Draghi's QE Dispenses Unwanted Results to European Stock Buyers

Updated on
  • All but 2 in Euro Stoxx 50 have lower valuations versus March
  • What else will it take, asks Morgan Stanley's Graham Secker

Is Draghi's ECB QE Reset Enough to Help Europe?

Mario Draghi’s stimulus program hasn’t quite succeeded at unleashing the desired animal spirits across Europe. Here’s the evidence: six months in, and 96 percent of companies in the Euro Stoxx 50 Index have actually gotten cheaper relative to earnings.

The European Central Bank’s plan to flood the financial system with cash by purchasing bonds was supposed to ignite the same celebration of risk-taking it did in the U.S. six years ago. In fact, the opposite has happened, culminating in as much as $526 billion of share values being wiped out last month.

The failure of European quantitative easing to improve sentiment toward equities is a troubling sign to bulls as markets from Shanghai to New York endure their worst selloffs since 2011. Rather than set Europe apart as a haven, Draghi’s program has been marginalized in the stock market by events such as Greece’s credit impasse. The Euro Stoxx 50 lost 9.2 percent in August amid concern China’s economy will subdue global growth. It rebounded 0.6 percent on Monday, following a weekly drop.

Very Nervous

“People get very nervous when they feel there are no more policy levers left,” Graham Secker, Morgan Stanley’s head of European equity strategy, said by phone from London. “Investor confidence is extremely low at the moment, and everyone wants to de-risk. They don’t see who is going to ride to the rescue.”

Going by economic data, Europe is making progress. Unemployment in the region unexpectedly fell, while German manufacturing expanded at a faster pace. Economists project Europe’s gross domestic product will grow 1.5 percent this year, the most since 2011. And analysts still predict profits for companies in the currency bloc will increase 12 percent this year.

The figures are doing little to help stocks. In the latest rout, valuations in the Euro Stoxx 50 fell to 12.4 times projected earnings, compared with 15.3 when Draghi’s program started in March. Dragged down by exporters and commodity stocks, the gauge has tumbled 13 percent in the last four weeks -- almost twice as much as the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index, where price-earnings ratios are about 19 percent higher.

Europe Automakers

Europe’s carmakers-- the companies that have most benefited from the depreciation in the euro -- have seen valuations decline as much as 34 percent since this year’s peak. A similar drop occurred in energy share valuations, and a gauge of chemical stocks became 22 percent cheaper. France’s Vinci SA and Vivendi SA stand out as the only two companies in the Euro Stoxx 50 that trade at higher multiples than then.

While the U.S. is trailing most developed-market stock indexes in 2015, its experiment with QE helped the S&P 500 post nine consecutive quarters of gains, the longest streak since 1998. At its May record, the gauge had jumped more than threefold from its 2009 low.

When stimulus moved to Europe, stock investors followed. The region’s shares enjoyed their best start to a year in almost two decades, with money flowing into European equity funds at a record pace. But after the Euro Stoxx 50 reached an almost seven-year high in April, crises from Greece to China quieted bulls and took the Euro Stoxx 50 down 17 percent from its peak.

Catching Colds

“Is Europe the region that catches everyone’s colds?” said David Hussey, head of European equities at Manulife Asset Management in London. “The economic recovery and bounce in corporate profits that the U.S. has seen in the last five years has not yet occurred in Europe. It will always be heavily influenced by events globally.”

Morgan Stanley is among those telling investors to buy the dip. Secker predicts stock prices will catch up with earnings once confidence returns, rather than the other way round. The bank recommends investing in stocks such as Deutsche Post AG and semiconductor equipment maker ASML Holding NV after their valuations fell more than 22 percent from recent peaks.

“It’s just really confusing -- there’s nothing on the economic or earnings horizon that looks bad for Europe,” said Teis Knuthsen, chief investment officer at Saxo Bank A/S’s private-banking unit in Hellerup, Denmark. “The selloff was not economic stress, it was financial stress. Now a lot of good companies look far too cheap if you consider that not much has changed on the fundamental side.”

Fed Rate

The danger is that they stay cheap with the Federal Reserve preparing to raise interest rates even after the International Monetary Fund said the outlook for global expansion is worse than it anticipated less than two months ago. Traders are pricing in a 30 percent chance rates will rise this month.

“China is threatening to slow down global growth at a time when the Fed is going to tighten,” said Luca Paolini, Pictet Asset Management’s chief strategist in London. “That’s not a good environment at all. The ECB can’t hold up the recovery on its own, and fundamentals have definitely deteriorated. European earnings aren’t safe from this.”