ECB's Weak Medicine Won't Heal Europe
Figures today showing that inflationin the euro area slowed to 0.5 percent in April all but guarantee that the European Central Bank will be reaching into unplumbed corners of the monetary-policy toolbox when it announces the results of its rate-setting meeting on Thursday. The one innovation it will almost definitely implement -- negative interest rates on cash left with the central bank -- will do little to goose lending.
The theory is simple enough; charging financial institutions for the privilege of keeping money on deposit with the central bank will spur them to do something more economically productive with their reserves, such as lending them to companies. But, as the chart below shows, Europe's banks only have about 29 billion euros ($39 billion) with the ECB's deposit facility, a far cry from the 771 billion euros hiding from the risk of a meltdown in the government bond market in the dark days of mid-2012:
Even if all 29 billion euros suddenly ran into the economy shouting "borrow me, borrow me!," that's won't be enough to stimulate lending and growth. Here's another chart showing how the supply of credit in the euro area has collapsed, based on the loans component of the money-supply data:
Inflation was even slower than the 0.6 percent predicted by 38 economists in a Bloomberg News survey, and down from 0.7 percent in March. After pledging action to avert deflation at last month's press conference, ECB President Mario Draghi will need to come up with something special this week -- another long-term lending facility for banks, perhaps, or some concrete plans to unleash his long-promised bond-buying program -- to prevent his promises from sounding increasingly empty.
This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Bloomberg View's editorial board or Bloomberg LP, its owners and investors.
To contact the author on this story:
Mark Gilbert at firstname.lastname@example.org
To contact the editor on this story:
James Greiff at email@example.com