A Winning Recipe

Building a company that matters

Patricia Karter, CEO of Dancing Deer Baking, is used to hearing people rave about her company's all-natural sweets, such as its Cherry Almond Ginger Chew cookies. She also often hears praise for the $8 million outfit's philanthropy and green packaging, as well as its commitment to its 65 employees and inner-city Boston. All of which makes her a bit chagrined. Great-tasting goodies aside, she thinks every company could do what she's doing. "We've created a brand with important values," says the 49-year-old Karter. "But Dancing Deer is not big enough to make an impact, to be a social or economic force. If I hit $50 million in sales, it can be."

Karter is determined to expand the company she co-founded in 1994 and to hang onto her values. She has already turned Dancing Deer from a startup selling homemade scones into a profitable wholesale, mail-order, and online business. Its cookies, brownies, cakes, and mixes, all packaged in recycled fiber and whimsically illustrated with stick-figure bakers and dancing deer, are sold in Whole Foods Market, Williams-Sonoma, and Wild Oats Markets.

Yet Karter still avoids artificial ingredients, and all employees receive stock options as well as free lunches. Some 35% of proceeds from the Sweet Home line of cakes go to help the homeless find housing and jobs through a Boston coalition of nonprofits. And although Dancing Deer will soon need more than twice the space its 18,000-square-foot quarters now provide, it will stay in low-income Roxbury rather than relocate to the less pricey suburbs.

Sticking to her guns hasn't always been easy. In the late '90s, Karter turned down a deal to sell molasses clove cookies to Williams-Sonoma. It would have doubled her sales, but it also would have meant adding preservatives. Her steadfastness impressed the bigger company, which later asked her to come up with preservative-free mixes it could sell in its stores. "I think they are a wonderful company," says Sally Geller, divisional manager of Williams-Sonoma's retail food division. "I have great respect and admiration for Trish and what she has done in providing high-quality products with natural ingredients."

Trained as a painter, Karter got her first taste of business when she returned home from Wheaton College to help her father save his recycling business. Later, she worked as a lobbyist for the glass industry and did a stint in Coca-Cola's marketing department, then went back for a master's degree from the Yale School of Management. She was painting full-time when she met baker Suzanne Lombardi in 1994. Karter loved Lombardi's cakes and cookies, and with her then-husband Ayis Antoniou invested $20,000 to launch Dancing Deer. Sales hit $283,000 in two years and more than doubled the next. In 1999, Karter divorced Antoniou and, with help from some investors, bought his and Lombardi's shares. "It was a painful, difficult time," she says, "and it nearly killed the company."

Now, growth is top of mind. To help finance it, Karter sold 10% of the company in 2005 to Christopher Gabrieli, a managing director at Boston's Ironwood Capital. To reduce the company's reliance on the holiday rush, she's adding a line of shortbread cookies that have a longer shelf life.

While Karter has had her hand in all facets of the business, from developing recipes to writing quirky packaging slogans, she recently hired a marketing officer and will bring in someone to oversee e-commerce and operations. "I knew I needed help," she says. "There are 20 opportunities a day to lose your way." And Karter isn't about to let her company, or her ideals, get lost.

By Stacy Perman

    Before it's here, it's on the Bloomberg Terminal.
    LEARN MORE