Toyota's Midlife Crisis
Toyota Motor Corp.'s commander in chief, Hiroshi Okuda, is beaming. Hundreds of French citizens are gathered to celebrate his latest conquest: a sprawling site for a $727 million factory near Valenciennes, in northeastern France. Okuda seals the deal by laying two stones for the plant, making $177,000 in donations to local causes, and planting several cherry trees--proof that Toyota wants to take root in Europe. Then he dons a short kimono and takes up a wooden mallet to open four barrels of hot sake as part of Japanese ritual. The spectacle leaves little doubt that Okuda is serious about extending Toyota's reach around the world.
But back at home, road warrior Toyota looks battered. Japan's No. 1 carmaker managed record pretax operating profits of $3.4 billion, on sales of $52 billion, for the first half of this year. Yet these figures obscure something important: Toyota is barely breaking even in its most critical market, Japan.
Some analysts believe the company has started to lose money in its domestic car business. Merrill Lynch & Co. reckons Toyota loses $423 on every car it sells at home. Only the sale of spare parts and accessories pushes domestic operations into the black. Toyota slices the data differently: It lumps export profits from Japanese plants together with domestic sales. But even its executives admit conditions in the home market are dreadful. Toyota's vehicle sales in Japan have tumbled 31% since 1990. Its market share has been below 40% since 1995, and the company must spend more than ever to lure customers into showrooms. Even if Toyota recovers a 40% share by yearend, it will sell less than 2 million vehicles in Japan for the first time in a decade. Japan's economy, it seems, has become Toyota's Achilles' heel.
To Toyota's North American rivals, none of this matters for now. All they see is the Toyota juggernaut in the U.S., which in November upped its share of the world's biggest market by more than a full percentage point, to 9.1%. Detroit executives are only dimly aware of Toyota's woes at home and probably figure the giant will recover its momentum when the recession ends. "Toyota is a tough, tough competitor," says Ronald L. Zarrella, head of General Motors North America.
SHORT ON ZIP. But the question still demands an answer: How long can any carmaker afford to give up profits in its core market? Japan accounts for just 38% of Toyota's worldwide car sales--down from 52% in 1990. Those sales generate little in the way of profit, while North America accounts for an estimated 80% of operating income, with Europe accounting for most of the rest. "Americans have been feeding us," concedes Kanji Kurioka, executive vice-president for domestic sales. Yet with the yen now strengthening against the dollar, every one-yen increase knocks an estimated $68 million off Toyota's net profit. Partly because of the currency situation, Toyota has just lowered its 1999 profit forecast. Says Fujio Cho, executive vice-president for corporate planning: "I tell people, `You can't rely forever on a weaker yen."'
The recession has certainly taken a bite out of Toyota's Japanese results, but the company must accept much of the blame for its troubles. It has failed to cater to younger buyers' desires for zippy compact minivans and sport-utility vehicles. Shrinking sales mean that Toyota must pay for factory and dealership workers it doesn't need. Toyota also worries investors by spending billions on investments such as housing and telecoms that could yield minimal returns.
Increasingly, Toyota's woes typify the problems plaguing Japan Inc. Until the mid-1990s, Toyota could depend on strong results at home to drive rapid expansion abroad: Some analysts believe Toyota earned as much as 90% of operating income from its domestic operations at its peak in 1990. The Japanese car market was predictable, with Toyota firmly on top. It faced weak rivals, was supported by dealers who felt little need to discount, and sold to consumers who meekly accepted high prices. Japanese officials helped by conducting such stiff vehicle inspections that most consumers were forced to buy a new car every three years. Toyota could keep its Toyota City plants operating at full tilt because of the steady growth of export markets and a booming local economy.
Now, the pattern is reversed, and overseas profits are propping up Japan. Excess capacity, picky consumers, surplus workers, price wars, and hemorrhaging affiliates have become the rule of the Japanese market. Honda Motor Co., which for years played a small role in Japan, is attacking Toyota's domestic market with a vengeance. Already, Toyota must worry about keeping its No. 3 ranking among the world's auto makers. DRI/McGraw-Hill automotive analyst Philip Rosengarten estimates that Toyota and Volkswagen will each sell 4.5 million vehicles this year. "Toyota has not changed, but the world has changed," says Shoichiro Toyoda, Toyota's chairman.
If these conditions persist, even Toyota's $25 billion cash hoard could start to dwindle, as the giant wages a war of attrition against rivals at home. Eventually, a low-profit domestic market could sap its ability to finance its global ambitions and fend off rivals. "In a sense, we are troubled," admits Okuda. "We set a target of selling 6 million vehicles [a year] by the early 21st century. However, because of the recession, it's necessary to extend that target."
Some Toyota executives even compare their problems in Japan with those GM faced more than a decade ago. "In a way, we have gotten too big, and it's tough to manage Toyota," says Chairman Toyoda. "Sometimes, we face difficulties deciding which direction to go. I used to think that [GM Chairman] Roger Smith had [that] trouble." Toyota is much healthier than GM--but Toyota executives know how foreign profits dulled GM management's sense of crisis at home. In the U.S. GM's market share has shrunk from 40.3% in 1985 to 29.4% this year.
SACRED GROUND. Recognizing that Toyota must fix its domestic sales to remain a leader, Okuda has embarked on an aggressive restructuring. "Toyota has a sense of crisis, and it is making efforts, but it takes time," says Takaki Nakanishi, an automotive analyst at Merrill Lynch. Yet watching competitors such as Nissan Motor Co. and Mitsubishi Corp. approach the brink has convinced Okuda that the longer he waits, the more painful the process will be.
So Toyota has started to tread on sacred territory. Some investors remain frustrated that it keeps workers on the payroll even as its factories run at 85% of capacity. But next year, Toyota will hire 9% fewer high school and university graduates. More important, some of these new hires will be contract employees with no expectation of lifetime employment. If all goes as scheduled, such hires will make up one-third of the payroll by early in the next century. "We will be streamlining and gradually reducing our workforce," says Okuda.
Toyota also expects to shed $678 million in costs this year, largely by designing cars with fewer, simpler parts and sharing more parts between models. To shave an estimated 30% off development costs, Toyota is using the chassis from its European-designed Yaris for a new subcompact in Japan and for at least two other models.
Such efforts should lessen the blow of smaller sales volumes during Japan's deepening recession. Toyota's engineers used to develop cars on the assumption that the company would sell 10,000 units per month. Now, many must design cars to make profits at lower prices and monthly volumes as low as 2,500. So engineers on the $26,270 Progres luxury sedan shared parts with other vehicles and overhauled everything from the development process to the stamping equipment to squeeze enough costs out to compete with the low-end Mercedes C class.
Beyond that, Okuda is shaking up the chain of command. After he became president in 1995, the sales staff showed him a report that described how Toyota's well-built blandness turned off the younger customers. More alarming, Toyota was losing ground with its core customers--folks in their 40s and 50s. So Okuda ordered a task force of thirtysomething managers to make up a youth division and to think big--fast. "He said that if we couldn't think of anything in three months, then we probably wouldn't be able to come up with an idea," recalls Hideaki Homma, 35. The result was a new company to design and sell cars for young people. Dubbed the Virtual Venture Co. (VVC), its managers answer only to Okuda. The company is housed in the hip Tokyo district of Sangenjaya, safe from contagion from Toyota's stodgy headquarters.
"NOT FOR US." Although VVC is keeping mum on details, it is scheduled to develop at least one cool car by 2000. But the longer VVC takes, the more opportunities Toyota misses to lure younger buyers. If Toyota wants to regain the volumes it had in 1990, it will have to go at full throttle. "Toyota is for old people, not for us," says Ken Nomura, 29, who cruises around Tokyo with his girlfriend in a Honda $19,200 CR-V sport-utility vehicle.
In the meantime, the VVC subsidiary is experimenting with unconventional sales strategies to jazz up Toyota's image. For a small fee, it is allowing the public to test-drive most of the cars in Toyota's lineup in a Kobe parking lot. It's building an $83 million amusement park on the edge of Tokyo that will open in April, complete with everything from displays of Toyota's visions for vehicles of the future to an area where people can design their own cars. VVC estimates that these efforts have boosted sales of some Toyota models by 10%, and recent consumer surveys show an improvement in Toyota's brand image, even though it still trails Honda.
A MODICUM OF FLOPS. Good stuff, but Toyota continues to struggle to regain its 40% market share. Many of Toyota's attempts to create entirely new markets aren't working. The Altezza and Progres luxury cars are hits. But the $18,600 Vista next-generation sedan and the $16,000 Nadia "monospace" sedan, which looks like a cross between a station wagon and a minivan, continue to fall far short of sales targets. Some dealers fear that just at the time Toyota is discovering what Japan's youth really want, youngsters aren't able or willing to afford it.
Even Toyota's revolutionary hybrid, the Prius--which runs both on gasoline and an electric battery to cut the emissions dramatically--may be an example of a superb technology with no real market. Okuda's launch of the Prius one year ago is still remembered with awe and bewilderment by everyone from Toyota's competitors to its suppliers to its stockholders. That's because the $16,500 Prius is being sold at a price that analysts estimate is only about half what it costs to build the car. Toyota makes 2,000 Prius cars a month. Yet starting in August this year, consumers have bought only 1,561 of them on average. "The Prius is being sold near [other Toyotas] that are discounted. And only cheap cars are selling now," says a disappointed Akihiro Wada, executive vice-president for research and development. Toyota now wants its dealership chains to specialize in different parts of its lineup.
Toyota has also started to pressure dealers. Its sprawling network of more than 300 dealerships--with 5,600 outlets--has long been regarded as the key to its might. No rival can match Toyota's reach. Yet sometimes, Toyota outlets are located one block from each other. They may even display some of the same models.
Now, Toyota wants to overhaul this crazy-quilt system, an act previously considered taboo. It has stopped supplying dealers with look-alike models, to eliminate unnecessary price competition. It has pulled the plug on monetary incentives for dealers. Instead, starting next year, if dealers cannot meet sales targets, they run the risk of losing their franchise. Toyota has also asked some dealers to rebuild and rename outlets to attract more young people. In the past year, for example, 66 dealers have established 1,074 "Netz" dealerships intended to attract women and youth with showrooms that are brighter and swankier than most Toyota outlets. On its own, Toyota has begun constructing a massive "auto mall" in the Japanese Alps that will sell every model in Toyota's lineup--in addition to prefabricated houses--from November, 2000.
Dealers are getting the message. Toyota's second-largest dealer, Tokyo Corolla, closed down a dozen of its outlets in the capital this year and has drawn up a blueprint for paring down its payroll by 300 employees in two years. Tokyo Corolla is also trying to build trust among customers, revamping one of its main outlets so that passersby can see through a window how workmen fix cars. "We dealers are trying things that we have never tried before," says Akira Nishimura, chairman of Tokyo Corolla.
Okuda figures that a lot more has to be done before Japan can once again be an engine of growth, even while shrugging off the naysayers. "Financial analysts are saying all sorts of things about our company," he says. "They don't know anything about the future, and they don't know the details of our operations. I don't care that much about what they're saying."
Yet he admits Toyota must go ahead at full speed. Says Okuda: "Recession is a time to overwhelm the enemy." And, he hopes, the best time to fix what ails Japan's preeminent company.
To continue reading this article you must be a Bloomberg Professional Service Subscriber.
If you believe that you may have received this message in error please let us know.
- China Warns It May Retaliate If U.S. Imposes Metal Tariffs
- Box-Office Smash ‘Black Panther’ May Be Game Changer for Artists
- All 65 Aboard Plane Feared Dead in Crash in Southern Iran
- Noble Group Flags a $5 Billion Loss as Debt-Deal Endgame Nears
- European Stocks Extend Rally; Dollar Steady: Markets Wrap