Putin Threat to Ukraine Seen Leaving West With Few Good OptionsLeon Mangasarian
Russian President Vladimir Putin’s threat to invade Ukraine poses one of the biggest dangers to regional security since the Berlin Wall fell. Analysts say there may not be much the West can do.
One day after President Barack Obama warned Russia to stay out of Ukraine, Putin yesterday sought and obtained unanimous approval from the Russian parliament for the right to send troops into the former Soviet republic. Ukraine said in response that an invasion would be an act of war.
“The world is on the verge of a conflict whose consequences we don’t yet realize,” Polish Prime Minister Donald Tusk, whose country borders Ukraine, said in an address to the nation yesterday. “This will be a moment of truth and will shape relations between countries in this region for decades.”
Putin is defying calls from Tusk, Obama and other leaders to show restraint as he moves to assert what he sees as Russia’s right to dominate the region just as the Soviet Union once did. While the West greeted the uprising that toppled Ukrainian President Viktor Yanukovych last week and pledged financial assistance to help the new interim government, Putin may be calculating that they won’t go much further than that.
“It’s now clear that if you embolden dictatorships like in Russia they will just keep going,” said Joerg Forbrig, a senior program officer at the Berlin bureau of the German Marshall Fund of the U.S., in a phone interview. “For the second time since Georgia in 2008, Russia is showing deeply aggressive behavior and Europeans are not able to handle it.”
Putin is preparing the ground for a potential invasion of the southern Ukrainian region of Crimea and possibly other ethnic Russian regions after a string of disturbances in the aftermath of Yanukovych’s ouster. Putin told Obama in a phone conversation yesterday that he reserves the right to defend Russian speakers if they are threatened by violence.
For Europe and the U.S., standing by would call into question their willingness to support allies in times of need, said Ian Bremmer, president of the Eurasia Group in an email.
At the same time, there are practical issues to consider when calibrating their response to any invasion.
Russian help is needed in ongoing negotiations to resolve the Iranian nuclear issue and ending Syria’s civil war. Soviet-era pipelines in Ukraine carry about half of Russia’s gas shipments to Europe and Turkey.
Economic sanctions may be shrugged off by Putin, a former KGB agent who cares more about hard power and, as Forbrig said, “doesn’t have an economic mind.”
Obama also needs Putin to get troops and equipment home from Afghanistan because the U.S. depends on Russia for part of its Northern Distribution Network.
The network of supply routes “is of great value and it depends on Russia,” said Daniel Serwer of the Center for TransAtlantic Relations School of Advanced International Studies at Johns Hopkins University in Washington. “So do the nuclear talks with Iran. So what are we going to do about Russia? It’s a very gloomy picture, but I don’t know what we can do.”
Nor is Ukraine a member of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization or the European Union.
Serwer said the Obama administration “has come to understand that the Russians have already taken Crimea and there’s not much they can do about it.”
Ukrainians awoke on the morning of Feb. 28 to news that unidentified troops, which Ukraine says are Russian, had taken control of airports in Crimea. That came after gunmen stormed the regional assembly and a pro-Russian was installed as prime minister.
A U.S. official described events over the past days as an orchestrated series of steps that are intended to make Russian military intervention in Crimea appear legitimate. The official requested anonymity to discuss classified intelligence matters.
For Putin, Ukraine offers an opportunity to assert his dominance in the region as he tries to restore the prestige Russia lost after the collapse of the Soviet Union, an event he’s described as the worst geopolitical disaster of the 20th century.
Crimea was part of Russia until 1954 and is home to the Black Sea Fleet. Ethnic Russians comprise 59 percent of Crimea’s population of about 2 million people, with 24 percent Ukrainian and 12 percent Tatar, according to 2001 census data. Of the entire country’s population, 78 percent are Ukrainian and 17 percent are Russian.
Making Putin Hurt
Still, Barbara von Ow-Freytag, who advised the German government from 2008 to 2013 on Russian issues, said there are three ways the West can respond to Putin that will hurt: freezing assets of Russian officials involved in the Ukraine intervention, imposing travel bans on them and canceling the planned Group of Eight Sochi summit in June.
“Putin loves putting on soft power shows like Sochi -- the most expensive Olympics in history,” she said in a telephone interview. “Staying away from the G-8 would be a slap in the face for him.”
U.K. Prime Minister David Cameron said yesterday that it would be “very difficult” to proceed with the G-8 meeting if Putin goes ahead with military action.
Von Ow-Freytag said another response, harder to quantify, would be to stop regarding Russia as a normal country in international organizations like the United Nations.
“Start treating Russia as a disturber and a molester in global politics, instead of a constructive force,” she said.
Even limited economic sanctions would harm Russia given that growth has slowed to about 1 percent and Putin hasn’t been investing enough in infrastructure, von Ow-Freytag said.
Yet Forbrig believes that fear of medium- or long-term damage to Russia’s economy won’t stop the Russian leader. Putin’s handing out gas subsidies to countries like Belarus and Ukraine’s ex-leader Yanukovych, despite the misgivings of his ministers, shows his international relations aren’t constrained by economic concerns, he said.
The stakes are high as the U.S. and Europe consider how much Russian aggression it’s prepared to tolerate, he said.
“This is a Munich moment for the U.S. and Europe.”