Saudi Banks Show Signs of Stress With Stocks Cheaper Than Assetsby
Price-to-book ratio of Saudi banks near lowest in 10 Years
Lenders punished on outlook for more bad loans, outflows: SIC
Saudi banking stocks have fallen to the lowest levels in at least a decade relative to their net assets, showing the slump in oil is stoking concern that bad loans will increase.
Following a 10 percent slide since the start of the year, an index of 12 lenders on the Tadawul All Share Index is trading at an average 1.3 times book value, near the weakest since Bloomberg started tracking the data in 2006. Four of those have fallen below their net assets, compared with two in December, while two others are trading at multiples of just above 1. They include Samba Financial Group and Riyad Bank, the nation’s third- and fourth-biggest banks.
Investors are punishing financial stocks because “there’s an expectation of non-performing loans going up and for deposit outflows to continue,” said Chiradeep Ghosh, a research manager at Manama-based Securities & Investment Co. This “suggests banks will have to pay more to get their funding back. A weak economic environment would also impact the banks’ brokerages and investment banking businesses,” he said.
Still, NPLs made up just 1.2 percent of total loans held by Saudi banks at the end of September, while lenders have set aside provisions for more than the debt is worth, central bank data show. Banks should therefore be able to absorb a “reasonable amount” of toxic credit, according to Ghosh, who called valuations “very attractive.” Brent crude rebounded 8 percent last week, including a surge that happened after Saudi markets closed on Thursday.
The Tadawul, whose price-to-book ratio of 1.4 is still higher than the MSCI Emerging Markets Index, has fallen about 34 percent in the past year, making it the third worst performing market tracked worldwide by Bloomberg. The price of oil, the kingdom’s primary revenue source, retreated about a third in London over that period, forcing Saudi Arabia to scale back spending.
The slow-down in deposit growth is credit-negative for the nation’s lenders, Moody’s Investors Service said in a Jan. 28 report. The rating company expects non-performing loans to increase to 2.5 percent of total loans over the next 12 months.