Bridge Unbuilt in India Shows Gandhi Family’s Fading Promise
Himat Bahadur Singh recalls when former India Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi promised his village a bridge that would allow easy access to a community on the other side of the river. Thirty years later, he’s still waiting.
“There’s a limit to our patience,” Singh, 70, said while watching a wooden boat ferry passengers across the Sai River in a parliamentary constituency that has been represented by Gandhi family members and a loyalist for all but one year since 1980. “It gives us pain and anger thinking that Rahul Gandhi is unable to fulfill the promises his father made to us.”
Rahul Gandhi, 43, is seeking re-election in Amethi as Singh and other constituents head to the polls today, the eighth of nine rounds of voting in elections ending May 16. His family has produced three prime ministers, including his great-grandfather, grandmother and father.
While Gandhi’s ruling Congress party channeled subsidies into India’s rural regions and sought to aid the poor with work guarantees, disenchantment mounted with corruption cases and a tumble in the nation’s growth rate. Narendra Modi and his Bharatiya Janata Party are capitalizing on the discontent by showcasing the relative economic success of his state, Gujarat.
“The traditional constituents of the Congress party have become ambitious,” said Shiv Visvanathan, a professor at the Jindal School of Government and Public Policy in Haryana state bordering Delhi who has been studying Indian politics for more than two decades. “They want delivery, not just promises. They feel they have been cheated and want to punish Congress.”
Opinion polls show the Congress party heading for its worst-ever defeat in elections dating back to 1947, when Jawaharlal Nehru, Rahul Gandhi’s great-grandfather, became India’s first prime minister after independence. Indira Gandhi, his grandmother, led the country for more than 15 years before her assassination in 1984.
The Congress-led government has seen Asia’s second-fastest inflation erode the purchasing power of some 800 million who live on less than $2 per day. The economy expanded 4.9 percent in the last financial year, close to the decade-low expansion of 4.5 percent in the previous year, according to Statistics Ministry forecasts.
India’s subsidy bill rose fivefold in the past decade under Congress rule to 2.6 trillion rupees ($43 billion) a year, a period in which the Indian economy only doubled in size. The rupee fell to a record low in August before rebounding to be one of the world’s best performers since then.
The Amethi seat -- one of 80 in Uttar Pradesh, India’s most populous state -- has been held previously by Sanjay Gandhi, Rahul’s uncle, and both of Rahul Gandhi’s parents: Rajiv Gandhi until his assassination in 1991 and Sonia Gandhi from 1999 to 2004. Rahul took over afterward, and in 2009 won re-election by a margin of about 370,000 votes.
His rivals are pushing to make it a close race this time, citing pot-holed roads, a sporadic electricity supply, lack of a good hospital and closed factories as evidence of mismanagement under the Gandhis. Both Modi and Arvind Kejriwal, leader of the upstart Aam Aadmi Party, have campaigned in Amethi in the past week and blasted the family for the poor state of development.
“They are running the government for the last 10 years, but they couldn’t develop Amethi,” Kejriwal told a rally in the constituency on May 1. “If Rahul Gandhi loses elections here, not only Amethi, but the whole country will be freed from the Gandhi family.”
‘Looting the Nation’
Modi, campaigning in Amethi two days ago, contrasted its lack of development with economic gains in Gujarat, the state he’s run since 2001, which has outpaced the national economic growth rate in 11 of the past 12 financial years for which data is available. He blasted Rahul Gandhi for a lack of toilets in Amethi’s schools.
“They go all over the nation and abuse the Gujarat model - - do they have the courage to ask what is happening in Amethi?” Modi said, referring to the Gandhi family. “In the name of the poor they are looting the nation.”
Rahul Gandhi visited Amethi today to stop by polling booths, Press Trust of India reported. He has dismissed the attacks, telling a campaign rally in Amethi last week that it’s much easier to criticize than to govern. He said that his party has improved schools and hospitals in the area, and blamed the state government and legal issues for the poor road conditions and lack of a 24-hour electricity supply.
“I came here at the age of 12 with my father,” Rahul Gandhi told a crowd of about 5,000 people in the constituency on May 3. “I don’t have a political relationship with this place - - it’s an old family relationship.”
Priyanka Gandhi Vadra, Rahul’s sister, has also invoked her family’s bond with the people of Amethi while walking through crowded marketplaces and meeting women’s groups.
“He thinks he is working to fulfill the unfinished dreams of his father,” Vadra said last week, referring to Rahul.
For some in Amethi, those emotional appeals are enough to win their votes.
“Whatever Amethi has achieved is because of the Gandhi family, and whatever identity Amethi has is also because of them,” said Ganesh Mohalla, a 65-year-old shopkeeper in the constituency.
Others like Bhanu Kumar Vishwakarama, 43, point to abandoned paper, fiber and steel factories in Amethi as a reason to vote against the Gandhis.
“Our fortunes stopped shining the day when Rajiv Gandhi was assassinated,” Vishwakarama said. “Rahul proved he can’t deliver.”
Singh, who was present in Sitkhiya village with 2,000 others in 1984 when Rajiv Gandhi pledged to build the bridge, said he plans to vote against Congress for the first time in three decades. Sudhir Kumar of neighboring Kushal ka Purwa village, which sits along the river, agrees with him.
“Building this bridge will not cost much -- only due to a lack of sincerity it’s not happening,” Kumar said. “I don’t know when and by whom it will be constructed, but our votes aren’t going to Congress.”
Yogendra Mishra, a local Congress leader in Amethi, said that while he couldn’t recall any promise made by Rajiv Gandhi to construct the bridge, “in the future we will make every effort to build it.” Even so, it’s the state government’s responsibility to build infrastructure such as roads and bridges, he said.
While Congress is campaigning on the party’s record of spending on programs ranging from cheap food to guaranteed work in rural areas, polls show the message isn’t resonating. The final round of voting will take place on May 12, with all the ballots counted four days later.
“The attitude of rural voters has changed,” said D.H. Pai Panandiker, president of the RPG Foundation, a New Delhi-based research group. “The crux of the whole thing is that Congress failed on promoting development. That is because they failed to boost economic growth.”
To contact the reporter on this story: Bibhudatta Pradhan in New Delhi at firstname.lastname@example.org
To contact the editors responsible for this story: Daniel Ten Kate at email@example.com Sunil Jagtiani