Toyota Ends Go-It-Alone Strategy With BMW, Tesla Alliances: Cars
Toyoda agreed this month to equip some Toyota cars with Bayerische Motoren Werke AG diesel engines, building on an earlier deal to use Tesla Motors Inc. (TSLA) battery packs in future electric vehicles. Before the grandson of the founder became president, Toyota had not purchased such core technologies from other carmakers, said Shiori Hashimoto, a spokeswoman at the Toyota City-based carmaker.
The alliances illustrate how Toyoda is shaking up decades- old practices at Japan’s largest manufacturer, which is poised to cede its three-year lead in the global automotive industry to General Motors Co. (GM) As the company emerges from three years of crisis management -- from millions of vehicles recalled to coping with Japan’s biggest postwar natural disaster -- Toyoda now faces the challenge of recovering ground lost to GM and Hyundai Motor Co. (005380)
“They have a high need for control, because they want a high level of confidence things will be delivered on time,” said Jeff Liker, an engineering professor at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor specializing in Toyota research. “When you go outside the family, there’s some risk. Akio is willing to take that risk.”
The worldwide recalls in 2009 and 2010 created an opportunity to push changes in Toyota’s corporate culture, Liker said. The CEO likely “came to the conclusion Toyota has grown too insular in Japan, that it needed to open up more, get more access to the outside world,” he said.
Toyoda has reason to drive change. The company forecasts profit will fall to 1 percent of revenue this fiscal year, Toyota’s second-lowest margin, based on data compiled by Bloomberg stretching back to 1992.
At its height, when Fujio Cho and Katsuaki Watanabe were running Toyota in the mid 2000s, the carmaker was generating margins of almost 7 percent. The stock is down about 70 percent from its peak in February 2007.
“Toyota used to be able to grow simply by manufacturing the cars it made best, but now it needs to make gasoline and diesel cars, hybrids and electric vehicles,” said Mitsushige Akino, who oversees about $600 million at Ichiyoshi Investment Management Co. in Tokyo. “If Toyota doesn’t reach out to other companies for help in technology, they won’t be able to sustain market share.”
Lagging in Europe
Under this month’s agreement, Toyota will equip some of its European models with BMW engines starting in 2014 to gain market share in the region, where most cars run on diesel.
Toyota’s share of European auto sales was 3.8 percent this year through October, according to the European Automobile Manufacturers’ Association. By comparison, Toyota’s U.S. share was 12.7 percent through November, according to Autodata Corp., based in Woodcliff Lake, New Jersey.
In May 2010, Toyota agreed to use Tesla’s lithium-ion battery pack and motor on its RAV4 sport-utility vehicle starting early next year. Toyoda said at the time that he hoped the partnership would also inspire Toyota workers to adopt the “venture business” spirit of Tesla.
The BMW and Tesla deals differ from previous partnerships because Toyota is the recipient of another company’s technology, Hashimoto, the Toyota spokeswoman, said. In previous deals such as a project to develop a hybrid system for trucks with Ford Motor Co. (F), and others with GM, Aston Martin and Fuji Heavy Industries Ltd. (7270)’s Subaru, Toyota either provided or co-developed technologies, she said.
The new push for alliances may fall short of turning around Toyota.
Only the BMW accord is likely to yield direct benefits for the Japanese carmaker because the other agreements are “small, isolated deals,” said Maryann Keller, an auto analyst and president at Maryann Keller & Associates.
The project with Palo Alto, California-based Tesla, for example, isn’t likely to change Toyota’s management practices because “you cannot change a corporate culture simply by working with a company that’s 3,000 miles away,” she said.
Even the BMW deal isn’t a guaranteed success, Akino said.
“Why would Toyota’s partners provide them with the best technology?” he said. “In partnering with other companies, Toyota is putting its reputation as a company of quality, ‘made- in-Japan’ products at risk.”
Toyota generally resisted an industrywide wave of equity tie-ups that began in the 1990s, including the alliance between Nissan Motor (7201) Co. and Renault SA; Daimler AG (DAI)’s acquisitions of Chrysler Corp. and a stake in Mitsubishi Motors Corp. (7211); and the pre-bankruptcy General Motors Corp.’s purchase of Korea’s Daewoo Motor Co. and interests in Fiat SpA (F), Isuzu Motors Ltd. (7202), Suzuki Motor Corp. (7269) and Fuji Heavy.
In 1999, Toyota and GM announced plans to share research on hybrid vehicles and hydrogen fuel-cell technology. That agreement yielded no results. While Toyota also supplied hybrid components to Nissan for its gasoline-electric Altima sedan, the companies didn’t expand that arrangement beyond a limited supply deal.
Toyota’s go-it-alone strategy worked through the most of the 2000s, with earnings (7203) reaching 1.72 trillion yen ($22 billion) in the fiscal year ended March 2008, before Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc.’s bankruptcy exacerbated a global recession.
The alliances support the executive’s goal of giving Toyota vehicles more driving performance and character, said Ed Kim, an analyst for industry researcher AutoPacific Inc. in Tustin, California.
“Akio is a motorsports enthusiast -- his brain is definitely wired that way,” Kim said. “It’s a good thing for Toyota to have someone at the helm who is passionate about vehicles, given the criticism the company gets for vehicles lacking character or soul.”
For some investors, the partnerships are key.
“Partnerships all seem very necessary,” said Edwin Merner, president of Atlantis Investment Research Corp. “Toyota, under the new president, realized that they need to cooperate if they are going to survive and they must get help from companies where they are weak.”