The $20 Ad Campaign: Alternatives to Google AdWordsJeff John Roberts
Gerald Gorman, who runs online businesses such as Lawyer.com, pays Google $100,000 a month to place ads near search results and on Google’s partner sites. While the ads have proved effective at attracting customers, their increasing price tag has led Gorman to look around for alternatives.
In the past, Gorman would have been out of luck. That’s because, despite the Internet’s rapid growth, most small and midsize businesses had few viable online ad options beyond Google or Bing. This is changing, however, as upstart ad companies tap into new publishing tools and social media to offer effective online campaigns for as low as $20 a pop.
In Gorman’s case, he laid down $1,000 on two such companies, Outbrain and Virurl, and was delighted with the results. While he pays as much as $10 for a customer to click on one of his Google ads, he found he paid 8¢ and 5¢ at the other sites and also earned surges in traffic.
This may sound too good to be true. But for the growing number of businesses priced out of Google Adwords, it could be the real deal.
Instead of buying a search keyword, as they do with Google Adwords, advertisers such as Lawyer.com can pay Outbrain and Virurl to act as distributors for their messages. They supply the message in the form of a link to a piece of content—a picture, a story, or a video. Outbrain and Virurl then spray the link across the Web via third-party publishers and on social-media sites such as Tumblr and Twitter.
Compared with Google Adwords, the upstart services are remarkable for their simplicity: Outbrain and Virurl provide a website for the advertiser to upload a content link and to set a budget and duration for the ad campaign. While Outbrain has traditionally worked with publishers to augment and monetize their traffic, it recently added an advertising tool called Amplify for small and medium-size businesses.
The advertiser can use a credit card to get the campaign up and running almost immediately, compared with the five days Gorman says it takes Google to approve content (the delay is important for brands that want to jump on time-sensitive ad opportunities such as Big Bird). As for the money, the advertiser’s allocated budget is depleted every time someone clicks on the link; some of the money goes to the publisher that hosts the ad and the rest goes to the distributors—in Gorman’s case, to Outbrain or Virurl. The distributors also share real-time analytics that let the advertiser monitor the campaign.
To be clear, the two would-be Adwords competitors have different business models. Outbrain is bigger and works primarily with major publishers, including premium ones such as CNN and Time, to augment traffic or to find spots for ad-driven content. Virurl, on the other hand, is aimed at getting ad content to go viral on social networks, such as Twitter, where “influencers” retweet the links and are paid for clicks. But from a small business perspective, the underlying strategy is the same: Find ad content that people want to see and pay to distribute it.
Gorman notes that the young ad companies’ geographic targeting isn’t as good as Google’s. (“You can target down to the lamp post with Google AdWords.”) He says, however, that they permit users to choose between U.S. and oversees viewers. He also says they have been forthcoming about fraudulent clicks and will refund money for suspicious traffic.
The advent of cheap, easily managed ad campaigns is good news for companies like Lawyer.com. There’s a catch, though: To sign up for these distribution networks, a company can’t just show up with 20 bucks. It also needs to have a piece of content people want to see.
“We spend a lot on screening. We’re pretty fanatical about taking on only quality,” said Outbrain Chief Executive Officer Yaron Galai by phone, explaining that the company rejects half of all would-be clients. He added that such advertisers as GE are producing “wonderful content,” such as a video interview with the inventor of the LED. Media companies looking to acquire more traffic to meet ad needs are also logical customers for Outbrain.
In the case of Lawyer.com, Gorman said the site produces quality original content that suits Outbrain. What about other small companies? Galai said small, nonmedia companies are unlikely to have the capacity to produce quality content, and their best bet is to use “earned media,” such as reviews or press mentions. If they are ambitious, they could still try to make Outbrain’s quality cut; a bakery might, for instance, start a cupcake or recipe blog.
Virurl, which was featured at a Paley Media Center’s “Next Big Thing” event, is less finicky about the content it sends out. But the social advertising startup likewise uses a quality control process to weed out junky ads.
“A human in our Santa Monica [Calif.] office views the content and either approves or rejects it. We will never drive anyone to a product page or anything that is spammy or a clear ad. … The underlying philosophy is that—if the advertiser put enough thought into tapping into human emotion it will likely be approved,” wrote Virurl CEO Francisco Diaz-Mitoma in an e-mail message.
The bottom line is that the new ad distributors offer small businesses a low-cost way to get their brands before huge numbers of potential customers, provided they have the ingenuity to make or earn quality content. The people who see the ad content may not have the same “intent-level” as those who click on Google search ads but for now, the price advantage mean companies such as Outbrain and Virurl could one day emerge as viable competitors to Google.
Also from GigaOM:
The Double-Edged Sword of Political Mobile Ads (subscription required)