In Mumbai, Eating That Steak Could Cost 5 Years in JailSiddharth Philip and Adi Narayan
A prime filet mignon at New York’s Old Homestead Steakhouse will set you back $56. Wolfgang Puck’s Cut in London charges as much as $210 for a ribeye. In Tokyo, a sirloin can top $250.
But nowhere is a juicy piece of beef as dear as in Mumbai, where it can now cost you five years in prison.
The government of the state of Maharashtra this week banned possession of beef and its byproducts and the slaughtering of cows, bulls and bullocks. The prohibition marks a victory for hard-line Hindu groups that have sought to protect an animal their religion considers holy.
“This is not the sign of a maturing society,” said Avinash Raheja, an angel investor and founder of Mumbai car-parking app Veh2Park who does not eat beef. “We claim to be the world’s biggest democracy, but does democracy apply only to the right to choose our electoral candidate?”
The hashtag #BeefBan became a trending topic on Twitter, prompting scores of jokes and memes. The move risks appearing to enforce conservative Hindu principles on Muslim and Christian minorities in a nation of 1.2 billion, according to Shiv Visvanathan, a professor at the O.P. Jindal Global University’s school of government and public policy near Delhi.
“The real battle of prohibition today will not be against alcohol; it will be against meat,” Viswanathan said. “Many landlords won’t rent a house if you eat meat. That is also a way of throwing Muslims out.”
The law was originally proposed in 1995 when Maharashtra was run by a coalition of pro-Hindu parties.
“We welcome the decision of the Maharashtra government,” Surendra Jain, joint general secretary of the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, a religious group that advocates scrapping legal privileges for religious minorities and banning cow slaughter nationwide, said in an e-mail. “We hope other governments will follow.”
While beef and pork are taboo at many Indian eateries, including McDonald’s Corp. and Burger King outlets, some Mumbai restaurants do serve beef and others offer it off the menu.
“If I show beef on the menu, lots of people may not enter,” said P.K. Krishnan, who runs a restaurant specializing in south Indian-cuisine in the Mahim working-class neighborhood. Yet he sells as much as 12 kilograms (26 pounds) of beef daily, mostly in a spicy chili-fry dish popular in Kerala state.
Line Out the Door
In Imbiss, in the upscale Bandra neighborhood, owner Bruce Rodrigues caters to patrons who put up with a cramped room and air thick with the smell of bacon to tuck into 165 rupee ($2.60) burgers and 265 rupee steaks. After the state’s chief minister announced the ban on March 3, his 10-table place was overwhelmed.
“There were people waiting outside, and that’s quite unusual for a Tuesday afternoon,” said Rodrigues, who was a bank manager before starting the restaurant three years ago. “Some regulars came by asking if they can participate in a protest or something.”
It’s not just steaks and hamburgers. Most of the cows’ offal -- spleen, liver, kidneys and tongue -- is sold to street vendors who mix it with soups and rice to sell to poor locals who can’t afford any other meat.
A bowl of chickpea soup mixed with a piece of grilled beef spleen sells for as little as 10 rupees, said Sultan Shaikh, who been runs a sidewalk stall in the Mahim neighborhood. Most of the customers tend to be Muslims, he said.
“This is the cheapest source of protein” among meat products, said Mohammad Ali Qureshi, president of the Bombay Suburban Beef Dealers Association. “For a poor man, one kilo of beef is enough to provide two meals for his family. All are looking at it from the religious angle and not the economic angle.”
India exports $4 billion of beef annually, almost all of it from buffalo. During his election campaign, Prime Minister Narendra Modi criticized the Congress-led coalition for promoting slaughterhouses and meat exports through subsidies and tax breaks.
In Mumbai alone, almost 100,000 people are involved in the beef and beef-product trade. An abattoir in the suburb of Deonar that slaughters about 400 bullocks and buffalo a day generates revenue of 250,000 rupees daily for the city government. Its operations were halted as of March 4, General Manager Apsing Pawara said.
At a busy eatery close to the Bandra commuter-train station, restaurant owner Maqeen Qureshi says that beef is the cheapest skewered meat he offers. An order of beef kebab at his bustling restaurant costs 60 rupees, whereas mutton costs 100 rupees and chicken costs 90 rupees.
“Every part of the animal - the skin, the organs, the meat, the blood -- it all gets used for something or the other,” Qureshi said.