Mineworker Debt Mounts as South African Lending BoomsFranz Wild, Mike Cohen and Renee Bonorchis
In 2008, James Ntseane borrowed 8,000 rand ($931) from African Bank Investments Ltd. to pay for his grandmother’s funeral in the South African village of Ganyesa. It seemed so easy the platinum miner took out two more loans, worth 10,000 rand, for a sofa and house extension over the following six months.
Four years later, he owes at least 30,515 rand, according to text messages he gets from African Bank, South Africa’s biggest provider of unsecured loans. To make the payments, 1,700 rand is taken off his monthly salary of about 12,600 rand by his employer under a court-imposed garnishee order and given to the lender. He doesn’t know how much interest he’s paying.
“Even if they tell me 14 percent, I don’t know how much that is,” said Ntseane, 41, who works nights operating a rock-hauling machine almost a mile under the surface at Impala Platinum Holdings Ltd.’s mine north of Johannesburg. “They are taking too much money from us. They don’t even care how much you earn.”
Ntseane is one of more than 9 million South Africans with a blemished credit record, their ranks swollen by an unsecured-loan boom driven by lenders including African Bank and counterparts Capitec Bank Holdings Ltd. and Bayport Ltd. Rising indebtedness from interest rates of as much as 80 percent a year may have contributed to a series of strikes that led to the worst mining industry violence since apartheid ended in 1994, according to the government.
“One of the contributing factors to all of these strikes has been this surge in unsecured lending,” said Mike Schussler, chief economist at Economists.co.za, a research group, in an interview from Johannesburg today. “We are very close to a peak.”
In November, South Africa’s National Treasury and the Banking Association of South Africa said they had agreed to tighten lending rules after the number of people with bad credit records rose to a record, threatening to trap poor families in a “debt spiral.” Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan called the rise in unsecured lending “worrying” a week earlier.
The value of consumer loans not backed by assets surged 39 percent in the year through September to 140 billion rand, according to the Johannesburg-based National Credit Regulator. The loans accounted for 10 percent of consumer credit at the end of September, up from 8 percent a year earlier.
“You have got people who are getting more and more over-indebted,” Nomsa Motshegare, the credit regulator’s chief executive officer, told reporters in Pretoria in October. “At the same time you have got more and more money being extended to these people.”
African Bank boosted its loan advances by 33 percent in the year through September, while net income rose 17 percent to 2.74 billion rand, the Johannesburg-based lender said in a Nov. 19 stock-exchange filing.
Capitec’s 39 percent increase in loans in the six months through August helped net income surge 43 percent to 700 million rand, the Stellenbosch-based company said in a Sept. 26 filing.
Bayport, a unit of Johannesburg-based Transaction Capital Ltd., boosted unsecured lending 55 percent to 4.7 billion rand by the end of September. The bank makes financial provisions assuming that 55 percent of its loans will go bad, said David Hurwitz, Transaction’s chief financial officer, said on July 25.
“A complex set of business rules apply to our credit granting to ensure that our lending is not reckless,” African Bank said in a response to e-mailed questions. Those rules give the bank “significant comfort in screening our clients.”
African Bank CEO Leon Kirkinis said on Nov. 19 that more stringent criteria are now being used to assess borrowers. One-third of people seeking loans from Capitec are overcommitted and this is indicative of what may be happening in the wider industry, Capitec CEO Riaan Stassen said in an e-mailed response to questions.
The company ensures that clients can afford the loans they take out and appoints staff who can speak the predominant language of the region in which the loans are made, he said.
Mark Herskovits, head of debt capital markets for Transaction Capital, said by e-mail that with CEO Mark Lamberti and CFO Hurwitz on vacation the company would be unable to comment on how Bayport assesses loan applications and tries to ensure borrowers understand the liabilities they are taking on.
Many borrowers, like Ntseane, may not fully understand the contracts they are signing because they come from impoverished, rural areas and have had a poor education. South Africa’s mathematics education bettered only Yemen’s in a survey of 144 countries by the World Economic Forum in its 2012-2013 Global Competitiveness Report. Ntseane says he got his high school qualification at the age of 26.
High levels of debt were one reason behind the violent strike at Lonmin Plc’s Marikana mine, 30 kilometers (19 miles) east of Impala’s operation. At least 46 people died, including 34 who were killed by police on Aug. 16. An earlier strike at Impala led to four deaths. The strikes ended only when pay rises of as much as 22 percent were agreed to by the companies.
“There were many, many causal factors,” Trade and Industry Minister Rob Davies told reporters in Cape Town in October. One “is high levels of indebtedness. Unsustainable debt levels are fueling high wage demands.”
Miners who borrow are often hampered by a poor command of English. While African Bank says it also offers contracts in Zulu and Southern Sotho, Impala and Lonmin operate in predominantly Tswana-speaking areas. Many miners come from the Eastern Cape Province, where the main language is Xhosa.
“I don’t know how it works,” said Ntseane, who has worked at the mine for 11 years. “I wasn’t expecting garnishees, because she didn’t properly explain what I should expect,” he said of the African Bank representative.
After being stabbed in a home robbery in 2010, Ntseane couldn’t work for 10 months and said African Bank agreed to put off the loan repayments and wouldn’t charge him interest. When he resumed work he discovered three garnishee orders on his pay slip, which he showed to Bloomberg reporters.
Bank representatives are expected to fully explain contracts to borrowers, African Bank said in an e-mailed response to questions.
Many lenders collect arrears by obtaining magistrate-court orders that instruct employers to dock workers’ salaries and pay the money over to creditors. About 3 million garnishee orders are currently active in South Africa, according to the National Debt Mediation Association, a credit industry body in Johannesburg that assists indebted consumers and estimates that about 8,000 of them apply for debt counseling each month.
Between 10 percent and 15 percent of workers at Lonmin and Anglo American Platinum Ltd. have at least one garnishee order against them, according to Kem Westdyk, chief executive officer of Summit Garnishee Solutions, which helps the two companies review claims against their payrolls. Most orders are issued in favor of African Bank and Bayport because they provide the bulk of loans and do their own collections, while lenders such as Capitec use lawyers and debt collectors, he said.
“At Anglo Platinum, African Bank has about 25 to 30 percent of garnishee orders,” Westdyk said in a phone interview from Johannesburg. “They may have reckless lending problems. We have employees at Anglo Platinum or Lonmin that have five or six African Bank garnishee orders against their names.”
Impala offers counseling and interest-free loans in some cases to deter its workers from borrowing money they can’t afford to pay back, Johan Theron, the company’s executive for personnel, said in a phone interview. Low numeracy and literacy mean that Impala’s efforts may not be fully understood, he said.
“We are powerless in terms of being able to look out for our employees’ best interests because it becomes an order of court and we have to make the deductions,” he said. “It would help us, as an employer, a lot if we had a basis on which we could refuse these garnishee orders.”
Davies and the country’s national credit regulator have pledged to clamp down on abuses.
That action has come too late for Ntseane, who needs to work overtime to afford the fare for a four-hour bus ride home to see his children once a month.
“I don’t know when I will stop paying,” he said. “I’m just working for free.”