Less Microsoft Is More as Investors Eye Breakup: Real M&A
Microsoft Corp. (MSFT)’s new leadership could almost double the company’s valuation by parting with a good chunk of the businesses it uses to court consumers.
Jettisoning units such as Xbox video-game consoles and the Bing search engine may be the change Microsoft needs to rejuvenate growth as Satya Nadella takes over as chief executive officer, said Schwartz Investment Counsel Inc., which owns Microsoft shares. The world’s biggest software maker should go further by also splitting off Windows and smartphones to focus on providing services to business customers, said Stifel Financial Corp.
“They need to decide whether it still makes sense to have those assets,” said Todd Lowenstein, a Los Angeles-based fund manager at HighMark Capital Management Inc., which oversees about $17 billion including Microsoft shares. “Eighty percent of the value of Microsoft is on the enterprise side and it’s not being valued that way today. The consumer side of the business gets a disproportionate amount of attention.”
Nadella, named CEO today by Microsoft’s board, would inherit a company whose inroads in providing cloud-based enterprise software and services have been overshadowed by disappointments in tablets, smartphones and its search engine. Microsoft’s price-earnings ratio is about half the median for software makers, according to data compiled by Bloomberg, implying that the company’s valuation could almost double if it focused just on software and services.
Microsoft, which had a market value of $303 billion yesterday, has touted the benefits of having Bing as an ingredient in products like Windows and Xbox. In his final shareholder meeting in November, Steve Ballmer, the outgoing CEO, cited the new Xbox One as representing the vision the company has for a unified set of products and mentioned Bing as well.
Peter Wootton, a spokesman for Redmond, Washington-based Microsoft, declined to comment yesterday on whether the company would be open to a split.
Microsoft rose 2.7 percent on Jan. 31 -- the day after Bloomberg News reported Nadella would be promoted to CEO -- for the biggest increase in the Dow Jones Industrial Average (INDU), which fell 0.9 percent.
Investors are wagering that Nadella, a 22-year Microsoft veteran, will help concentrate the company more on the faster growing enterprise and cloud businesses that he currently runs, according to Donald Selkin, who helps manage about $3 billion including Microsoft shares as chief market strategist at National Securities Corp. in New York.
“This is the direction that investors think would be their best chance of getting their earnings back up and increasing their revenue,” Selkin said in a phone interview. Stocks of cloud-based software and services companies “have really exploded over the last year or so.”
Yesterday, Microsoft shares fell 3.6 percent to $36.48, erasing last week’s gain, as the S&P 500 slumped the most since June. Today, the stock slid 0.4 percent to $36.35 after Nadella’s appointment was announced.
Shareholders may find an insider advocate in Mason Morfit, the president of activist investing firm ValueAct Holdings LP. Morfit, who’s set to join Microsoft’s board in March, wants the company to reduce its focus on Windows and accelerate efforts to unchain products and services from the operating system, according to people familiar with the matter who asked not to be identified because the information is private.
Morfit also wants to emphasize enterprise and cloud businesses and push Microsoft to look at splitting off or scaling back hardware and consumer products such as Xbox, the people said.
Xbox, which started selling the new Xbox One console in November, may be worth about $23 billion on its own, based on Nintendo Co. (7974)’s price-sales ratio, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
Spinning off the more consumer-focused businesses together -- including Windows, phones, Xbox and the Bing Internet search service -- would boost investor returns and help focus the company on software and services for business customers, said Brad Reback, an Atlanta-based analyst at Stifel. Such a move would also keep Bing tied to many of the consumer products into which it’s integrated.
“I remain very skeptical around the device side of the business and their ability to make money and really add value to shareholders over time,” he said in a phone interview.
Reback’s suggestion would involve splitting off pieces of Microsoft that accounted for about 40 percent of the company’s $78 billion of revenue in fiscal 2013, which ended in June, data compiled by Bloomberg show.
Focusing on software and services would transform Microsoft into a company that more closely resembles its industry peers, which fetch a valuation that’s almost double Microsoft’s.
Microsoft’s price-earnings ratio yesterday of 12.8 is the second-lowest among software providers with market values exceeding $5 billion, data compiled by Bloomberg show. The group’s median is about 25.5, the data show.
“The stock is incredibly cheap,” Tim Schwartz, a fund manager at Bloomfield Hills, Michigan-based Schwartz Investment, said in a phone interview. “We’re looking for the new CEO to break from the past and take Microsoft in a new direction. We’re hopeful that the enterprise part of Microsoft becomes more of a focus.”
After a split, Microsoft may seek to buy software-as-a-service companies, such as Ultimate Software Group Inc. (ULTI) or Concur Technologies Inc. (CNQR), to bolster its enterprise applications business, said Reback of Stifel.
“At some point, I think you need to be fully in or out of that business,” known as Microsoft Dynamics, Reback said. “If they were to spin out the device business and head down a pure enterprise path, I think they would double down on that Dynamics business and look to augment what they have with acquisitions.”
Representatives for Ultimate Software, which has a market value of $4.4 billion, and $6.5 billion Concur Technologies didn’t immediately respond to requests for comment.
Even with Morfit joining the board, it may be tough to persuade Microsoft’s directors that it’s time for a breakup, Reback said. The board signed off on the purchase of Nokia Oyj’s handset business in September after Ballmer reorganized the company to accelerate development of hardware and services and announced his plans to retire as CEO.
A breakup may be wishful thinking because Nadella is being promoted from within Microsoft and because the Nokia deal showed a commitment to consumer businesses, said Schwartz, whose firm oversees $1.5 billion and owns Microsoft shares.
“I don’t think that’s going to happen,” he said. “But we’d certainly be in favor of it if it did.”
Others are concerned that Microsoft is losing corporate business as it cedes its grip on consumers, with workers bringing personal devices from Apple Inc. and Google Inc. into the office. Abandoning the market could make it worse, according to Brent Thill, an analyst at UBS AG.
“Consumer needs to be worked out,” Thill said. “The commercial business is their fastball and we don’t want them to defocus, but there is a consumerization of” information technology.
Former CEO and co-founder Bill Gates is stepping down as chairman and taking on the role of technology adviser, while remaining on the board. John Thompson, the board member who led the CEO search, becomes chairman.
Removing Gates as chairman would signal that Nadella will be free to make the changes he deems necessary, Mark Luschini, chief investment strategist at Janney Montgomery Scott LLC, said before the announcement. His firm oversees $63 billion including Microsoft shares.
“The code behind that change is to say that the new person -- in this case, if it’s Nadella -- is going to be unencumbered by the influence of a founder and ex-CEO to do what he determines is the best thing to do for Microsoft shareholders, not Microsoft, the legacy,” Luschini said in a phone interview.
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Sarah Rabil at email@example.com