Wall Street Hope Revived as Trump Plans to Roll Back Rulesby , , and
Executive action would start unwinding Dodd-Frank regulations
Morgan Stanley, Goldman surge most since day after election
Just when Wall Street was starting to wonder whether President Donald Trump really would be good for business, the new administration is delivering on bankers’ wish lists and sending shares of the biggest U.S. financial companies soaring.
Trump on Friday signed two directives aimed at starting the process of rolling back restrictions put in place to prevent another financial crisis. Among the targets are rules that guard against predatory lenders, force brokers to lower fees for retirees and ban proprietary trading -- protections that consumer advocates vowed to defend.
Chief executives including Goldman Sachs Group Inc.’s Lloyd Blankfein and JPMorgan Chase & Co.’s Jamie Dimon have been pushing for changes for years, arguing that the industry has been too constrained by the system put in place by the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act. After Trump focused on limiting trade and immigration during his first two weeks in office -- policies opposed by many in the financial industry -- the president’s stroke of a pen unleashes a process to undo many of the rules they find most irksome.
“We’re going to attack all aspects of Dodd-Frank,” Gary Cohn, the director of the White House National Economic Council and former Goldman Sachs president, said Friday in an interview with Bloomberg Television. The administration “can do quite a bit” without help from lawmakers, Cohn said, “but the more help we get from Congress the better off we’re all going to be.”
Getting Congress to pass changes to Dodd-Frank won’t be easy. Most legislation would require support from at least eight Democrats in the Senate to get around filibuster rules. Republicans could try to go after parts of the law through a process known as budget reconciliation that wouldn’t require a single Democratic vote, but that requires proving specific provisions of Dodd-Frank are a drain on the budget.
House Republicans, led by Financial Services Committee Chairman Jeb Hensarling, plan to roll out a bill to replace Dodd-Frank in coming weeks. The Senate Banking Committee hasn’t proposed its own legislation.
U.S. equity markets, which had dropped earlier in the week amid the immigration controversy, climbed toward recent record highs Friday, with financial stocks leading the way. The 63-company S&P 500 Financials Index advanced 2 percent at 4:22 p.m. in New York. Goldman Sachs surged 4.6 percent and Morgan Stanley jumped 5.5 percent, the biggest gain since the day after the U.S. election on Nov. 9.
Cohn and Steve Mnuchin, Trump’s nominee for Treasury Secretary, advised the president on the rule changes.
Trump’s executive order set up a series of core financial aims for his administration, including preventing taxpayer-funded bailouts, boosting the competitiveness of American firms, narrowing the aim of regulations and pushing U.S. interests in international regulatory negotiations. The order instructs the Treasury secretary to talk to the heads of U.S. financial agencies about how existing laws and standards meet those core principles.
The order never mentions any particular law or regulator, and it doesn’t call for any action on these points, except to demand a study. The secretary -- presumably Mnuchin after his nomination is confirmed by the Senate -- must report back to President Trump by the beginning of June on how the government is doing.
Dimon and other CEOs have complained that the rules tie up resources that could otherwise be used to boost lending and help stimulate the economy.
“Banks have been forced to hoard capital,” which prohibits them from making new loans, Cohn said in the interview.
The restrictions haven’t prevented a jump in new lending. U.S. commercial banks had $9.19 trillion in loans and leases outstanding at the end of last year, according to data compiled by Bloomberg from Federal Reserve statistics. That’s a $558 billion increase, or 6.5 percent, over 2015, the data show. Of that, $2.1 trillion are business loans, a 7.3 percent advance from the prior year.
Lending to small businesses and farms fell for several years after the 2008 crisis, but has grown consistently by a quarterly average of 2 percent since 2013, according to data from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp.
At JPMorgan, the biggest U.S. bank, loans increased 10 percent to $806.2 billion last year, with gains in every category including credit cards and wholesale debt.
On Monday, Trump promised to do “a big number” on the Dodd-Frank Act during a meeting with small-business owners. He said the law had damaged the country’s entrepreneurial spirit and limited access to needed credit, calling it a “disaster.”
The stress-testing mechanism put in place by the act forces banks to prove to regulators they have enough capital to weather intense economic downturns. The process is complex, but it’s made the U.S. banking system “extremely strong, the strongest in the world,” Christopher Wheeler, a bank analyst at Atlantic Equities, said in a Bloomberg Television interview. “The question is, will he tamper with that.”
One focus will be the Volcker Rule limits on banks making speculative bets with their own funds, Cohn said. Trump also signed an executive memorandum directing the Department of Labor to review and stall the fiduciary rule -- set to take effect in April -- that the Obama administration said would protect millions of retirees from being steered into inappropriate investments that generate bigger profits for brokers.
Lincoln National Corp. and Voya Financial Inc. were among annuity providers that rallied on the move. Prudential Financial Inc., MetLife Inc. and American International Group Inc. also jumped. The three insurers had been named non-bank systemically important financial institutions, a tag that had the potential to bring tighter capital restrictions under Dodd-Frank.
“There’s so much in Dodd-Frank that just doesn’t make sense,” said Robert Albertson, a principal and chief strategist at Sandler O’Neill & Partners LP. “The dialogue between the financials and regulators had to change.”
The president signaled that he wants a change of direction at the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Cohn told the Wall Street Journal that one way to do that would be to replace its director, Richard Cordray. That could trigger a legal battle if Cordray refuses to step down.
Trump’s deregulation plans will be opposed by Democrats such as Senator Elizabeth Warren, who’s championed the consumer-protection bureau and the stricter bank rules. She’s said Trump plans to use his power to benefit wealthy friends.
“The Wall Street bankers and lobbyists whose greed and recklessness nearly destroyed this country may be toasting each other with champagne, but the American people have not forgotten the 2008 financial crisis -- and they will not forget what happened today,” Warren, a Massachusetts Democrat, said in a statement Friday.
Trump’s orders are likely “symbolic” because there’s little he can do directly to alter Dodd-Frank, the Department of Labor’s fiduciary rule or the fate of the CFPB, Cowen & Co.’s Jaret Seiberg said in a note Friday. The real change may occur once Trump has named his people to government agencies, the analyst wrote.
“The president over the next 12 months gets to put his people in charge of the financial regulators,” Seiberg wrote. “That will then open the door to ease regulatory burden.”
For some in the industry, the changes may be coming too late.
“Many firms in these sectors have already taken steps and adjusted fees to restructure their businesses to comply,” Brian Gardner, an analyst at Keefe, Bruyette and Woods, said in a note to clients about the fiduciary rule. “We are skeptical whether many of them will reverse course, simply because such a reversal may look like the firm is putting its interests ahead of its customers.”
Morgan Stanley spokesman Wesley McDade said in a statement that the firm “will continue to move forward with many of the initiatives we have underway, reflecting our ongoing commitment to raising the standard of care we provide our retirement and non-retirement clients.”