Vale Earnings Fall to Six-Year Low as China Steel Boom Fades

Vale SA earnings slumped to the lowest since 2009, in line with estimates, as the world’s largest iron-ore producer faces shrinking Chinese steel demand.

First-quarter adjusted earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, or Ebitda, dropped 61 percent to $1.6 billion from a year earlier, the Rio de Janeiro-based company said Thursday. That compared with the $1.55 billion average of 11 estimates compiled by Bloomberg and was the lowest Ebitda since the second quarter of 2009.

Top global miners including Vale, Rio Tinto Group and BHP Billiton Ltd. are raising output of the steelmaking ingredient, a strategy aimed at capturing market share from smaller, higher-cost rivals. That’s coinciding with an unexpected contraction in Chinese steel demand, resulting in a supply glut that sent prices to the lowest in a decade.

Profit, excluding cash generated by a gold deal signed in March, fell short of estimates from BB&T Corp. analyst Garrett Nelson, who said the company generates “very slim margins” in iron ore.

“We were expecting some bad results but this was even worse than expected,” Nelson said by telephone from Richmond, Virginia. “It’s an ugly release.”

On a net basis, Vale reported a quarterly loss of $3.12 billion compared with net income of $2.52 billion a year ago.

Currency Loss

The shares of the company led by Chief Executive Officer Murilo Ferreira fell 0.7 percent to 16.97 reais at 10:51 a.m. in Sao Paulo. The stock declined 36 percent in the last 12 months.

“Weak market fundamentals continued to undermine prices, with soft demand from Chinese steel mills and strong seaborne supply,” Vale said in a statement released before the start of trading in Brazil. “We expect some improvements in the Chinese steel demand as the property sector responds” to current government easing measures and possible new action.

The Brazilian real was the world’s worst-performing major currency in the past six months, prompting Vale to report net losses in three consecutive quarters as costs to serve its $24.8 billion net debt increased. First-quarter capital expenditure was $2.2 billion, down $377 million from a year earlier.

Sales declined 34 percent to $6.24 billion in the quarter compared with the $7.42 billion average of 11 analysts’ estimates compiled by Bloomberg. Vale sold its iron ore at an average $46.01 a metric ton, down from $94.79 a year earlier. Selling prices for copper also fell and nickel was stable.

While iron ore entered a bull market last week after BHP said it will defer port works in Australia, benchmark prices averaged about half the value of a year earlier. Ore with 62 percent content at Qingdao, China, fell 1.7 percent to $56.18 a ton Thursday, according to Metal Bulletin Ltd. On Tuesday the price reached the highest since March 4.

Oversupplied Market

“We continue to see an oversupplied iron-ore market ahead and view the recent recovery in spot prices as transitory,” Banco Santander SA analysts led by Felipe Reis in Sao Paulo said in a note Wednesday. “China finally will enter a period of lower production, negatively affecting iron-ore demand.”

Steel consumption in the Asian country is set to decline this year as demand from the property, auto, ship and appliance industries weakens, the China Iron and Steel Association said Wednesday, adding that the country’s apparent crude steel demand fell 6 percent in the first quarter.

Vale, the largest nickel producer, also said shipments of the base metal grew 4.6 percent to 68,000 tons in the first quarter while copper volumes jumped to 98,000 tons.

(Vale is hosting a conference call with analysts on Thursday at 11 a.m. New York time. An earlier call was a 9 a.m. Details here.)

Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.
LEARN MORE