Brexit Hobbles Japan Inc. as Rising Yen Damps Profit Outlookby
Annual earnings headed for first decline in four years
Analysts cut Toyota estimate as yen climbs 10% since April 1
Japan Inc. is already counting the cost of Brexit. The yen’s extended surge after U.K.’s decision to exit the EU has turned the outlook for a gain in annual profit to the first decline in four years.
Take Toyota Motor Corp. Since the June 23 Brexit vote, the mean forecast for net income at the world’s biggest automaker has slid to $16.5 billion, with four analysts cutting their predictions by an average $2.3 billion for the fiscal year that started April 1. The referendum outcome triggered the yen’s biggest one-day advance in almost 18 years, taking its gain against the dollar in 2016 to 17 percent, the most among developed nations.
Profit estimates for Nissan Motor Co. and Canon Inc. were also cut by analysts after the referendum vote pushed up the yen, paring the value of income from overseas. Concern growth would slow in Europe is also casting a shadow on Japan’s exports and undermining Prime Minister Shinzo Abe’s effort to end deflation and spur expansion.
“Abenomics is finished,” said Takuji Okubo, Tokyo-based chief economist at Japan Macro Advisors. “The yen appreciation will be the largest impact from Brexit to Japan. Japanese corporate profits will decline and how much they will decline depends on how much the yen appreciates. There is significant risk the yen could increase very sharply to 90 yen against the dollar.”
Earnings at 200 of Japan’s largest companies would drop about 3.6 percent in the fiscal year, Daiwa Securities Group Inc. estimates, based on the yen averaging 100 against the dollar and 115 against the euro during the year. The currency traded at about 102 yen as of July 5. Should the dollar average 105 yen, current profit would drop 0.5 percent, Daiwa estimates.
“The yen is strengthening against several currencies and this is weighing heavily on earnings at Japanese automakers,” analysts led by Kota Yuzawa at Goldman Sachs Group Inc., wrote in a report. “We revise Goldman Sachs estimates following the U.K.’s referendum vote to leave the EU.” The company lowered its Toyota operating profit forecast by 21 percent to 1.78 trillion yen ($17.4 billion) for this fiscal year.
Toyota shares have slumped about 32 percent this year, almost double the 18 percent drop in the Nikkei 225 Stock Average. The stock was little changed Tuesday.
Toyota said its approach to maintaining production of 3 million vehicles in Japan hasn’t changed, and that its system isn’t dictated by “short-term factors such as exchange rates, regardless of how much the business environment fluctuates.” If analysts are right with their predictions, it would be Toyota’s first drop in profit in five years.
Canon declined to comment. Nissan said it desires exchange-rate stability and it is “always working to create a business structure that minimizes exchange-rate volatility.”
Suzuki Motor Corp. said the Indian rupee and the euro have the biggest impact on its earnings.
“We are going to cope with a stronger yen through further cost-cut efforts and local production,” Takashi Iwatsuki, a corporate director in charge of overseas sales at Suzuki, told shareholders at a meeting last week.
Wacoal Holdings Corp., a Japanese bra maker that got about a third of profit overseas last year, said it will consider moving its U.K. warehouse should Brexit cause tariffs to rise.
The prospect of lower profit is also adding to pressure on Bank of Japan Governor Haruhiko Kuroda to expand monetary stimulus at the central bank’s policy meeting later this month. Failing to take that step may make the yen rise even further, said Hiroaki Muto, chief economist at Tokai Tokyo Research Center.
More conservative profit forecasts would signal bleaker prospects for growth in key export markets including Europe, China and the U.S. Japan’s exports fell 11 percent in May, an eighth monthly decline as shipments to all three trading partners slumped.
“You’re in trouble if you’re exporting,” said Edwin Merner, president of Atlantis Investment Research Corp. in Tokyo. “If the currency changes slowly over a period of a couple of years you can adjust, but if it moves very quickly like it has, you cannot adjust so quickly -- it’s pretty serious.”
The Brexit vote may cost automakers worldwide about 2.8 million light-vehicle sales through 2018, researcher IHS Automotive said in its latest projections for the industry. Global stock markets that were whipsawed after the referendum may suffer more, according to Olav Chen, who oversees 80 billion kroner ($9.6 billion) at Storebrand Asset Management, a tactical asset allocation unit of Norway’s biggest listed life insurer.
Since Abe assumed office, corporate profits have been up for three years, while the Topix index has climbed 50 percent.
Some Japan Inc. stalwarts are benefiting. The shift in fortunes for manufacturers has boosted the relative market value of companies less affected by foreign exchange fluctuations. Three of Japan’s four biggest companies are now telecommunications carriers and analysts have increased earnings estimates for each of them following Brexit.
Still, there are concerns about growth in Europe in addition to the yen appreciation. Masataka Kunugimoto, an analyst with Nomura Securities Co., said in a report after the Brexit vote that the company has lowered growth forecasts for the European car market for this fiscal year and next. He also slashed his operating profit forecast for Toyota by 309 billion yen to 1.77 trillion yen.
“We have lowered our earnings forecasts on the Brexit vote, which we expect to lead to substantial yen appreciation,” Kunugimoto said in the report.