India Targets Century-Old Bankruptcy Law to Revive Momentumby
Finance Ministry to receive recommendations on law this week
To deepen corporate bond market and finance long-term infra
Prime Minister Narendra Modi is poised to overhaul Indian bankruptcy laws that date back a century in a bid to get his reform agenda back on track after a series of setbacks.
This week a government-backed committee plans to submit recommendations to the Finance Ministry for a bill that may be tabled during the parliament session starting next month. Unifying more than four overlapping sets of rules, the code aims to slash the time it takes to wind up a dying company or recover dues from a defaulter.
“People who thrive on delays will suffer," T.K. Vishwanathan, head of the drafting panel, said in an interview in New Delhi. “The current law is creditor-unfriendly. We will balance it."
Modi has seen his reform agenda stall in recent months, leading to declines in stocks and the currency as China’s slowdown leads to increased global volatility. Opponents have blocked a vote on a national sales tax first proposed in 2006, and Modi backtracked in August on moves to make it easier for companies to acquire land for development projects.
"Investor patience is running out and the government needs to push through at least one big-banner reform," Kaushik Das, an economist at Deutsche Bank AG, wrote in an Oct. 15 report. "The bankruptcy code will help reorganize a stressed business in a short span of time without endless litigation which erodes the viability of an enterprise."
Under India’s current bankruptcy laws, individuals can go to jail for failing to repay just 500 rupees ($8), the cost of about two Starbucks espressos. Under what passes for insolvency protection for companies, firms need to wait until at least half of their value is wiped out before seeking any help from the government.
Creditors in India recover about 25.7 cents on the dollar in the 4.3 years that it takes to resolve insolvency, World Bank data show, compared with 80.4 cents in the U.S. after less than half that time. The inability to collect on dues has also locked up funds at banks, with stressed assets at the highest level in more than a decade.
The new law will tackle this by providing information on creditworthiness "at the touch of a button," Vishwanathan said. Experts brought in to revive or wind up an ailing company would be strictly regulated to avoid malpractices, such as support for management that’s out to defraud creditors or deny employees their rights.
A crucial aspect of the bankruptcy code is protection for unsecured creditors. Bringing such investors under the law would give them more confidence to lend to long-term projects such as building roads, ports and power plants, according to Raghuram Rajan, governor of India’s central bank.
“Failure is inevitable in a free enterprise system," Rajan said in a speech last month. He called for a “speedy bankruptcy code” to resolve distress while still maintaining the priority structure of claims.
About half of India’s 575 stalled projects are stuck due to policy related issues, HSBC Holdings Plc estimates. Formalizing an effective bankruptcy code, setting up tribunals to tackle financial distress and recover debt are therefore among critical reforms needed, economists Pranjul Bhandari wrote in an Oct. 5 report.
Companies in India now can only get help if they’ve been operating for at least five years. They are declared “sick" only if they’ve accumulated losses exceeding net worth, and identified as ailing if they lose 50 percent of its value or fail to repay debts for three consecutive quarters.
An individual can seek rescue -- or face charges -- if he’s unable to repay a debt of 500 rupees. Even the clothes off his children’s back can be seized as long as they cost more than 300 rupees, according to the clauses of the Presidency Towns Insolvency Act, 1909.
Apart from archaic rules, such cases are judged by overburdened district courts that lack the expertise to deal with the details, Vishwanathan said. His new bill would propose creating Debt Recovery Tribunals similar to those in the U.S. and U.K.
“This will help us promote entrepreneurship as youngsters will be able to take risks," Vishwanathan said. “At the same time, we will see that interests of creditors are not compromised."