Bloodied Trader Pines for Risk as Wall Street Retreats
Sean George kneeled in the Church of St. Paul the Apostle in Manhattan. He wasn’t praying. A gash below his right brow bled into his eye and down his nose before a knee to his groin sent him to the floor.
George, 39, head of credit-derivatives trading at Jefferies Group Inc. (JEF), was making his Muay Thai debut at the church June 22 in a sport that allows kicking, elbowing and kneeing. His eye was swelling shut by the time he lost in a split decision.
It was the happiest he’s been all year, he said.
“Right now at work I’m making less risk decisions -- and I enjoy taking risks,” George, who headed investment-grade credit-default-swap trading at Deutsche Bank AG before he joined Jefferies last year, said in an interview. “If you’re in it for the game and the fight, the game’s over and the fight’s over.”
Wall Street set pay and profit records half a decade ago by wagering billions of borrowed dollars on lightly regulated products that didn’t exist a generation earlier. The excitement and rewards that swelled even after the financial system almost collapsed in 2008 have been replaced by restrictions and malaise, according to interviews with more than two dozen current and former bankers and traders.
Some, like George, are seeking their kicks in less regulated jobs. Others say they’re struggling to cope as JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM) is being investigated for trades that caused at least $5.8 billion in losses, Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS) reported the worst first half since before Lloyd C. Blankfein became chief executive officer in 2006 and Barclays Plc was fined a record 290 million pounds ($450 million) for trying to rig global interest rates.
Banks face new restrictions designed to prevent another global credit crisis. Limits on proprietary trading, or bets with firms’ own money, and rules requiring them to hold more capital make it more difficult to use borrowed funds to boost returns. As the European sovereign-debt crisis escalates and economic growth in the U.S. and China slows, clients are refraining from the deals that power Wall Street profit.
“There’s no sexiness, there’s no fun, there’s no intellectual intrigue, either,” said Ethan Garber, who ran proprietary credit-arbitrage portfolios for Credit Suisse Group AG and Bear Stearns Cos.
“A lot of my friends who actually lingered for the last four years are all now getting fired anyway,” said Garber, 45, currently CEO of IdleAir, a Knoxville, Tennessee-based firm that provides electricity at truck stops. “The air is taken out.”
Wall Street’s five largest banks -- JPMorgan, Bank of America Corp., Citigroup Inc. (C), Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley -- reported the lowest first-half revenue since 2008, and their leverage has dropped an average of 44 percent. Shares of the firms are down an average 33 percent in the past 12 months, four times as big a decline as the 81-company Standard & Poor’s 500 Financials Index. (S5FINL)
Bonuses fell by 20 percent to more than 40 percent at the major commercial and investment banks last year, compensation- consulting firm Johnson Associates Inc. said in a report.
Goldman Sachs, the most profitable firm in Wall Street history before it converted to a bank in 2008, is making less money, taking fewer risks and lowering pay. It reported that second-quarter profit dropped 11 percent as compensation in the year’s first half declined 14 percent. Value-at-risk, a measure of how much traders can lose in a day, fell to $92 million, the lowest in six years. Morgan Stanley (MS)’s $87.5 million over the past two quarters was the smallest in five years.
Risk is what drew George and the colleagues he respects to Wall Street, he said. He could bring in millions of dollars in a single month at his peak, and trading was so intense that during one credit-default-swap deal he smashed a phone against his desk, sending part of it three rows away, “one of the records for the best break,” he said.
Sam Polk, 32, who traded credit derivatives at Bank of America and the New York-based hedge fund King Street Capital Management LP, described the lure of Wall Street before he walked away in 2010.
“You could be a 20-something trader three years out of school, able to go to any restaurant or club or ballgame on any night that you wanted, and it was totally paid for,” he said. “It was a tremendous feeling of power.”
Robert McTamaney, who helped run Goldman Sachs’s equities- trading business in Asia until he left last year, likened the shift on Wall Street to a “dulling down of the colors.”
“The socks are higher, the skirts are longer,” he said. “It’s like styles: They change, and you’ve got to change with it or be left behind.”
Another former Goldman Sachs partner, Robert C. Jones, mourned the loss of the joys of experimentation in banking.
“You’re not going to be able to attract the same kind of creative people that are looking to develop innovative new strategies in an environment where innovation is frowned upon,” said Jones, 55, who helped found and lead the bank’s quantitative equity-fund-management unit before leaving in 2010. “The increasingly detailed and micromanaged regulatory environment has taken a lot of the fun out of the game.”
McWelling Todman, a professor of clinical psychology at the New School in New York, said restrictions frustrate risk-takers.
“If you’re essentially telling them to be like everybody else and to follow rules, you’re amputating a large part of who they are, who they consider themselves to be,” Todman said.
The response to curtailed risk is similar to withdrawal, according to Leo Goldberger, an emeritus psychology professor at New York University, where he studied stress.
“It would be like a drug addict not getting what he has to have,” Goldberger said.
Fabrizio Capanna quit in May as BNP Paribas SA (BNP)’s European head of retail and electronic credit trading to start JCI Capital Ltd., a privately owned financial-advisory firm in London, he said in June. He left the month that BNP Paribas, France’s largest bank, announced it had reduced its 2011 bonus pool for traders and other risk-related employees by 52 percent as Europe’s debt crisis threatened revenue.
“The reason I am leaving the banking sector is that it changed drastically,” said Capanna, 48. “Less motivating in terms of remuneration, less challenging in terms of risk-taking, heavier from a bureaucratic point of view.”
Michael Meyer, a former head of global investment-grade sales and trading at Bank of America who left in 2007, said he doesn’t see life at the big banks “getting better anytime soon.” The Charlotte, North Carolina-based lender announced July 18 it would trim $3 billion from annual expenses in investment banking, trading and wealth management, in addition to the 30,000 jobs in other units already targeted for cuts.
“The light at the end of the tunnel is dim,” said Meyer, now co-head of sales and trading at New York investment bank Seaport Group.
Citigroup, the third-largest U.S. bank, said in January it’s cutting about 5,000 workers as clients take fewer risks and the firm adjusts to new trading regulations.
“Working at those large places can be a lot less fun these days, how it feels day in day out,” said Herald “Hal” Ritch, CEO of Sagent Advisors LLC, a New York-based investment bank. “It grinds on people and wears them down psychologically.”
Ritch, 61, said the downturn is worse than anything he has seen since starting work in 1975 at firms including Citigroup, Kidder Peabody & Co. and Donaldson, Lufkin & Jenrette.
“I understand their frustration, but we can’t go back to a world of vast risk-taking,” said Eugene N. White, an economics professor at Rutgers University in New Brunswick, New Jersey. “You have individuals who take risks and get the private gains, whereas if their gamble fails the cost is socialized.”
Neil M. Barofsky, the former special inspector general in charge of overseeing the Troubled Asset Relief Program, whose book “Bailout” was published this month, said that bankers sometimes confuse what’s best for them with what’s best for others. Limiting outsized risk and pay on Wall Street “would unquestionably be a very good thing for the country,” he said.
Even as compensation costs have declined at Goldman Sachs, the firm paid each employee an average of $225,789 for the first six months, five times what a starting New York City firefighter would make in a full year. U.S. unemployment has been stuck above 8 percent for 41 consecutive months.
For George, the Muay Thai fighter, fulfillment is less about the money than the excitement.
“People are sad,” he said of his colleagues on Wall Street. “They don’t have any risk. There is nothing to be stressed about. The upside is you get paid a little more than your base. The downside is, you’re fired.”
George, who said he had his best month of the year in May, praised firms such as New York-based Jefferies that are less regulated than the biggest banks. Even so, he said, Wall Street is “not the same industry that drew me in.”
“I’m excited about that,” he said.
To contact the editor responsible for this story: David Scheer at firstname.lastname@example.org