Subprime Time Bomb
As investors swallowed negative news from two of the biggest players in the subprime mortgage market on Feb. 8, the "housing bottom" question took a backseat to a new debate: Who will get crushed in the subprime shakeout, and who will emerge unscathed?
The market started showing more signs of subprime jitters when HSBC Finance, the Prospect Heights (Ill.)-based consumer lending unit of British banking giant HSBC Holdings (HBC) said it was setting aside 20% more than analysts had estimated for bad loans in 2006 because of weakening in the U.S. mortgage business. Shares of the bank were off 3% early afternoon on Feb. 8.
More bad news came from Irvine (Calif.)-based lender New Century Financial (NEW). New Century, the second-largest subprime mortgage originator in the U.S., announced it would restate results for the first three quarters of 2006 to correct accounting errors related to loan repurchase losses, sending the stock down 30% on Feb. 8. The company expects to see a loss for the fourth quarter of 2006 due to early payment defaults.
Defaults Aren't the Whole Story
Shares of other big mortgage players, Countrywide Financial (CFC) and Washington Mutual (WM), were down more than 2% on Feb. 8. Smaller subprime lenders were hit even harder: Kansas City (Mo.)-based Novastar Financial (NFI) shares fell 13%, and San Diego-based Accredited Home Lenders Holding (LEND) dropped 7%.
As investors become more aware of the problems with subprime loans, lenders that focus on customers with poor credit histories will have to face the music. But it may be for different reasons than people think.
"Just because some subprimers are bad doesn't mean all are," says Stuart Plesser, a mortgage lender and insurer analyst for Standard & Poor's Equity Research. "Countrywide will suffer because they are going to face a pricing issue." Plesser has a "sell" rating on Countrywide, the No. 1 mortgage originator and fourth largest subprime mortgage originator in the U.S., according to National Mortgage News.
Many mortgage lenders, including Countrywide and New Century, sell their loans to banks and investors that are attracted to the high interest rates they carry. HSBC got into subprime during the U.S. housing market boom, but when the market began to cool and foreclosure trends accelerated, the bank found itself in trouble. Washington Mutual, another big player in the subprime market, said in January that its mortgage business lost $122 million in the fourth quarter thanks entirely to losses in its subprime segment.
"This is the leitmotif of this whole thing: These people don't really know what they are doing in mortgage banking," says Plesser. "They are writing whatever loans just to write loans, thinking they will worry about it later. But now it's later."
Regular lenders also suffer when banks get into their territory. Companies like Countrywide have been forced to price loans lower since investment banks started buying up subprime loans and pricing them aggressively. Banks assumed they were covered from potential losses by the revenue streams from their myriad other businesses.
Despite the headwinds, lenders like Countrywide, which only has 10% of its business in subprime production, could weather the housing slump better than nearly pure subprime companies, like New Century and Novastar.
"Countrywide is diversified and will start picking it up when everyone goes out of business," says Piper Jaffray analyst Bob Napoli, who has a "buy" rating on the stock. Napoli also says Accredited, though a pure subprime company, could also "get to the other side."
Diversified Against Danger
As for New Century, Napoli says that although the earnings restatement came as a surprise, he has been looking for an ugly fourth quarter from a company that "grew way too fast for their infrastructure." Still, the analyst has a "market perform" rating on New Century shares, which he says are "not yet a certain sell."
Several other analysts downgraded New Century to "sell" on the news Feb. 8, including Kenneth Bruce of Merrill Lynch (MER). "In short, we think New Century will shift to survival mode, putting shareholders at further risk," the analyst wrote in a report.
Diversification will also be the key factor in keeping banks afloat in 2007. That may be why Bear Stearns (BSC) wasn't afraid to buy the subprime loan business last October of another Irvine-based lender, ECC Capital (ECR).
"Because they are so big and [Bear Sterns has] so many businesses, it doesn't go straight to their bottom line," says Plesser. By 2008, the analyst expects many of the big banks to unload their subprime portfolios and leave the business to the regular lenders.
Let That Be a Lesson
Even if banks decide to stick with their subprime segments, HSBC's profit warning and New Century's restatement may prevent other banks from getting into it in the future. Despite the profit warning, Standard & Poor's Ratings Services affirmed its "AA" long-term and "A1" short-term credit ratings on HSBC Holdings on Feb. 8 and said the outlook for the company remains positive. "The positive outlook reflects the potential for HSBC's diversification to generate very strong group performance even when some business lines are performing weakly," wrote credit analyst Michelle Brennan.
"They are going to look really stupid for making these acquisitions," says Napoli. "Things like this remind people that it's not an easy business."
Click here to see the U.S. cities with the highest foreclosure rates.