Wall Street's Pile of Unwanted Treasuries Exposes Market Cracks

Updated on
  • Firms' holdings in February reached highest since 2013
  • Ripple effects seen in repos, futures, harder-to-trade debt

Wall Street Is Stuck With Unwanted Treasuries

The world’s biggest bond dealers are getting saddled with Treasuries they can’t seem to easily get rid of, adding to evidence of cracks in the $13.3 trillion market for U.S. government debt.

The 22 primary dealers held more Treasuries last month than any time in the last two years, Federal Reserve Bank of New York data show. While at first glance that may suggest a bullish stance, the surge in holdings is more likely the result of investors including central banks dumping the debt on the firms, said JPMorgan Chase & Co. strategist Jay Barry. Foreign official accounts sold a net $105 billion of the securities in December and January, an unprecedented liquidation, Treasury Department data show.

Strategists say there are signs that the buildup of Treasuries held by dealers is having a ripple effect, mucking up the plumbing of the financial system. While the holdings show they did their job by soaking up the supply from central banks raising cash to support their currencies, it’s adding to questions about the resilience of the world’s most important market. The Treasury Department is already looking into whether the market isn’t operating as smoothly as it should.

Surging Holdings

“This was a lot of dealers doing what they are supposed to do -- provide liquidity,” said Scott Buchta, head of fixed-income strategy at Brean Capital LLC in New York. “But the liquidity providers right now are getting the short end of the stick. It’s harder for dealers to offload these securities because the market depth just isn’t there.”

Primary dealers’ stash of Treasuries reached as high as $121 billion last month, the most since October 2013 and up from about $9 billion in July of last year. They held $111 billion as of March 9, almost double the average for the last five years.

As the world’s biggest bond dealers -- including banks such as Bank of America Corp., Goldman Sachs Group Inc. and JPMorgan -- struggled to get rid of the burgeoning pile of debt, the premium for the newest, easiest-to-trade Treasuries soared to the highest since 2011. The firms’ efforts to hedge all the Treasuries collecting on their balance sheets also roiled the futures market and a crucial corner of the financial system where traders lend and borrow securities overnight.

Under Pressure

All of this has been happening as the bond-trading business has been coming under pressure. Last year, the world’s biggest banks generated the lowest revenue from fixed-income products since 2008, according to research firm Coalition Development Ltd. Critics contend that regulations enacted since the financial crisis, such as increasing capital requirements and curtailing leverage, restrict dealers’ willingness to make markets.

Officials say the rules have made the financial system safer. The Treasury Department is conducting its first comprehensive review of the government-debt market’s structure since 1998. The review was prompted by a 12-minute plunge and rebound in yields on Oct. 15, 2014.

“Without question, the reforms adopted following the crisis have created a stronger, more resilient system,” Antonio Weiss, counselor to Treasury secretary Jack Lew, said in prepared comments March 16 in Washington.

Upheaval Evidence

Dealers moved to minimize the risk of holding so many tough-to-unload securities by selling, or shorting, benchmark notes, said Barry of JPMorgan. They had the biggest bearish position in the newest 30-year bonds since May in the week ended March 9, according to a Credit Agricole SA analysis of New York Fed data.

Part of the fallout was seen in the $1.6 trillion market for repurchase agreements, or repos, where Wall Street goes to exchange securities for overnight cash.

The combination of dealer demand, a global government-debt rally and reduced auction sizes caused a shortage in the repo market for the securities needed to close short positions in 10-year debt. Failures to deliver 10-year notes surged in the week ended March 9 to the most since at least 2013. For all Treasuries, failures reached the highest since the financial crisis, New York Fed data show.

QuickTake The Repo Market

Demand was so great for the benchmark 10-year note that its repo rate traded at about negative 3 percent for more than a week, before an auction of the debt settled March 15 and eased the shortage. At that level, the cost of borrowing the security in the repo market was steeper than the 3 percent penalty for uncompleted trades, leading more traders to opt to let deals fail.

“We haven’t seen anything at this sort of scale in three years,” said Barry, an interest-rate strategist at JPMorgan in New York.

The distortions extended into prices of cash Treasuries as well, as dealers’ efforts to unload their older, toughest-to-trade securities depressed prices of that debt. On March 2, the premium that the most liquid, newest securities, known as on-the-run notes, commanded over off-the-run securities reached the highest since 2011, data compiled by Bloomberg show.

Old debt was selling at such a deep discount that the typical buyers of those bonds -- money managers and pension funds who tend to hold them for long periods -- probably chose to stay away, said Gennadiy Goldberg, a New York-based interest-rate strategist for TD Securities (USA) LLC, a primary dealer.

Buying off-the-run debt is “normally a great trade, but when that spread widens from 3 basis points to 8 basis points, you don’t want to touch it, because you’re afraid it will widen from 8 to 12,” Goldberg said. “Dealers were stuck warehousing it.”

The increase in dealer ownership was most pronounced in Treasuries maturing in 11 or more years, for which holdings reached a record last month. Hedging of those positions widened the yield gap between 30-year bond futures and 30-year “ultra” futures, which are a better hedge for that maturity, according to David Keeble, New York-based head of fixed-income strategy at Credit Agricole. That spread grew as dealers bet on declines in the ultras.

Easing Up

There are signs that the dislocations have abated. The gap between prices of new and old securities has fallen closer to its average for the past year, and in the repo market, 10-year Treasuries are no longer what’s known as “on special.” Dealers that lend cash in exchange for the notes in these deals now receive interest, since the repo rate is positive.

Bond bulls can also take heart in how the stress on the system didn’t slow the rush into U.S. government debt this year. Treasuries maturing in greater than a year have earned 1.7 percent in 2016 as stocks slumped to start the year amid concern global economic growth was cooling, Bloomberg Treasury bond index data show. The Treasury 10-year note yield rose four basis points, or 0.04 percentage point, to 1.91 percent as of 1 p.m. New York time.

In a twist, the demand for U.S. debt that drove 10-year yields toward record lows in February may have contributed to the strains, Keeble said. Buyers of Treasuries who typically don’t lend out securities in the repo market may have bought benchmark 10-year securities as a haven, he said.

For George Goncalves, head of rates research at primary dealer Nomura Securities Inc. in New York, dealers already holding so much debt may have less capacity to absorb more rounds of selling in the future.

“If there is another round of bond selloff, the market will need real-money support to keep everything orderly,” he said in a March 17 research note.

— With assistance by Lukanyo Mnyanda, Robert Gee, and Andrea Wong

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal. LEARN MORE