Lumber Liquidators Falls 25 Percent After ‘60 Minutes’ StoryJack Clark and Matt Townsend
Lumber Liquidators Holdings Inc. shares plunged after a “60 Minutes” report accused the company of selling Chinese-made flooring with illegal levels of formaldehyde.
The stock sank 25 percent to $38.83 in New York following the broadcast on CBS Sunday evening. The investigation, which used undercover reporters and hidden cameras, found that flooring was billed as meeting California health and safety standards even though it didn’t. Video showed managers at three Chinese factories admitting to using false labeling that made it look like the products met regulations.
“60 Minutes” also said it tested flooring from China that was being sold in several states outside of California, including Virginia, Florida, Texas and New York. Of the 31 products tested, only one would have been legal in California, the show found. The tests were used to back up similar claims made in lawsuits against Lumber Liquidators.
In a response to the allegations, Lumber Liquidators said Monday in a filing that “60 Minutes” used an improper test and that all its laminate floors are safe. The company has also contacted the Chinese suppliers included in the story and have confirmed that all products made for Lumber Liquidators have been compliant with California regulations.
“We randomly test each of our six laminate suppliers in China using unannounced audits and all products tested are compliant and safe,” the Toano, Virginia-based company said in the statement.
None of Lumber Liquidators’ Finished Goods or Fiberboard Core products contains formaldehyde levels in excess of the California Fiberboard Standard, according to the health and safety section of its corporate website.
“Our goal is to sell a good product at a good price,” Tom Sullivan, the company’s chairman and founder, said during the show. “And we don’t get the price by skimping on anything. We get the price by low overhead, huge volume and being very efficient at what we do. And we’re never sell something unsafe.”
The company also disclosed in a regulatory filing on Wednesday that the U.S. Department of Justice may file criminal charges relating to an inquiry that began in 2013 for a violation of import laws.
The shares had already dropped 26 percent on Wednesday after Lumber Liquidators Chief Executive Officer Robert Lynch disclosed that “60 Minutes” was doing the story and that it would probably put the company in an unfavorable light.
Lumber Liquidators also has been grappling with a sales slump. Comparable-store sales decreased 4.3 percent in 2014 from a year earlier and net income also declined. The company, founded in the 1990s, competes with Home Depot Inc. and Lowe’s Cos.
Whitney Tilson, an investor betting against the stock, said he has a price target for Lumber Liquidators of $0 a share. A formaldehyde problem “is likely to be equivalent to asbestos,” he said in an interview with Bloomberg News on Saturday. Tilson was interviewed by “60 Minutes” about the company, on which he has held a short position that he disclosed on November 2013.
“In 16 years of professional money management, I’ve seen hundreds of companies do all sorts of bad things to get their stock prices up,” Tilson said during the broadcast. “But this has got to be the worst.”