Photographer: Sanjit Das/Bloomberg

Investors Seen Hunting Value in 1MDB-Stricken Malaysian Stocks

  • Earnings could reach end of downgrade cycle: Affin Hwang’s Gan
  • Malaysia is home to longest bull market run in world

With Malaysian stocks on the brink of their longest stretch of annual losses ever, one money manager is buying amid bets valuations and signs of shifting overseas sentiment will spur a rebound.

Gan Eng Peng of Affin Hwang Asset Management Bhd. says earnings are stabilizing after sinking to the lowest since 2011, while an undervalued ringgit may prompt foreigners to consider buying again. Overseas brokers he spoke to have signaled unusual interest in Malaysia, says Gan, who took “big positions” in three of the largest stocks including Sime Darby Bhd. and CIMB Group Holdings Bhd. The move comes in a market clouded by weak profits and a scandal linked to a state fund.

“After nine quarters of earnings disappointment, we could be reaching the end of the downgrade cycle,” said Gan, equities head of Kuala Lumpur-based Affin Hwang, whose Select Opportunity Fund beat 97 percent of peers with an 11 percent return in the past year. “Foreign funds are on the hunt for ideas in Malaysia. The strong outperformance of Indonesia, political issues in Thailand and Philippines, could drive some re-balancing of monies into Malaysia.”  

Stocks in Malaysia, home to the world’s longest bull market, haven’t been this cheap since 2009 relative to global equities. Yet they have been laggards in Southeast Asia, caught between weak oil that has dented the government’s oil revenue, a scandal engulfing 1Malaysia Development Bhd., and the prospect for higher U.S. borrowing costs. The benchmark stock index is headed for a third year of declines.

While Indonesian and Thai shares are up at least 16 percent this year and the Philippines has gained 10 percent, Malaysian equities are down 1.5 percent. They may catch up, Gan says. 

“Foreign funds are attracted by the 33 percent underperformance” of the ringgit versus its Asian peers since 2013, he said. “Recent investment conferences including one in Hong Kong have seen packed participation for Malaysia strategy meetings, which is unusual. The big caveat is that all these have not resulted into stronger foreign flows yet.”

Foreign buying has been erratic. Inflows hit a peak of 6.4 billion ringgit ($1.5 billion) in April, only to see a selloff halving them to 2.2 billion ringgit as of last week. Foreigners pulled 26.4 billion ringgit in the last two years.

Value Trap

The FTSE Bursa Malaysia KLCI Index is valued at 18 times its current earnings, the cheapest since 2009 versus the MSCI All Country World Index. The measure sank 3.9 percent in 2015. It almost doubled from its 2008 low without succumbing to a 20 percent drop, making it the longest bull-market worldwide. 

The Malaysian stock gauge climbed 0.2 percent to a one-month high at Friday’s close. Banking group CIMB led gains, rising 2.2 percent to the highest level in a year, while plantation giant Sime Darby reached a two-month high.

Not everyone is optimistic.  

“The negative newsflow surrounding 1MDB is a drag to foreign funds,” said Clive McDonnell, Singapore-based head of emerging-markets equity strategy at Standard Chartered Plc. “It is certainly attractive by its value, however cheap stays cheap without a catalyst.”

1MDB is at the center of multiple international investigations into whether money was mishandled at the state-owned fund. Earlier this month, Singapore regulators ordered Falcon Private Bank to cease operations in the island city for breaches of anti-money laundering regulations in relation to its role in moving funds associated with 1MDB. The fund has consistently denied any wrongdoing.

For a QuickTake Q&A on 1MDB, click here.

Stocks “risk becoming a value trap without better growth,” said Alan Richardson, a Hong Kong-based fund manager at Samsung Asset Management Ltd. Opportunities are mainly confined to smaller stocks outside of indexes, he said.

Earlier this month, Fitch Ratings raised its outlook on Sime Darby to stable following a share sale, saying business has improved significantly. CIMB posted a 38 percent gain in first-half profit, following a slump a year earlier, and predicted a “better” performance in the second half.

“2017 is looking like it could generate about 7 percent to 8 percent corporate earnings growth,” said Gan. “Combined with 2 percent to 3 percent market yield, total return is around 10 percent.”

Gan bought real estate investment trusts and high dividend stocks amid a “low growth and low rate environment.” He’s also more selective in buying rather than broad-based. He bought CIMB for its turnaround of its Indonesian business, Sime Darby for a potential revamp, and Tenaga Nasional Bhd., the cheapest non-bank large-cap stocks. 

“Less is more,” he said. “A broader portfolio will end up with more bombs.”

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.