Costco, Citi Flooded With Complaints in Rocky Card Rolloutby and
Citigroup received 1.5 million customer calls in two days
Card switch ‘friction’ could slow Costco sales, analyst says
Costco Wholesale Corp. customers have deluged the retailer’s Facebook page with hundreds of complaints about a new credit card from Citigroup Inc., saying they endured lengthy wait times and had trouble activating accounts.
Costco, the world’s largest wholesale club, told customers that the bank is working to deal with a spate of calls about the new Costco Anywhere Visa cards. The cards were available for use starting on Monday.
“Due to high levels of interest in the Costco Anywhere Card and high volumes of calls from cardholders, callers to Citi should expect longer-than-desired hold times,” Costco said on the Facebook page. “Citi is reviewing processes and pulling in additional resources to alleviate hold times.”
Costco decided last year to end its 16-year relationship with American Express Co. after the firms couldn’t agree on card fees. Costco’s sales have slowed in recent months, disappointing analysts. One reason could be “friction” from the credit-card switch, Scott Mushkin, an analyst at Wolfe Research, said in a note to clients this month.
Costco shares slipped 0.7 percent to $157.03 in New York trading, the worst performance in the 36-company S&P 500 Consumer Staples Index.
One Costco customer said on the retailer’s Facebook page that she was on hold for three hours waiting to talk to a Citigroup representative. Another said that he was improperly billed for charges he already settled with AmEx. Dozens of customers posted that they still haven’t received their cards, and others said they were having trouble activating their accounts.
Jennifer Bombardier, a spokeswoman for New York-based Citigroup, apologized to customers who were inconvenienced. She said Citigroup had issued 11 million of the cards and received 1.5 million customer calls by late Wednesday.
“Some customers experienced delays reaching customer service,” Bombardier said in an e-mailed statement. “Call volumes are starting to return to normal and we are working diligently to meet their needs. In addition to phone service representatives, we also provide online activation.”
Marina Norville, a spokeswoman for AmEx, said the company has received calls from Costco customers and they’re directing them to Citigroup representatives.
Costco Chief Financial Officer Richard Galanti said wait times have dropped from an average of 30 to 40 minutes on Monday to less than 10 minutes late Thursday as Citi has increased the number of customer-service representatives taking calls to more than 2,000.
Galanti said two-thirds of cards have been activated and the company is working to address any remaining issues, including with 180,000 customers who didn’t get a card because it was mailed to the wrong address. While some customers have had trouble with the card, 100,000 customers who didn’t have the old card have signed up, he said.
"We don’t take it lightly, but we are trying to convey to people that this was well planned out," he said. "It is not without its issues but we are addressing them and working hard to do that."
The situation should be “manageable," said Michael Lasser, an analyst with UBS Group AG. Most of the 25 stores UBS called said they were having only isolated issues with the cards, he said, adding that the retailer has set up booths in stores to provide temporary cards to customers who haven’t received one.
“While the mild disruption suggests June sales expectations should be held in check, these issues should be resolved rather quickly," Lasser said in a note to clients.
Citigroup, the world’s biggest credit-card lender, ranked second-to-last out of 10 companies in a J.D. Power credit-card customer satisfaction ranking last year. AmEx slid to second place behind Discover Financial Services after holding the top spot in the first eight years of the survey.
Analysts have been counting on Costco’s new partnership with Citigroup and Visa to help the retailer cut costs. Morgan Stanley analyst Simeon Gutman estimated that 25 percent of Costco’s sales were made using the AmEx card, which carried a fee of 0.6 percent, costing the company $180 million a year. With Visa, Gutman expects the fees to fall to 0.1 percent to 0.4 percent, saving $60 million to $150 million a year for Costco. He was looking for the company to use the savings to offer better deals to customers.