Speed Traders Make Peanuts in Profits From Economic DataAnnabelle Ju
High-frequency traders treat the latest economic reports like predators stalking their prey, pouncing in tiny fractions of a second to buy or sell according to whether it was good news or bad.
For all the preparation and high technology, a new academic paper suggests they’re not minting money in the stock market.
Emory University researchers examined how much the fastest firms earn with two key financial products in the moments after major U.S. economic data comes out. In aggregate, algorithmic traders made about $24,000 per event with the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust and $75,000 with E-mini S&P 500 futures contracts, the academics found. That pales in comparison to the $100 million of total trading after such reports, according to the paper.
“They’re not able to make a lot of money from exploiting slow investors following macroeconomic news,” Clifton Green, an associate professor of finance at Emory and one of three authors of the paper, said in a phone interview. “Concerns that they’re exploiting slow investors may be overstated.”
High-frequency traders have been the target of critics who say they use the fastest systems to gain an advantage over other market participants. A subset of those firms aim to make money by being the first to react to the latest news. (Bloomberg LP, the parent company of this news organization, gives traders access to economic reports.)
Because of the substantial investments they’ve made in deploying the most advanced trading systems, they can react to fresh information within tiny slices of a second -- in times measured in millionths of a second or even billionths.
The researchers -- Green, Tarun Chordia and Badrinath Kottimukkalur of Emory University in Atlanta -- only examined an exchange-traded fund and futures contract tracking the Standard & Poor’s 500 Index. Traders can and do buy and sell other stocks and derivatives following economic releases. The paper didn’t examine those products.
The findings indicate profits from event-driven trading may not be substantial -- or at least not for any given economic report. “Although algorithmic traders respond swiftly and convincingly to macro news releases, we find the economic benefits of trading on announcement surprises are modest,” according to the paper.
Income from such trading has shrunk because there’s more competition, Green said. The study found that during the span of 2008 to 2013, the smallest annual earnings were generated in the most recent year.
“The idea is that there’s nobody left to exploit,” he said. “So, people willing to trade or trying to trade are both moving quickly in response to the news.”