Depositors Fleeing Euro Get Negative Rates at State Street
State Street Corp. (STT) and Bank of New York Mellon Corp., two of the world’s biggest custody banks, will charge depositors to hold Danish kroner and Swiss francs as customers seek refuge from the crisis-stricken euro.
State Street will apply a negative interest rate of 0.75 percent annually to krone deposits starting Nov. 1, with a separate charge for francs, according to a note to clients last week. That means money managers, insurance companies and pension funds must pay the bank to hold their cash. BNY Mellon started charging for krone deposits last month, a person with knowledge of the matter said. The lender isn’t charging for francs.
Denmark and Switzerland have cut interest rates close to or below zero to keep the krone and franc from rising as investors flee the euro for safer havens, reflecting concern that the currency may break up. While negative rates may drive off some customers, global lenders want to restore the profit margin between what they pay for deposits and what they earn on investments.
“It does look customer-unfriendly, but since State Street’s mainly dealing with institutions I would think that people would be more understanding,” said Richard Herring, a professor of international banking at the University of Pennsylvania. “The overall problem is the distortions that are caused by the monetary policies that are being pursued in the major countries.”
Royal Bank of Canada, the largest lender in that nation, also is imposing negative rates on some customers who hold kroner and francs, according to a statement from Katherine Gay, a spokeswoman for the Toronto-based company. She didn’t disclose the interest charge.
Negative rates are a symptom of Europe’s debt crisis, which has disrupted savings and lending patterns across the globe as depositors and bankers sought safety in case one or more nations stopped using the euro as their currency. Last year, banks with holdings in Greece had to take writedowns on investments in that nation as default loomed, U.S. money markets pared loans to French lenders and deposits flooded into dollar accounts at the biggest U.S. banks.
Depositors have turned to Denmark and Switzerland as they hunt for currencies with less risk than the euro, whose fate depends in part on whether cash-strapped nations such as Greece can pay their debts.
Denmark’s appeal as a haven comes from its triple-A rating, a current account surplus and a government debt load that’s less than half the euro zone’s average. Switzerland, too, is triple- A. While a strong currency enables nations to borrow at low cost, it can hurt an economy by making goods and services more expensive for foreign customers, depressing exports and tourism.
State Street plans to charge 0.25 percent for accounts in Swiss francs, the Boston-based company said in last week’s note to customers, which was obtained by Bloomberg News. The contents were confirmed by a bank spokeswoman, Carolyn Cichon.
The charges will apply only to a “small percentage” of customers whose accounts in the two currencies exceed a set minimum, according to Cichon. At current exchange rates, the threshold would be about 225,000 kroner ($39,000) or 100,000 francs ($107,000), according to a person with direct knowledge of the company’s plan.
“We doubt the news will have a lasting weakening effect on the Swiss franc, however, given that interest rates have been negative in the interbank market for months, and those who wish to hold Swiss franc deposits for safe haven reasons are unlikely to be deterred by a 25 basis-point penalty,” he wrote in an e- mailed note today.
BNY Mellon is charging “an extremely small number of clients that hold Danish kroner in their accounts,” according to Kevin Heine, a bank spokesman. Heine cited negative short- term market interest rates for the Danish krone. “This is being done to cover costs associated with maintaining these deposits, which include charges being imposed by sub-custodians and market-driven investment rates,” he said.
Heine said his company isn’t charging customers for holding Swiss francs. BNY Mellon, the world’s largest custody bank, imposed a 0.13 percent charge last year on depositors with unusually high dollar balances to help stem the influx at the New York-based firm.
The Danish central bank cut its deposit rate to negative 0.2 percent in July, and Switzerland cut its benchmark rate to near zero in September 2011. Jean-Pierre Danthine, a vice president with the Swiss central bank, said in June that it might impose negative interest rates “if the circumstances warrant it.”
Domestic lenders in Denmark have been weakened by the cut in the central bank’s deposit rate to below zero, because competition has forced most of them to keep paying customers a positive rate, Fitch Ratings said in September.
State Street executives overcame their reluctance to charge depositors after central bankers in the countries signaled that benchmark rates may stay low for an extended period, and as some competitors began to impose the charges, said two people with knowledge of the plan. The people familiar with the two U.S. custody banks requested anonymity because the decisions haven’t been discussed publicly.
While depositing customers’ money at the Danish central bank is one option, the market rate for lending money for a one- week period to other Danish banks also has turned negative, currently about minus 0.03 percent.
“The industry is experiencing unprecedented market pricing behavior in these two countries, and State Street needs to ensure we continue to provide our clients with the most efficient pricing in all of the markets where they operate,” Cichon said in an e-mailed statement.
State Street is “just reflecting where the market is,” said Herring of the University of Pennsylvania.
UBS, Switzerland’s biggest bank, in August 2011 considered levying a temporary fee on Swiss franc balances to stem flows into the customers’ cash clearing accounts. The pressure abated the next month when the Swiss National Bank cut the benchmark rate.
Interest rates have fallen below zero before. U.S. Treasury securities traded at negative yields during parts of the 1930s and 1940s, and Switzerland imposed negative interest rates in the 1970s as part of capital controls.
Still, negative rates can produce unintended consequences. That could include customers keeping large amounts of cash in vaults, taxpayers making excess prepayments in anticipation of a full refund and savers keeping cashier’s checks made out to themselves in a drawer, according to an Aug. 29 blog post by researchers at the Federal Reserve Bank of New York.