Permian may already be fading. Less than half the respondents in a Bloomberg Intelligence survey said the Permian will draw the most acquisition interest in the coming year. That’s down from 57 percent in 2016.
Another sign of weakness for the region may be gleaned from the performance of Jagged Peak Energy Inc., a Permian explorer that had to cut the price and size of its initial share sale last month, and has fallen almost 3 percent since its debut.
‘What You Pay’
“It’s all about what you pay to get into an asset compared to how much you can get out of it,” said David Zusman, chief investment officer and co-founder of Talara, which has $600 million under management. The firm began investing in Permian driller Caza Oil & Gas Inc. in late 2014 and took control of the company at a bargain price the following year during the depths of the market collapse.
Although major Permian operators including Exxon, Pioneer Natural Resources Co. and Anadarko Petroleum Corp. are “in it to win it” and unlikely to alter course, “new entrants may be turned off and look elsewhere,” said Joseph Triepke, founder of Infill Thinking, a Dallas-based oil research firm, and a former analyst at Citadel LLC’s Surveyor Capital unit.
“Oklahoma is the logical place to go” because of the huge potential in the Scoop and Stack regions, Triepke said. “Those are the places that will benefit most from the Permian bubble.”