Dear Google: Harm or Not, You Fouled up on PrivacyMathew Ingram
The controversy over Google's (GOOG) collection of personal data via its Street View photo-taking program continues to grow, but the company appears reluctant to acknowledge the full importance of the lapse, saying no harm was done. Although co-founder Sergey Brin has admitted Google "screwed up," CEO Eric Schmidt said at the Zeitgeist conference in the U.K.that no one was harmed by the incident, and as such, "No harm, no foul."
Others, however, clearly disagree. The company is facing a class action in Washington and Oregon.Two legislators in Washington, D.C., in a letter to the Federal Trade Commission, have raised the issue of whether Google's behavior was illegal. A consumer advocacy group has also complained to the FTC, and Germany has begun a criminal investigation.
Google recently admitted that its Street View cars had been collecting data from public Wi-Fi networks—then later admitted that, contrary to its initial statements, such data included personal information and perhaps even the content of e-mails and other communications. The company also said that the data were collected accidentally and that none were ever released or used by anyone. Google has since stopped collecting data from Wi-Fi networks and says it's consulting with government and policy groups on the best way to get rid of the information so that users and consumer groups will be satisfied that it had done so properly.
A Case of Misunderstanding?
Nevertheless, the company maintains that the issue was a simple oversight and nothing worth getting concerned about. This isn't the first time Google has played down complaints about its behavior on privacy. After Buzz was launched and a number of users criticized the company for connecting them with all their e-mail contacts, whether they wanted to be connected or not—and subsequently publicizing those connections without making it clear they would be public—Google CEO Eric Schmidt told attendees of one conference that the issue was blown out of proportion, that no harm was caused, and that the situation was primarily a result of users misunderstanding the service.
Yet the criticisms aimed at Google have continued. Privacy authorities from 10 countries, led by the Canadian Privacy Commissioner, sent a strongly worded letter to the company last month about its privacy practices. The group said that Google too often had "failed to take adequate account of privacy considerations when launching new services" and that it needed to build privacy safeguards and controls directly into new products as they were being designed, rather than trying to apply them later.
In addition to the letter from the two U.S. legislators about the Street View data collection, the advocacy group Consumer Watchdog has sent a letter to the FTC asking it to investigate Google's practices. The group also launched a site called Inside Google (http://insidegoogle.com/) to call attention to what it believes are the company's failings in various areas, including privacy. As the growing furor over Facebook and its approach to privacy has shown, concern is mounting about social networks and Web companies, what kinds of data they're collecting, and how they're using the information. Google continues to downplay the importance of what was a serious breach of personal privacy.
Also from the GigaOM network: