PPR Investors May Sell Fnac Shares After Voting for Spinoff
Fnac, the French DVD, books and video-games chain, is seen falling after being spun off this week from PPR SA (KER) as investors who hold PPR for luxury brands such as Gucci sell stock in the retailer.
“It is often the case that the immediate reaction of shareholders receiving shares, after a spinoff of this kind, is to sell the shares,” said Luca Solca, an analyst at Exane BNP Paribas. “Hence shares tend to decline, as a first step. It is only later that the new entity finds its new natural holders.”
Fnac faces a “difficult” economic climate, particularly in France and southern Europe, Matthieu Malige, the retailer’s finance director, said in an interview yesterday. Competition from online retailers such as Amazon.com Inc. is also hurting sales. Fnac’s revenue has declined every year since 2008.
“The prospects for physical media and electronics retailers are tough,” said Solca, who rates PPR market perform.
PPR investors approved the spinoff, which sees them receive one Fnac share for every eight PPR shares they hold, at today’s annual meeting of the Paris-based company. Trading is due to start June 20.
In addition to spinning off Fnac, PPR plans to sell online and mail-order fashion retailer La Redoute this year to focus on luxury and sporting goods, which are more profitable and have better growth prospects. Talks have started with suitors, which include industrial companies and private-equity funds, PPR Chief Executive Officer Francois-Henri Pinault said today.
Shareholders also approved changing PPR’s name to Kering at today’s meeting to signal its transformation.
PPR, which trades at a discount to luxury peers because of its retail units, is seeking a valuation of about 400 million euros ($530 million) for Fnac, people with knowledge of the process have said. The price will be set after today’s meeting. Artemis Group, through which billionaire Pinault controls PPR, will retain a 38.9 percent stake and hold Fnac shares for three years, the CEO said at the meeting.
Fnac is midway through a turnaround plan to “stabilize” sales and profitability by 2016 as Europe’s debt crisis weighs on demand in the region and shopping for books, music, film, video-games and computer hardware shifts online, Malige said.
The pressure on Fnac would have been greater had PPR sold the retailer to a private-equity fund, Pinault said today, adding he is “confident” in the company’s turnaround plan. Fnac is “resisting quite well” in a difficult market, he said.
According to a prospectus for the distributor of Johnny Hallyday CDs and Samsung Galaxy S4 mobile phones, the spinoff will increase Fnac’s “visibility, build on its strengths and reinforce its competitive position.”
Still, while more aggressive pricing, new products such as children’s toys and smaller franchised stores in medium-sized cities are helping boost Fnac’s market share, the business is fighting an uphill battle, particularly against online competitors such as Amazon.com, (AMZN) according to Solca.
“Whether a national or multi-local player can win online against global players like Amazon is a big question mark,” said Solca.
Music chain Virgin France, owned by Butler Capital Partners and Lagardere SCA (MMB), has already become a casualty of online competition, digital downloading and a worsening economic climate. It filed for bankruptcy in January.
Fnac sales fell 2.4 percent to 4.1 billion euros in 2012. The retailer, founded in 1954, gets about 70 percent of revenue from France, which is mired in recession, and more than half from electronics. It had 170 stores as of Dec. 31, including in Spain, Portugal, Brazil, Belgium, Switzerland and Morocco.
The business, which had a net loss of 141.7 million euros last year, agreed to sell its Italian operations in November.
With no debt, 420 million euros of cash as of Dec. 31 and a revolving credit facility in place since last month, Fnac has the means to pursue its transformation, Malige said.
“We will continue to implement cost saving actions with the same magnitude as we have done in the past,” he said, ruling out job cuts at Paris stores in the immediate future.
After 2016, “we have the objective that Fnac realize an above 3 percent Ebit margin,” he said.
To contact the reporter on this story: Andrew Roberts in Paris at firstname.lastname@example.org
To contact the editor responsible for this story: Celeste Perri at email@example.com