Lone Star Buys Buildings From State Farm for Lease-BackNoah Buhayar and David M. Levitt
Lone Star Funds, the private-equity firm led by Chairman John Grayken, bought 23 buildings from State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Co. and will lease them back to the largest U.S. property-casualty insurer.
The operations centers comprise 6.2 million square feet (576,000 square meters) of office space in 16 states, the insurer’s broker, Transwestern, said in a statement today. That’s more than twice the rentable space in New York’s Empire State Building.
The deal will provide cash for policyholder-owned State Farm without requiring the company to issue debt. The insurer is working to protect its share of the $178 billion auto market as competitors including Berkshire Hathaway Inc.’s Geico unit and Progressive Corp. add customers.
“Leasing rather than owning property provides State Farm the flexibility to make adjustments in our operations to better serve our customers,” Rachael Risinger, a spokeswoman for Bloomington, Illinois-based State Farm said yesterday in an e-mail. The insurer has “options to renew these leases if we choose to do so.”
The purchase is the largest in the U.S. office market since Blackstone Group LP bought about 10 million square feet from Duke Realty Corp. for $1.1 billion in December 2011, according to Real Capital Analytics Inc., a property-research firm. That excludes deals in which the buyer took a minority interest.
A spokesman for Dallas-based Lone Star declined to comment on the agreement with State Farm. Terms for the deal, which was completed Nov. 8, weren’t disclosed.
Lone Star specializes in buying assets from financial institutions looking to cut debt or raise capital. The company made its name acquiring distressed loan portfolios and lenders in Asia starting in the late 1990s with investments ranging from golf courses in Japan to office towers in Seoul.
Grayken’s company typically wagers on assets that have a real-estate component. U.S. investments have included supermarket Southeastern Grocers Inc., which filed for an initial public offering in September, and Del Frisco’s Restaurant Group Inc.
Lone Star raised $6.6 billion for a new fund this year to invest in commercial real-estate debt and equity, mainly in Europe. The firm has said its U.S. investments from that pool will be mostly in secondary markets.
State Farm struck a similar deal this year. Two of W.P. Carey Inc.’s real-estate investment trusts bought the insurer’s operation center in Austin, Texas, in an August transaction valued at about $110 million.
The main reason investment-grade companies do these kinds of transactions “is to have the real-estate capital earn higher returns in core businesses,” said Brian Scott, senior managing director of the sale-leaseback group at CBRE Group Inc., the world’s biggest commercial real-estate services firm. State Farm is rated AA by Standard & Poor’s, two levels from the top.
Competition for U.S. auto-insurance customers intensified in the past decade with carriers spending almost $6 billion on advertising last year, data compiled by SNL Financial show. Many companies failed to increase their market share even with the higher expenses, McKinsey & Co. said in a January report.
State Farm’s portion of total policy sales was little changed at 18 percent in the four years through 2012, according to data compiled by the National Association of Insurance Commissioners. Berkshire gained about 2 percentage points to end the period at 9.6 percent of the market. Progressive also gained share.