Recovery of Commercial Property Fueled by Apartments: Mortgages
When Arenda Capital Management LLC bought an Atlanta apartment complex whose owners defaulted on a $26 million loan, they did something distressed investors rarely do: They paid full price, deciding not to wait for lender LNR Partners to foreclose and face competition from other acquirers.
“If I don’t buy the deal, then it may be 12 to 24 months before I’d have another chance to buy it, and they still may not be selling unless I make them whole,” said Ryan Millsap, managing principal at Los Angeles-based Arenda, which bought the 592-unit property in October.
Demand for U.S. apartment buildings is surging as the homeownership rate hovers near the lowest level since 1998 and government-supported mortgage companies provide record levels of financing for apartment properties. That’s fueling a rush by investors to buy buildings and helping lenders recover 75 percent of the value of defaulted mortgages tied to multifamily housing, the highest recovery rate on all commercial property.
Sales of U.S. apartment properties totaled $3.8 billion in January, a 53 percent increase from the same month a year earlier, the strongest start to the year compared with offices, and shopping centers, according to Real Capital Analytics Inc., a New York-based commercial property data firm.
Fannie, Freddie Loans
The dollar volume of multifamily loan originations by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac hit an all-time high in the fourth quarter, according to a Mortgage Bankers Association index that has tracked the data for 11 years. The government-supported entities increased lending by selling $33.9 billion of bonds tied to apartment buildings last year, from $21.6 billion in 2010, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
For Millsap, paying full price to acquire Atlanta’s Arbors at Winters Chapel before foreclosure seemed like a pretty safe bet, he said.
“Multifamily was not hit hard from an operating standpoint,” Millsap said. “Everybody overpaid -- but there was nothing wrong with the actual properties and today’s market recognizes that. The property itself doesn’t know the difference -- it just keeps operating.”
When the complex was appraised in March, 2006, it was valued at $39 million. The original loan matured last May and went into default because the borrower was unable to refinance, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
Little Capital Risk
Millsap’s firm got a loan from Freddie Mac at a 4.5 percent interest rate. The capitalization rate, a measure of investment yield on the property, is about 7.8 percent, by Millsap’s estimates. “That puts me in a position where I don’t feel like I have a lot of capital risk,” Millsap said.
“Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae originate a huge portion of the loans out there for apartments,” said Ben Carlos Thypin, director of market analysis for Real Capital Analytics Inc. “If a buyer can secure cheap financing, whether from a government sponsored entity or elsewhere, that allows them to be able to pay more for a property.”
The interest rate for a 10-year fixed multifamily loan designated for purchase by Fannie and Freddie was 4.1 percent, as of March 2, according to New York real estate investment banking firm Cushman & Wakefield Sonnenblick Goldman. The rate is for a loan that covers up to 80 percent of the asset value.
Life insurance companies and commercial banks are also competing to lend in the relatively stable apartment market, offering mortgages for shorter durations and for “transitional” properties that are not fully occupied, said Bert Crouch, director of acquisitions for structured investments at Dallas-based Invesco Real Estate.
“You’re seeing interest rates fall and a very stable and aggressive lending environment, and you’ve got a supply constrained world,” Crouch said.
Rents in the U.S. climbed 4.1 percent in the 12 months through December, according to Axiometrics Inc. Apartment owners are projected to see their rental revenue increase by 6.7 percent this year, as little new supply comes to market.
For all of 2011, 37,678 new apartment units were completed, the lowest annual total in 31 years of data compiled by New York-based Reis Inc.
While Invesco’s real estate holdings are “overweight” on multifamily properties, the firm hasn’t found the kinds of deals it had hoped for when dealing with lenders disposing of troubled apartment loans.
‘Difficult to Find’
“On the distressed side it’s been very difficult to find the quality of product that we’re comfortable with and at the same time get a meaningful discount,” Crouch said. “We have not been nearly as productive in that area as we would have wanted.”
In major metropolitan areas, where institutional apartment investors such as REITs and pension funds have concentrated their acquisitions, recovery rates for liquidated apartment loans have come close to 100 percent of the outstanding debt, according to Real Capital. In Manhattan, apartment lenders disposing of bad loans recouped 88 percent of the debt in the second half of 2011. Lenders for properties in San Francisco and Los Angeles have been able to recover about 86 and 85 percent respectively.
The biggest losses were for states where high volumes of foreclosed single-family homes are competing with apartment buildings for renters. Lenders for apartment properties in Las Vegas and Miami recovered 59 percent of their debt in the second half of last year.
Acquiring notes on distressed multifamily loans makes sense in most markets, which isn’t the case for loans backing retail and office, said Matthew Schwab, managing director and co- founder of Los Angeles-based Karlin Real Estate. The investment firm bought the note and in June foreclosed on the 200-unit Vista Verde apartment complex in Orlando.
The main source of distress in the apartment market is the overleveraged owners, who borrowed at the peak of the market on rosy assumptions of rent growth, and then couldn’t repay their debt once rents plummeted in 2009, he said. Once that old debt is cleared, new loans can easily be supported by tenant demand, he said.
“If you told me about an office building in Orlando, now you’ve got to really study the office vacancy rates in that market,” Schwab said. “Retail, even if you get to the asset, you still have a challenge to lease up. With multifamily, once you get to that asset, the cash flow will be much more predictable.”
Mortgage Bankers Data
In 2011, banks and thrifts charged off less than one percent of their balance of multifamily mortgages, compared with a 1.55 percent charge-off rate for their total portfolio of loans and leases, the Mortgage Bankers Association said in a report today. In all years since 2007, banks charged off $7.8 billion in multifamily mortgages, the lowest dollar volume of charge-offs of any other type of loan. Commercial mortgages for properties other than apartments had $35.1 billion in charge- offs since 2007, the Mortgage Bankers said.
Banks liquidating debt from retail properties recovered 61 percent of what they were owed in the second half of 2011, Real Capital said. Defaulted office property loans mustered a 68 percent recovery rate. Industrials recovered 73 percent.
Apartment vacancy rates, now at a decade-low of 5.2 percent, never fell below 8 percent, even during the lowest point of the commercial property rout, according to data from Reis Inc. The office vacancy rate was 17.3 percent in the fourth quarter, while vacancies at shopping centers average 11 percent in the fourth quarter, unchanged from the previous three quarters.
“It’s a lot easier to hang your hat on something that’s experiencing good fundamentals where values are being supported than if somebody handed you a retail building that sits 60 or 70 percent occupied,” said Ryan Severino, senior economist at Reis.
To contact the reporter on this story: Oshrat Carmiel in New York at firstname.lastname@example.org.