Do Malaysia, South Africa Deserve Junk? Moody's Model Says Yesby
Malaysia, South Africa, Turkey, Kazakhstan perceived as junk
Implied ratings based on CDS differ from official grades
Six developing nations including Malaysia and South Africa deserve to follow Brazil into junk status, if credit-default-swaps traders are to be believed.
Two weeks after the Latin American country lost its investment grade at one of the three major ratings providers, CDS investors are punishing other emerging markets facing similar challenges, sending their implied ratings at least five levels below their official grades, according to data from Moody’s Corp. Malaysia is A3 at the company, though traders see it six levels lower at Ba3. South Africa, which is a Baa2, is viewed as a B1 borrower. Three Aa3 nations including China are perceived by the markets as deserving the lowest investment grade.
Most developing nations are confronting the same issues that saw Brazil losing its investment-grade rating at Standard & Poor’s -- a plunge in commodity prices, a slumping currency and political turmoil. Sputtering growth in China and the prospect of higher U.S. interest rates are also boosting concern of more downgrades across emerging markets. Having been censured for laxity during previous market meltdowns, the ratings providers won’t want to be caught failing to act this time round, Per Hammarlund of SEB AB said.
“The deterioration in commodity-dependent economies’ credit-risk metrics can lead to more downgrades in emerging markets in the next three to six months, if not earlier,” said Hammarlund, the chief emerging-markets strategist at SEB in Stockholm. “The rating agencies were roundly criticized for being slow to react during the 2008 crisis as well as the 2011 euro-zone crisis. They are going to be much more trigger happy this time.”
While investors don’t always agree with official grades, the gaps for these nine countries are some of the biggest among the 65 borrowers tracked by Moody’s implied-ratings model, which is based on CDS prices as of Sept. 21 compared with peers in the same ratings category. While the investors’ ever-changing opinions are not an input into the ratings decisions, the company’s analysts study them to understand why the gaps exist, according to Moody’s.
“Market-implied ratings tend to ‘lead’ Moody’s ratings, given financial markets’ propensity to instantaneously incorporate information,” Irina Baron, an assistant director at Moody’s Capital Markets Research Group, said by e-mail.
Finance-ministry officials in Chile and Malaysia didn’t respond to requests for remarks. A National Treasury spokeswoman in South Africa declined to comment. Middle Eastern and Turkish governments were closed for the Eid holiday.
“Calculating an implicit market rating based on the price of CDS as a proxy to measure the fundamental credit rating of a country is not appropriate,” Peru’s Finance Ministry said in a message to Bloomberg. “Peru’s CDS is highly correlated to its peers in the region such as Chile, Colombia and Mexico,” the ministry said,
Political disputes are a key hindrance to investors’ perception of emerging-market creditworthiness. Protesters in Malaysia are calling for Prime Minister Najib Razak’s resignation over a funding scandal and Turkish politicians are preparing for premature elections after failing to form a coalition government.
Depressed oil prices have hurt producers. Saudi Arabia is heading for the biggest budget deficit in almost three decades, while the shortfall in Bahrain is forecast to double this year from 2014. Although Bahrain may retain its investment grade this year, it remains vulnerable to a downgrade because of fiscal challenges, Bank of America Merrill Lynch economist Jean-Michel Saliba said in a note Thursday.
The risk of a default by Kazakhstan within 12 months is at a historical high, according to Bloomberg’s sovereign-risk model.
Even as investor pessimism pervades these nine nations, Brazil, too, may be at risk of more downgrades as confidence wanes in President Dilma Rousseff’s economic policies. The country, which still has investment grades at Moody’s and Fitch Ratings, saw its implied ratings trade six steps below the official level.
The Malaysian ringgit, South African rand and Turkish lira were the worst performers against the dollar on Thursday among 24 emerging-market currencies tracked by Bloomberg.