Israel Releases Palestinian Prisoners Before Kerry VisitCalev Ben-David and Jonathan Ferziger
Israel released 26 Palestinian prisoners early today as U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry prepared another effort to recharge peace talks that were branded a failure by the chief Palestinian negotiator.
Under the terms that brought the sides back to the negotiating table in July after a three-year deadlock, Israel agreed to free 104 Palestinian prisoners, most convicted of deadly attacks on Israelis, in four rounds.
Today’s post-midnight release of 26 men, confirmed in a phone interview by Prison Authority spokeswoman Sivan Weizman, was the third during the nine months of talks the sides agreed to pursue.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu criticized the celebrations held by the Palestinian Authority for the released prisoners, saying they were detrimental to the peace process.
“Murderers are not heroes,” Netanyahu said, according to a text message sent by his office. “This is not how you educate for peace; this is not how you make peace.”
Goodwill generated by the releases was eclipsed by an Israeli ministerial committee’s Dec. 29 decision to push ahead a bill that would annex parts of the West Bank, territory the Palestinians seek as part of a future state. Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat accused Israel of being “determined to undermine” Palestinian statehood.
“The talks failed,” Erekat told Voice of Palestine Radio yesterday. “We don’t need nine months to judge the negotiations. Israel has caused them to fail.”
Israel’s justice minister and chief negotiator, Tzipi Livni, also criticized the decision, calling it an attempt “to ignore the world and support delusional and extremist legislature.” She warned that failure to end Israel’s conflict with the Palestinians would deepen her country’s isolation.
Netanyahu told members of his Likud-Beitenu parliamentary faction in Jerusalem yesterday that releasing the prisoners was a hard decision and demonstrates that Israel has a “strategic interest” in the continuation of peace talks.
Negotiations have already been strained by Israeli settlement construction and escalating violence. With no breakthrough on issues such as final borders, the status of Jerusalem and the fate of Palestinian refugees, U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry is laboring to craft a blueprint that will allow talks to stay on track, possibly beyond the current April 29 end date. Kerry returns to the region this week.
While Netanyahu hasn’t thrown his support behind the annexation move, it isn’t the first time the Jordan Valley has emerged as a sticking point in the talks.
In the past, Netanyahu has said Israel must maintain a security presence in the Jordan Valley even after the area is handed over to the Palestinians, in order to safeguard its eastern frontier. Palestinian officials say such a presence would violate the sovereignty of the state they want to establish in the West Bank, Gaza Strip and east Jerusalem.
Kerry has tried to broker a compromise by limiting any future Israeli security presence in the Jordan Valley to a specific time frame, Israel Radio reported last week, with electronic monitoring devices and possibly international troops eventually taking their place.
Frictions between the sides have also been exacerbated by Israeli plans to announce new construction in West Bank settlements, timed to take the edge off domestic opposition to the prisoner releases. Palestinians, backed by the U.S., say such construction hinders the chance for a possible peace deal because it eats away at land they want for a state. Israel says it never agreed to halt such building during the talks.
Livni, speaking at a Tel Aviv conference yesterday, voiced concern about growing international sanctions penalizing Israel for its policies toward the Palestinians.
“The conflict is the Israeli economy’s glass ceiling,” she said, “a dangling sword threatening to fall on our head.”
“The international economic and academic boycott began with settlements, but spread to all of Israel,” she said. “Israeli exports will come up against ideological consumerism, universities will come up against an economic boycott and our vaunted research will encounter rigid European guidelines. And it doesn’t stop there. It is growing steadily and exponentially.”
Taking a harder line, Israeli Defense Minister Moshe Ya’alon told participants at the same conference that “a European boycott is preferable” to rocket fire from the West Bank on Israel’s heartland.
The European Union recently imposed funding restrictions on research institutions that operate in Israeli-occupied areas and an American academic group recently voted to boycott Israeli academic institutions.