Steel: The Mergers Aren't Over Yet
You would think that Guy Dollé, the cerebral CEO of Europe's leading steelmaker, Arcelor, would have mixed feelings about Lakshmi N. Mittal. After all, when Mittal announced last fall that he was creating the world's largest steel company by buying U.S.-based International Steel Group Inc. (ISG ), the Indian-born investor knocked Dollé's company into second place. But Dollé applauded. "It's a very positive signal to the industry that it has to move and consolidate," he says. "In coming years you will see a speeding up of mergers and acquisitions in the steel industry."
Dollé is determined that Arcelor be among the few steel titans to survive that wave. The Luxembourg company was born out of the $10 billion union of three of Europe's top producers -- France's Usinor, Luxembourg's Arbed, and Aceralia of Spain -- in 2002. Dollé, a veteran Usinor exec who became CEO at merger time, now wants to continue the process in Asia and North America, possibly even striking a deal with U.S. Steel (X ) or Nucor (NUE ). And some analysts believe he can pull it off. "Mittal and Arcelor are a sure thing to lead this consolidation," says Peter F. Marcus, managing partner of World Steel Dynamics Inc.
Better market conditions are spurring the pace of M&A. After falling for years, steel prices began to rise in late 2003 and have stayed up ever since. Chinese demand -- the main driver -- is expected to surge by 11% this year, to 290 million metric tons, or 29% of the global market. Arcelor managed to raise its prices dramatically for 2005, winning 20% to 50% increases in annual contracts with car and packaging companies. Arcelor's shares are up 32% in the past year. And on Feb. 17, it's expected to report 2004 operating profits of $4.2 billion -- over four times 2003's net -- on revenues of $39 billion, according to Michael Shillaker, an analyst at CSFB in London.
Dollé will need this financial strength if he wants to double Arcelor's size -- and that may be necessary to compete. Many analysts believe that, in coming years, the fragmented industry will consolidate into four to six global behemoths, each with 80 million to 100 million metric tons of production capacity. In 2004, Mittal's estimated output of 58 million metric tons was about 16% larger than Arcelor's.
Arcelor is taking steps to match Mittal's growth. With 30% to 35% of the European market, it can't grow at home, and is largely absent from the U.S. and Asia. But the recent takeover of Brazil's Companhia Siderúrgica de Tubarão vaulted Arcelor to the top spot in Latin America. It has also signaled that it will bid for Erdemir, Turkey's largest steelmaker, which will be privatized later this year. In Japan, Arcelor has inked an R&D partnership with Nippon Steel.
In the U.S., the world's second largest market after China, Dollé admits he's on the hunt. But a new plant built from the ground up is out of the question: "An acquisition, partnership, or merger" is the way to go. The timing is right, given Arcelor's stock price, strong balance sheet, and the weak dollar. Among the top candidates are a handful of North American players analysts consider too small to succeed solo, including AK Steel (AKS ), Dofasco, Schnitzer Steel Industries (SCHN ), and Steel Dynamics (STLD ). Bigger deals may also be possible. For now, neither Nucor nor U.S. Steel -- the largest U.S. players -- can match Mittal's global presence, points out Mary V. O'Connor, an analyst at New York's Locker Associates. A friendly hookup would help them survive. "Dollé's reputation is likely to attract merger partners who believe he can get the job done," adds WSD's Marcus.
Dollé also acknowledges that steel is a cyclical industry and that a slowdown in demand is inevitable. Like Mittal, he's betting that consolidation will mean that steelmakers -- who have been prone to overproduce when prices fall -- will exercise restraint this time. "It's better to cut production to avoid the price collapses," he says. With size, he hopes, will come a new sense of discipline.
By Stanley Reed in London with Adam Aston in New York