Oi’s Industry-Best Dividend Yield in Jeopardy: Corporate BrazilChristiana Sciaudone
Oi SA is in jeopardy of falling short on a pledge to deliver 2 billion reais ($920 million) in dividends this year, a payout that was forecast to make it the highest-yielding phone company in the world.
Brazil’s largest landline carrier promised to pay 1 billion reais in August as long as it closes this quarter with a net-debt-to-earnings ratio of less than 3, down from 3.05 in March. With June drawing to a close, the Rio de Janeiro-based company needs help from regulators, who must approve a deal to sell access to phone towers, adding 1 billion reais to Oi’s coffers.
Oi is spending about 6 billion reais this year on infrastructure improvements, the most among peers, to better satisfy customers after getting more complaints from Brazilians than any other phone company. Even with those expenses, new Chief Executive Officer Zeinal Bava faces pressure to supply a steady stream of cash to Oi’s controlling shareholders so they can pay off their own debt.
“They keep sucking and sucking the company dry,” said Eduardo Roche, head of equities at Rio de Janeiro-based Modal Asset Management, which manages 600 million reais. “The dividend isn’t necessary -- it’s necessary for the controller. For investors, it’s more interesting for the company to create value.”
Oi has fallen 50 percent in Sao Paulo trading since firing Chief Executive Officer Francisco Valim on Jan. 22. The company rallied 17 percent on June 4 when Bava, a veteran of majority shareholder Portugal Telecom SGPS SA, was named as Valim’s replacement. The shares rose 3.4 percent to 3.98 reais at the close today.
The company said today in a regulatory filing that Chief Financial Officer Alex Zornig left and will be replaced on interim basis by Bayard Gontijo.
Second-quarter results are not likely to vary much from the first quarter, when the ratio hit 3.05 and net income dropped 41 percent from a year earlier, Roche said. That makes the sale of assets such as telecommunications towers key, he said. The phone-tower access sale is pending approval by the regulatory agency known as Anatel, which didn’t return phone and e-mail requests for the status of the process.
An Oi press official who asked not to be named declined to comment on the company’s dividend policy and the upcoming payment. Based on analyst estimates compiled by Bloomberg, Oi’s dividend yield is more than 25, compared with an average of about 6 for the world’s 100 biggest telecommunications carriers.
The company is insisting on paying dividends and not doing more to strengthen its liquidity, said Gustavo Serra, an analyst at Planner Corretora de Valores SA whose rating for Oi is under review. Even if it gets below 3, Oi’s ratio of net debt to earnings would far surpass the average of Latin American telecommunications companies, which is less than 1, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
“At some point it will have to opt to reduce the dividend policy or reduce investments,” Serra said in a telephone interview from Sao Paulo. “The proceeds of the dividend make the return very attractive, especially if you consider the drop in the stock, but the market doesn’t see this as very positive because this type of growth is not sustainable and there is no sign of reversal.”
Oi has vowed to pay 8 billion reais in dividends between 2012 and 2015, according to its website. Oi’s controlling group, known as TmarPart, has about 3.5 billion reais in debt and paid 355 million in financial costs last year -- almost exactly the amount it receives in dividend payments from Oi, according to an Itau BBA SA note last month.
TmarPart is a holding company co-owned by Portugal Telecom, Brazilian pension funds, the Andrade Gutierrez conglomerate and the Jereissati family. A press official for TmarPart, Andrade Gutierrez and the Jereissati family didn’t return phone and e-mail requests for comment. A press official for Portugal Telecom didn’t return an e-mail request for comment.
The risk that Oi will miss this quarter’s debt ratio goal has analysts reconsidering their expectations. Luis Azevedo and Tales Freire, analysts from Bradesco BBI SA, cut their estimate for this year’s dividend payments in half to 1 billion reais, indicating that the August payment won’t happen at all, according to a note on June 7.
Oi could also choose to make a smaller payment instead of completely skipping the August dividend, said Sandra Peres, a Sao Paulo-based analyst at Coinvalores, in a telephone interview.
“If the debt ratio passes 3, Oi will still pay, just at a lower rate,” she said.
Bava’s arrival from Lisbon to become Oi’s new leader is fueling hope for a turnaround by showing the interest Portugal Telecom has in Brazil as its home market ceases to provide growth opportunities.
“The new president will put the house in order,” said Peres, who has a buy rating on Oi based upon its “strong investment plan.” Peres has a target price of 7 reais on Oi. “They are investing for a return in the long run.”
It’s best to hold out for Oi to make changes before buying the shares, said Modal’s Roche.
“With some changes, and redefining the dividend, Oi could become an attractive company in the long term,” Roche said, “but we still don’t see a buy opportunity right now.”