Bloomberg

Utah Software Engineer Mints Physical Bitcoins

The Rise of Bitcoin

Is It Real Money If It Doesn't Come From the Mint?

By Max Raskin | Updated Oct. 3, 2013

They’re called Bitcoins, but you can’t put one into your pocket. Don’t try to use it to tip the waiter. So what makes Bitcoin money? The same thing that makes all money money — trust, in this case backed up by a lot of code-breaking computers. Created in 2009, Bitcoin has grown into the world’s largest virtual currency, traded on exchanges around the world. It’s the product of open-source software and a decentralized network of electronic “miners,” making it a multibillion-dollar experiment in monetary privatization and perhaps the first step toward an age when the digital economy outgrows the restraints of nation states and wallets full of paper.

The Situation

The value of Bitcoin soared in early 2013 amid a torrent of media coverage, hitting an intraday record high of $266 in April. Some buyers were drawn by a mistrust of central banks they saw as fueling inflation; for them, Bitcoin, which has rigid limits on money supply written into its software, was a safer alternative.  Others liked its anonymity for online transactions, legal or not. But much of the surge was driven by newer investors with more traditional motivation — getting in on the ground floor of a product in demand. In July 2013, the Winklevoss twins of Facebook fame announced that they had bought 1 percent of the Bitcoin in existence and later filed to offer a Bitcoin ETF. Prominence also brought new problems, however. The largest Bitcoin exchange, Mt. Gox, located in Japan, was  the target of hacking attacks that drove the price down. In the summer of 2013, regulators began to take notice, raising thorny questions of oversight. Then on Oct. 2, Bitcoin prices plunged by a third after U.S. prosecutors announced the indictment of the operator of Silk Road, an anything-goes online market where drugs and other illicit goods were peddled for Bitcoin.

The Background

While private currencies are nothing new, putting them online is. And the real leap by Bitcoin’s pseudononymous creator, Satoshi Nakamoto (who may be one person or a group), was in devising a way to decentralize the issuing of a currency while maintaining its credibility. The key idea in a 2008 white paper and software he released shortly thereafter was that encrypted digital proof could take the place of verification by banks or governments. In effect, the validity of Bitcoin transactions are backed up by code-breaking work done by a network of “miners” who are paid for solving the system’s cryptographic challenges by being issued new Bitcoin. (To safeguard the value of the overall money supply, the pace of Bitcoin creation is limited, and no more than 21 million Bitcoins will ever be created; in mid-2013 more than 11 million had been issued.) Once they’re mined,  you can use your the digital currency to order more than heroin — cupcakes, for instance, are on sale online for Bitcoin.

The Argument

Although still small, Bitcoin raises questions about what the relationship between governments and money will be in an increasingly digital world. Money is based on trust, and Bitcoin proponents don’t trust fiat currency, the kind backed only by a government’s word. But while they may avoid inflation, its users are potentially vulnerable to hacking, and Bitcoin’s purchasing power swings with its price as pegged by currency markets. Governments could pay a price for Bitcoin’s rise, too. In October 2012, the European Central Bank released a report saying that central banks could become less influential if the public starts to doubt whether they control enough of the money supply to be effective. And it may be that Bitcoin users can’t disentangle themselves from governments entirely. Well before the Silk Road indictment, law enforcement officials complained about the growth of a currency they saw as used mainly to shield illegal transactions. In August 2013, the New York State attorney general subpoenaed 22 companies working in the field to see if they were following rules outlined in a U.S. Treasury Department  guidance document. The next week,  Germany declared that it was ready to recognize Bitcoin as legal private money so it could levy sales and capital gains taxes.  To some, the Silk  Road bust meant the beginning of the end for Bitcoin. To others, it was a necessary step for establishing Bitcoin as a legitimate currency, rather than a way around legal restraints.

The Reference Shelf

  • Bloomberg News traces the interest of the Winklevoss twins and Silicon Valley investors in Bitcoin.
  • Bitcoincharts.com has various data about the network, including market capitalization and pricing on various exchanges.
  • When the price of Bitcoin spiked to more than $200, Bloomberg Businessweek profiled some of the early adopters who became virtual millionaires and examined Bitcoin’s use in circumventing sanctions against Iran.
  • Wired magazine profiled the founder of Mt. Gox, who has moved on to another digital currency, and, a year earlier, the Silk Road drug website.
  • The New Yorker looks at Dark Wallet, a project meant to speed the spread of Bitcoin, from the law student who invented the printable gun.

To contact the writer of this QuickTake:

Max Raskin in New York at  mraskin5@bloomberg.net

 

To contact the editor responsible for this QuickTake:

John O'Neil at joneil18@bloomberg.net