Want to Buy Twitter Shares? Check Out These Charts FirstBy
The Twitter initial public offering is fast approaching, with shares expected to start trading on Thursday. According to the latest figures, the company is offering 70 million shares priced between $23 and $25. On the high end, Twitter could raise $1.75 billion, valuing the company at $13.6 billion.
Is it a worrisome sign that interest in the product has recently dipped, according to search trends on Google? By hovering your mouse over the chart below, you can see a level of 100 in June and 80 in October. That’s a 20 percent drop in four months. (For each chart below, the company’s peak search interest month is listed as 100, and every other month’s number is a percentage of that peak.)
A reading of Twitter’s search trends hasn’t been this low in two years. Even all the news surrounding its IPO wasn’t enough to give it a boost in public interest. Without the IPO news, the level might have even been lower. Let’s compare Twitter with recent IPOs of other Internet companies. We’ll see that the search trends leading up to the IPO actually did a decent job of forecasting the stock performance afterward.
LinkedIn went public in May 2011 while still on a very hot growth streak. That streak continued in both search trends and the stock price, which has lifted the $71 initial offering to more than $220 today.
At the time of Pandora’s June 2011 IPO, the search trends on the company were generally going up each year. The stock performance has followed as well. Pandora now trades at more than $25 per share, a good return from the company’s $16 initial offering price.
Groupon saw its trend reading soar just as it prepared to go public in November 2011. Perfect timing for the company—not so good for investors. The company experienced rapid growth in late 2011, never to be repeated again. Groupon’s founder was eventually fired as chief executive, and the stock is still half the original $20 price, including a peak-to-trough drop of 90 percent in its first year as a public company.
After a two-year period of flat-to-negative growth in the trend chart, Zynga went public in December 2011. This could have been a warning to investors, as the stock quickly cratered from $10 to $2. It’s still less than $4 today.
Yelp was in the middle of a hot streak on search trends at the time of its March 2012 IPO. The stock performance followed, reaching $75 from an initial start of $15.
Facebook’s May 2012 IPO came after nearly a year of flat growth in search trends. The post-IPO stock performance was historically bad and only recently recovered as the company’s expansion into mobile has paid off.
Finally, look at Google itself, which has shown nonstop increases in trends readings and share appreciation since its 2004 IPO. Even the first months of 2004 saw a 50 percent jump in search trends for the site, another example of the search data forecasting the stock growth to come.
Based on this entirely unscientific sampling of recent Internet IPOs, Twitter’s recent performance on search trends would suggest that the performance of the IPO may not be what investors want. Obviously, there’s a big difference between the curiosity of the general public and the investment interest of Wall Street.
A decline in search trends doesn’t necessarily mean the IPO is bad for investors, but it’s not the most promising sign. One huge attraction for investors to buy shares in an IPO is to get exposure to the potential upside of the company, and if it seems the company is stagnating in its public appeal, that has to be considered a potential risk.