Russia Stands to Lose More Than EU on Gas Dispute, Capital SaysAgnes Lovasz and Anna Andrianova
Russia will probably avoid turning off the natural gas taps to Europe or Ukraine as its economy approaches a recession, according to Neil Shearing, head of emerging-markets research at London-based Capital Economics.
Russia “stands to lose more” than Europe from halting westward energy exports, Shearing said. The country’s oil and gas shipments to Europe are worth about 10 percent of its gross domestic product, according to Capital’s calculations.
Russian President Vladimir Putin threatened to halt natural gas shipments to Ukraine, raising the specter of disruptions in flows to Europe, unless its former-Soviet neighbor pays off its debt, according to an e-mailed copy of a letter to 18 European heads of state, distributed by the Kremlin press service. Russia’s economy, stock market and ruble are reeling from tensions with the European Union and U.S., which imposed sanctions after Putin annexed Crimea last month.
“Our house view is that we’re going to avoid the very worst-case sanctions, like trade blockades on both sides, Russia and Ukraine and Russia and Europe,” Shearing said in an April 8 interview in London. “If Russia puts constraints on Ukraine, Europe will respond and it’s neither side’s interest to go down that route. Russia is more vulnerable to sanctions than it’s currently perceived.”
Russia’s economy was already struggling before the conflict with Ukraine intensified this year, Liza Ermolenko, an analyst at Capital, wrote in an e-mailed note yesterday. Gross domestic product may have grown at a 0.5 percent annual pace in the first quarter, slowing from 2 percent in the last three months of 2013 and may “easily” slide into recession this year, she wrote.
The ruble has weakened 7.7 percent against the dollar this year, the second-worst performer among 24 emerging-market currencies tracked by Bloomberg after the Argentine’s peso. The dollar-denominated RTS Index fell 16 percent this year, compared with the MSCI Emerging Market Index’s advance of 1.1 percent.