Fears Over 35,000 Jobs Stand Between Lonmin and Survivalby
Situation `politically explosive'; cuts can cause instability
Job losses risk deepening rift between companies, government
To survive the slump in platinum prices, Lonmin Plc may need to reduce production. The trouble is, it will mean fewer jobs in a country that can’t afford to lose any.
With prices of the metal near six-year lows, the current plan to raise $400 million in a share sale could prove inadequate, said Arqaam Capital Ltd. and Avior Capital Markets Pty Ltd. That would put Lonmin on a collision course with the government of South Africa, where one in four workers is unemployed.
More job losses risk deepening a rift between the government of the world’s biggest platinum producer and mining companies, which already plan to fire as many as 19,000 workers as commodity prices decline, costs surge and the economy is close to recession. The ruling African National Congress is under pressure to placate its labor-union allies, create 6 millions jobs by 2019, and stem a loss of support to opposition groups such as the Economic Freedom Fighters, which has campaigned on promises to nationalize mines.
“It’s a politically explosive situation because job losses can trigger social instability,” Mzukisi Qobo, an associate professor at the University of Johannesburg, said by phone Thursday. “There is going to be a fallout. While some actors within government understand the dire situation that Lonmin is faced with, the rest have absolutely no clue.”
In July, Gwede Mantashe, secretary general of the ANC, branded mining companies as “lazy” for firing staff rather than considering alternatives. Mining executives say the politicians’ stance, together with prolonged uncertainty over laws and an unreliable power supply, threatens their companies’ survival. The industry employs about 440,000 people locally and makes up more than half the nation’s exports.
For Lonmin, crippled by a five-month labor strike last year and a 58 percent drop in the platinum price since it peaked in March 2008, scaling back to focus on its most profitable assets is its only survival option, said Richard Hart, an analyst at Arqaam Capital in Johannesburg.
“The rights issue in our opinion is just plugging the hole for two years and then they’re in a cash problem again,” Hart said. “The business plan is entirely predicated upon a recovery in platinum prices. We don’t see that happening soon.”
Lonmin should reduce annual output by two-thirds to 250,000 ounces and outsource refining, said Adrian Williams, an analyst at Avior. This will result in a similar-sized cut to the workforce of 35,000 people, he said.
“If survival is what you want, then this is your answer,” Williams said. “Rather cut off the leg, or maybe both legs that are gangrenous and let the body survive.”
Lonmin has already cut 2,600 positions in the year to September. Further reductions will add as much as $150 million to its expenses and won’t be well received, Barclays Plc analysts Andrew Byrne and Ian Rossouw said.
“We question whether the government will allow these necessary shaft closures,” they wrote in a Nov. 5 note. If the capital raising is successful, it will “simply prolong the financial stress of the broader industry and potentially jeopardize the sustainability of the other 1.5 million ounces produced in the region and associated 100,000 jobs,” they wrote.
So far, the Public Investment Corp., which looks after South African state employees’ pensions and is the continent’s largest money manager, is the only investor backing the share sale and will underwrite an unspecified “material portion” of it.
It’s “the best decision under the current circumstances,” the Pretoria-based PIC said by e-mail. “Not supporting Lonmin could put the company at risk and it could potentially be harmful to the industry and the communities where Lonmin operates as well as the economy at large.”
Lonmin dropped 14 percent to 17 pence at 11:13 a.m. in London, extending losses for the year to 90 percent.
Ayanda Shezi, a spokeswoman for the Department of Mineral Resources, said by e-mail she couldn’t immediately comment.
Lonmin may “cease trading” should the refinancing plan fail, the Johannesburg-based company said in a letter to shareholders. While it can also sell assets, there will be “no certainty” that could be done “in the available timeframe on acceptable terms, or at all,” it said.
In August, the government, mining companies and unions adopted a 10-point plan to try curb job losses, which included finding buyers for distressed assets that could be run profitably under different management.
The Association of Mineworkers and Construction Union, which is the biggest representative of platinum employees, didn’t sign the proposals. It’s monitoring developments at Lonmin, spokesman Manzini Zungu said.
“It is of concern to us,” he said by phone. “We have people who work there who support families.”