Walking Oil Rigs Spur Cheaper, Quicker Drilling in Supply Glutby
Per-rig production up 40% since crude price plunge began
Drillers "incentivized to continue'' by improved equipment
Have you ever seen an oil rig walk?
Some of the newest rigs can travel hundreds of yards to the next well under their own power, lurching along like 150-foot-tall robots on hydraulic legs that raise the equipment five inches at a time, nudging forward at about a foot per minute. While that sounds slow, it is faster and cheaper than dismantling a rig and trucking the parts to a new site nearby.
More efficient drilling rigs that cost a third less than just a year earlier are changing the face of the U.S. shale industry, helping boost per-rig output in the four largest fields by at least 40 percent since the crude price plunge began in 2014. While helping producers pump more oil, the new rigs have a downside. Companies such as Helmerich & Payne Inc., Nabors Industries Ltd. and Patterson-UTI Energy Inc. that provide the equipment face investor concern that the improvements they’ve made might translate into fewer sales in the future.
Producers “are being incentivized to continue drilling to keep cash coming in the door because costs have come down so much,” Rob Desai, an analyst at Edward Jones in St. Louis, said in a telephone interview. “Even though the rig count is down by half, you can do more with the half that’s still working.”
Even though the number of rigs has dropped by more than half since prices began falling in June of last year, U.S. output is down just 3.3 percent from a four-decade high.
The rigs aren’t the only factors increasing efficiency in U.S. oil fields. Over the past few years, service companies such as Schlumberger Ltd. and Halliburton Co. have also been crafting more efficient systems to complete wells, including the use of 3-D seismic imaging that can track where cracks are going in the oil-soaked rock underground.
The newest rigs, though, are making a substantial difference at a time when producers, historically heavy users of debt to fund exploration, need to keep cash flowing as prices remain mired below $50 a barrel.
West Texas Intermediate crude lost 7.7 percent to $45.41 on the New York Mercantile Exchange. Helmerich & Payne and Nabors each fell 5.2 percent in New York while Patterson dropped 5.7 percent after Wells Fargo downgraded the rig contractor to the equivalent of a hold from a buy.
Anadarko Petroleum Corp. plans to boost the number of horizontal wells it drills this year in Colorado’s Wattenberg play to more than 380 from about 360 last year, employing just a little more than half the number of rigs it used in 2014, said John Christiansen, a spokesman for The Woodlands, Texas-based producer.
“Technology continues to improve and enhance the way we’re able to do things,” Christiansen said. “The walking rig is another evolution in that process.”
Rigs have been improving since the shale revolution began almost a decade ago. The so-called AC rigs of today run on alternating current, enabling drillers to tweak the power going to different components, such as
the mud pumps that shoot fluid into the well and the top drive that controls the drilling. The older, mechanical rigs were less accommodating, with a series of belts and pulleys that powered all of the components equally.
The most advanced rigs are likely to be the first ones put back to work once drilling activity starts to pick up again, according to a May 13 report from Bloomberg Intelligence.
"Fewer rigs may be needed to bring oil production back up to late-2014 levels as time and technology progress," Andrew Cosgrove and William Foiles, analysts at Bloomberg Intelligence, wrote in a June 22 report.
The walking rigs allow producers to take advantage of a new system of “pad” drilling in which clusters of wells are drilled within a small area. Giving the rigs mobility cuts both costs and time in moving them, said James West, an analyst at investment bank Evercore ISI in New York.
At the same time, the day rate for renting the most advanced rigs has fallen to about $20,000 from a high of as much as $30,000 last year, according to West. With the price of oil down, equipment suppliers have had to trim their own prices to stay competitive.
While newer technologies will cannibalize some rig demand, there will still be a need for a wide variety of rigs, said Sean Roach, vice president of drilling systems and services at Schramm Inc., a West Chester, Pennsylvania-based maker of walking rigs. Shale producers are taking the toolbox approach to drilling, with a variety of rigs for different types of wells, he said.
Nonetheless, Desai of Edward Jones said he doesn’t see how drilling contractors will be able to keep expanding their rig fleets after the rollout of new, more sophisticated rigs over the past few years.
“We need fewer rigs than we did a while ago for the same amount of production,” he said. “That is kind of a long-term fear we have for the onshore drilling market.”
(A previous version of this story corrected the description of the hydraulic walking legs.)