Oil Heirs Find Vases Are $1.5 Million Czarist RelicsKatya Kazakina
Two gigantic vases that stood in the foyer of a mansion outside Oklahoma City are heading to auction on April 17 after a surprising evaluation.
Visiting his grandparents as a child, Randy Buttram didn’t give the vases much thought.
“They were there all the time,” said Buttram, 66, in a recent telephone interview. “I had no clue about their historical value.”
Estimated at $1 million to $1.5 million, the 4.5-foot-tall vases will be sold by the Dallas Auction Gallery, whose experts traced them back to the Imperial Porcelain Factory in 19th-century St. Petersburg.
Like so many czarist relics and museum masterpieces, they were probably sold to western buyers by the nascent and needy Soviet government.
In the mid-1920s, the vases appeared at the Bernheimer Gallery in Munich. Buttram’s grandparents, who were touring in Europe, bought them and recorded the purchase in their travel diary.
Buttram’s grandfather, Frank Buttram, was a rags-to-riches oil magnate and founder of Buttram Energies Inc. Born in a log cabin on Oklahoma’s Indian Territory, he made his fortune before turning 30 and was one of five founding members of the Independent Petroleum Association of America. During World War II, he was tapped by President Franklin Roosevelt to serve on the Petroleum Industry War Council.
Randy Buttram, a financial planner, and his brother, Preston, who is president of Buttram Energies, inherited the vases along with some other furnishings and art after the death of their mother in 2011.
The brothers contacted Scott Shuford, president of Dallas Auction Gallery, to appraise the estate. When Shuford opened one of the cardboard boxes, he recognized an imperial mark.
“I could not see the whole thing, but I knew the mark,” said Shuford. “I thought, ‘Oh my gosh! This is a big deal.’”
Ekaterina Khmelnitskaya, curator of porcelain at the State Hermitage Museum in St. Petersburg, examined the vases and confirmed their authenticity.
“The rediscovery of these two Imperial vases is very exciting, first and foremost because they are of extremely high quality and date from the reign of Nicholas I, the golden era of Russian porcelain production,” she said in a statement.
The bandeau-shaped vases feature deep burgundy ground, gilded ornaments and handles shaped like acanthus scrolls. One vase is decorated with a copy of a painting titled “The Concert” by a 17th-century Dutch artist in the Hermitage collection.
“Based on archival records, we know that this painting was sent from the Hermitage to the Imperial Porcelain Factory in 1832 in order to make a copy on a vase,” said Khmelnitskaya.
While astonished by the history of the vases and their unexpected value, Randy Buttram said neither he nor his brother can accommodate them.
“We just don’t have space for these vases,” he said. “It’s fortunate we didn’t bump into them and knock them over.”
Muse highlights include Ryan Sutton on dining, Jeremy Gerard on theater.