Ten Minutes of Play Sums Up Nintendo’s Messy Super Mario DebutBy
Ratings in App Store lag behind Clash of Clans, Monster Strike
Criticism focuses on game-play, $10 cost of full version
Nintendo Co.’s debut game for smartphones is turning out to be anything but super.
Since its release for Apple Inc. devices on Thursday, Super Mario Run has shot to the top of download charts in more than 100 countries as tens of millions celebrated the iconic video game character’s arrival on iPhones. Yet problems emerged almost immediately, with thousands vigorously complaining that the three levels available with the free download were over too quickly -- in less than ten minutes in most cases -- and the $10 price tag to unlock the rest was too steep.
That backlash is now reverberating through its share price. Nintendo shares were largely unchanged at the Tuesday midday break after dropping by 11 percent in the two trading days since the game’s release, wiping out more than $3.5 billion in market value. Investors and analysts are starting to second-guess the company’s decisions and its ability to execute on mobile devices.
“A $10 upfront cost to unlock the game is a huge ask and one that flies in the face of current mobile games being free-to-play,” said Daniel Ahmad, an analyst for researcher Niko Partners. “The first three levels are not very long and the payment screen doesn’t seem to make it abundantly clear what the user is getting in return for that $10 purchase.”
Those comments mostly echo the reaction online, where more than a hundred thousand users have posted ratings on Apple’s App Stores in the U.S., Japan and elsewhere, ranking the game at two and a half stars out of five. That’s among the lowest for apps at the top of download rankings, and below other games such as Clash Royale, Candy Crush Saga or Monster Strike.
Besides the high price, reviewers focused on Nintendo’s decision to require an internet connection, with many complaining they couldn’t play during their commutes. Others said the over-simplified game-play removed features that are a staple of Super Mario games on consoles, such as fireballs.
“The negative reviews aren’t necessarily because it’s a bad game,” said Eliran Sapir, head of Apptopia. “It’s a combination of the high price tag and fans not liking the vehicle.”
Sapir said poor word-of-mouth could impact the game’s profitability. While the game has become the highest-grossing game in most countries, it could only reach third place in Japan -- the world’s third-largest app market, according to App Annie. That heightens the risk it could fall short of analysts’ expectations. Nomura Holdings Inc. has estimated the game will generate 36 billion yen ($306 million) by the end of March, while Macquarie Securities sees $200 million in the same period. The title earned $14 million in its first three days, according to researcher App Annie.
The negative buzz could particularly hurt sales to the much larger pool of Android users, who won’t get a version until an undetermined time next year.
Even among those who paid $10 for the full experience on Apple’s iOS, a common complaint was the lack of incentives to keep playing for longer. The quest to rescue Princess Peach can be completed in about two hours and thereafter the game encourages users to run through already-completed levels on harder difficulties and race against other players. Items they win are ultimately used in Kingdom Builder, a never-ending game mode where players can craft a small village to call their own.
The problem, users say, is that kingdom-building is a shallow affair. The small variety of items to buy and limited map size means most villages won’t differ much from player to player. That’s a far cry from other games such as Pokemon Go, where a high number of pocket monsters, each with unique characteristics, made catching them all a highly personalized experience. By comparison, Super Mario Run does little to make items in Kingdom Builder seem anything more than inanimate objects.
All of this raises questions about whether Nintendo fundamentally understands what smartphone gamers want, even as it teams with mobile gaming specialist DeNA Co. to bring out titles.
Since announcing its expansion into smartphones in March 2015, investors have pushed shares 74 percent higher on the promise the Kyoto-based company can bring its gaming prowess into the hands of the world’s 2.3 billion smartphone users. The decisions that went into Super Mario Run, and the reaction from users, is making some re-assess those convictions.
“Right now it is near the top of rankings, but people are foreseeing that it will fall quite quickly,” said Hideki Yasuda, an analyst at Ace Research Institute.
For analyst Serkan Toto, the real test is what Nintendo does next. To reverse the souring sentiment, the company should announce additional content to create more depth to the game-play. While a change to the pricing model is also possible, Nintendo has avoided lowering prices on products in the past.
“There will be more worlds, more stages and maybe also at some point in time a break away from the business model,” said Toto, founder of consultant Kantan Games Inc. “It’s just the first version of their first actual game.”
— With assistance by Nao Sano